Robert Geswell
Mr. Milton
Honors World History
March 23, 2023
Why the claim that the Armenian Genocide was a result of the Armenian’s support for Russia during World War 1 is false.
What was the most well-known and horrific genocide to take place during World War One? That was the Armenian Genocide committed against the Armenian people by the Turks of the Ottoman Empire. This resulted in the deaths of almost one and a half million Armenians and the displacement and deportation of countless Armenians. The series of events took place during World War 1. The Armenians gave aid and support to Russia during the World War. The support given included several factors such as; humanitarian relief, intelligence, and communications. Some would claim
…show more content…
This event resulted in the deaths of over one and a half million Armenians and the deportation and displacement of estimated millions of Armenians. This horrific series of events was most vastly due to the intolerance of the Ottoman Empire looking to Turkify the region. There was a peak of the murders of the race within the years 1915-1917. The quickest and simplest explanation as to what the Armenian Genocide was is, “The Armenian Genocide is the name given to a murderous campaign conducted by the Ottoman Empire during the early 20th century.” The tragic event is often compared to the horrific extermination of Jewish people throughout Europe in the 1940s which was the Holocaust by Adolf Hitler. The Armenian Genocide is the second most commonly known genocide in the world second only to the Holocaust. The Armenian Genocide took place during World War 1 (WWI). This event is also known as one of the most controversial issues in world history. Some countries such as Turkey still refuse to recognize the event similar to other countries responsible for genocides and events throughout …show more content…
However, while yes the Armenians did in fact support Russia during the war the real reason for the Genocide was that the Ottoman Empire wanted to Turkify the region of the world. Turkification was based on the Turkish nationalism held by the Ottomans. A large driving factor of nationalism was to convert the Armenians to Islam as they were, however, Armenians were devoted to
“Genocide begins, however improbably, in the conviction that classes of biological distinction indisputably sanction social and political discrimination” (Dworkin). Genocides are mass killings of people, targeted and purposefully killed because of their faith or what nation they represent. In other words, large amounts of people were killed because of discrimination and hatred that turns violent and destructive. Innocent people are dying in genocides by others who are unforgiving and merciless or have a weak mentality. A couple notable genocides that have occurred throughout history is the Holocaust and the Armenian Genocide.
There have been many more genocides that many people do not know have occurred or are still taking place to this day. One of them being in 2003, the Darfur genocide. The government of Sudan responded to a rebellion by civilians and this resulted in the deaths of over 300,000 when he began a genocide. This genocide is still occurring to this day. It was declared a genocide by the United States Secretary of State Colin Powell on 9 September 2004 and no genocidal policy has been pursued and implemented in Darfur by the Government authorities.
In document 2 the Turkish Minister said that “however criminal the measures may be'' they must kill all Armenians living in the Ottoman Empire. He even admits that the government had decided to destroy all Armenians .The fact that a Turkish Minister is saying this only strengthens the idea that this genocide was backed by the government and that it wasnt a civil war. Since the government has both influence on its citizens and control of the law, they can easily make what they are doing seem socially acceptable. Next in the document Adolf Hitler says, “After all, who remembers today the extermination of the Armenians?”.
The second key point is Propaganda, Propaganda is the spreading of political ideas, information in a way. The last key point is the Inhumane Outcome, the inhumane outcome is cruel and heartless. The genocide in Armenian was similar to the Holocaust because the oppressors used tactics of dehumanization and successful propaganda; both of which led to the inhumane outcome of each genocide.
They were murdered in either massacre and individual killings, or from systematic ill-treatment, exposure, and starvation. In the novel Forgotten Fire, the main social issue, the Armenian Genocide, compares to the Holocaust as they both were caused by a hatred of a specific race, they both resulted in extreme violence and immense casualties, and they both had many heroes who made considerable sacrifices on behalf of those being persecuted. The Holocaust and the Armenian Genocide were sparked by the hatred of a specific minority race, the Jews, and the Armenians. The leaders of the countries involved in genocides often promoted them and contribute to the heinous crimes.
Many men were executed. Women were raped. People were even put into gas chambers. Some were put into caves or churches and burned alive (Atamian, pg 23-26). Still to this day, the Turkish government denies that the Armenian Genocide ever occurred.
The main definition of Genocide is known as the intentional destruction of an entire human group based on national, racial, religious, or ethnic identity. There have been many genocides that never make it to the news, and many countries in a position to help have turned away. But the problem of genocide can be resolved by addressing the problem, making international laws, taking military action, and ending stereotypes. The easiest way for everyone around the world to stop or help in ending genocide is to address the problem of genocide itself and spread the word around.
For example, during World War I, the Turkish nationalist government oversaw the deportation and killing of an estimated 1.1 to 1.8 million “to put an end to the Armenian question. The means for this are quite simple and consist of the extermination of the Armenian nation” (“Past Genocide”). Armenians in Eastern Turkey. April 24, 1915 was the beginning of the Armenian Genocide. Armenians were deported from cities and towns in Asia Minor and Turkish Armenia.
Rahul Mone Mrs. Marsden ELA Honors I 4 February, 2016 The Cambodian Genocide The genocides of Cambodia and the Holocaust were two major genocides that have changed the history of the world forever. The Cambodian genocide started when the Khmer Rouge attempted to nationalize and centralize the peasant farming society of Cambodia (Quinn 63).
A genocide is the the deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially those of a particular ethnic group or nation, the Holocaust and the Cambodian Genocide are examples of this. After the Holocaust, in 1945 the United Nations realized that genocides were a continuously happening. They realized they needed to prevent genocides and global conflict in general. The Holocaust began on January 30, 1933 when Adolf Hitler became chancellor of Germany and ended May 8, 1945 when the war officially ended.
The Armenian Genocide occurred during the First World War when the Ottoman Empire was experiences the pressures of war from the Triple Entente. In 1915, the ANZAC forces had landed in Gallipoli and the Russian forces were advancing down from the Caucasian fields. During this time, the Ottoman Empire displaced and forced millions of Christian minorities to march through the desert. Historically, it had been Muslims who victims of violence in the area. However, Christian minorities were in a vulnerable position due to the decline of the Ottoman Empire and impending revolutionary violence (Jones 155).
To start off, both the Armenians and the Jews were dehumanized and thought of as an inferior race. They were looked down upon and treated like animals. The people who were against the Jews and the Armenians did not care what happened to them. Most of the time they would either be worked to death or murdered. Albert Ward talked about how the Armenians were mistreated in his book, Critical World Issues: Genocide.
The Holocaust v. Armenian Genocide Genocide is defined as “the deliberate killing of a large group of people, especially those of a particular ethnic group or nation” (Dictionary.com). Genocide has eight stages:classification, symbolization, dehumanization, organization, polarization, preparation, extermination, and denial. Genocide has taken place many times throughout history. Two prominent genocides are that of the Armenians and that of the Jews and other minority groups during the Holocaust. There are considerable resemblances between the Armenian genocide and the Holocaust, especially in the nature of the genocides, a skewed view of the group persecuted by the governing group, and the ‘purposes’ behind both, but these mass killings
Genocide is the act of mass murdering groups of people because of someone 's disliking. In other words getting rid of people or stop their existence,mostly because of their religion, ethnic, or race. One of the most atrocious ones was the Armenian Genocide(April 24,1915-1916), in which 1.5 million of the Armenian population, living in the Ottoman Empire were either deported or killed. During this time,the Turkish government had planned the genocide to get rid of the entire Armenian population in the Ottoman Empire(which was one of the largest empires to rule on the border of the Mediterranean Sea) because they feared that the Armenian community would join their enemy troops during WWI in 1915.
There were an estimated 200,000 people who were killed between 1992-1995 in a genocide commited by the Serbs against the Muslims, and Croats in Bosnia. On top of this, another 2 million Bosnians were displaced from their homes and placed in dangerous environments. Three main groups fought each other within the country, Bosnian Muslims, Serbs, and also the Croats. This was a horrible and important genocide that killed thousands of people between 1992-1995. Like the Nazi’s cleansing Europe of it’s Jews, the Serbs aim was the ethnic cleansing of any Muslims or Croatian presence in Serbian territory.