ipl-logo

Ashcroft V. Free Speech Coalition Case Study

547 Words3 Pages

Citation: Ashcroft v. Free Speech Coalition
535 U.S. 234 (2002)
U.S. Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit
Facts: The Free Speech Coalition which is a non-profit trade association of the pornography and adult entertainment industry in the United States filed suit, against the Child Pornography Prevention Act of 1996 (CPPA). The child pornography prevention act prohibits and sets penalties for activities such as depicting any visual image of the sexual abuse of minors. This includes pictures, video, and even modified images with the likeness or appearance of a minor engaging in a sexual act. The Promotion, advertisement, and distribution of such works are also prohibited and have consequences. The Free Speech Coalition claims that these prohibitions are overbroad and vague and, …show more content…

The Court held the CPPA prohibitions to be too broad and in violation of the constitutional freedoms. The judgment from district court was reversed.
Explanation:
The Justices found the ban on certain images to be to broad and therefore sided in favor of the Free Coalition.
A. Rule: The Child Pornography Protection Act 1996 (CPPA) due to the advancement in technology prohibits and penalizes not only child porn but anything in its likeliness such as computerized images or young adults portraying minors. The Government submits that virtual child pornography whets the appetites of pedophiles and encourages them to engage in illegal conduct. The government also submits that it aids in the development and spread of child pornography. The court accepts these interests, but rejects the governments argument: 1. There is counterweights to the governments argument: a. The mere tendency to encourage unlawful acts is not a sufficient enough reason for banning

Show More
Related

  • Poultry Corporation V. US Schechter Brothers Case Brief Summary

    558 Words  | 3 Pages

    Ava. Baghaevaji 1) Name of the Case: Schechter Poultry Corporation v. United States 295 U.S. 495, 55 S. CT. 837 (1935) 2) Facts of the Case: The Schechter brothers ran a slaughterhouse in New York City which would kill and supply chickens to local stores. The brothers were convicted and tried by a federal district for violating standards set by the National Recovery Administration.

    Read More

  • Packingham V. North Carolina First Amendment Case Study

    182 Words  | 1 Pages

    The United States Supreme Court in the Packingham v. North Carolina first amendment case has ruled in favor of Lester Gerard Packingham. The state from now on may not bar social media access to registered sex offenders. The case’s build up dates back to 2002 when 21 year old college student Lester G. Packingham had a sexual relationship with a 13-year-old girl. For involvement with a minor he received a 10-12 month sentence, but having never met problems with the law, the judge required him to go on a 24 month probation and register as a sex offender. Five years had passed and in 2008 North Carolina forbid any person on the sex offender list to use any type of social media.

    Read More

  • Megan's Law Policy Analysis

    1758 Words  | 8 Pages

    Policy Analysis: Megan’s Law Sexual violence, particularly against children, is a significant issue all around the world. In the early 1990’s in the United States, there were multiple well-publicized cases of sexual violence against children. From kidnappings, to rapes, and everything in between, violence was being committed against children and something needed to be done about it. In 1996, Megan’s Law was passed in response to the sexual assault and death of Megan Kanka, a seven-year-old from New Jersey (Corrigan, 2006).

    Read More

  • Who Killed The Constitution By Thomas E. And Kevin R. Gutzman

    1457 Words  | 6 Pages

    Congress’s power to limit freedom of speech in any way is not included in the enumerated powers listed in Article I, Section 8 of the Constitution (20-21). The states, if anyone, are the only governments that might posses the power to limit free speech (21). Government officials, however, obviously have no regard for the Constitution or freedom of speech and are acting upon their own desires and values (21). Many examples of freedom of speech infringement are given throughout this book, and the author shows how these kinds of laws are enacted throughout history.

    Read More

  • Attorney General Ashcroft Case Study

    495 Words  | 2 Pages

    Attorney General Ashcroft does not have the legal right to threaten physicians with revoking their license since, only seven years before Oregon passed the Act which allowed to assist their patients in death. Some may believe that the Attorney General took his personal and moral opinion to work, where he could change law to his preference. The District court agreed with the statement above, therefore, they concluded that Attorney General Ashcroft did not have the authority to override a state 's decision regarding what is or is not a "legitimate medical practice" and that Ashcroft exceeded his authority under the CSA. In July 2005, Oregon v. Ashcroft changes to Gonzales v. Oregon.

    Read More

  • Bush V. Gore Case Study

    781 Words  | 4 Pages

    Bush v. Gore was a Supreme Court case that occurred in 2000 after the presidential election between George W. Bush and Al Gore. After Florida citizens casted their votes, officials noticed the numbers were very close; Bush led Gore by only about 1,800 votes. Florida law allowed Gore the option of manual recount in the Florida counties of his choice. He chose to have votes of four counties recounted. Florida law also required that the state’s election be certified by the Secretary of State, Katherine Harris, within 7 days of the election (November 14th, 2000).

    Read More

  • First Amendment Rights: The Westboro Baptist Church

    355 Words  | 2 Pages

    First Amendment rights are guaranteed to all American citizens, but current free speech issues are testing Constitutional boundaries. Where must the line be drawn between free speech and infringement upon others’ rights? Is there some speech so cruel and so appalling that it does not merit protection? These issues have been raised by the recent activities of the Westboro Baptist Church. Based out of Topeka, Kansas[1], this small group of radicals is marked by their hateful views and their contempt for homosexuality. The Westboro Baptist Church has gained notoriety and sparked national outrage with their offensive acts, particularly by protesting the funerals of fallen soldiers.

    Read More

  • Summary: The Coddling Of The American Mind

    993 Words  | 4 Pages

    Where this fits in this conversation is on the side of supporting censorship on the grounds that the parent censors what ever the parent sees fit. However, the article minimally discusses how responsible the parents will be when they censor what their kids will see and hear as well as how they will treat sudden exposure to ideas and images. The writer, here, is on the side of the common, fearful parent who wants to help other parents censor their kids. Unfortunately, this article does not discuss the treatment of censorship when kids are exposed to what the world has. Article 2 Discussion () Even though this article is on the side of pushing for censorship without questioning it’s effects, this article paints the perspective of the reason why censorship exist in the first place; to make sure ideas that are nuanced, very descriptive, and depicts a portion real life through the eyes of mature human beings.

    Read More

  • Essay On First Amendment In Schools

    869 Words  | 4 Pages

    In which Fraser gave an inappropriate speech which contained perverted and inferred sexual words in his speech to try an get one of his friends into office, but got suspended and was no longer allowed to speak at graduation. According to document E it says “Bethel school district acted within its permissible authority in imposing sanctions on Fraser after his inappropriate speech”. This quote shows students are limited to what they can say and can't really speak their minds without restrictions therefore this shows that this case restricts the 1st amendment rights of students even though the U.S promotes freedom of speech but nevertheless there are others way to speak without using indecent words and also it was within a place of learning. The court was right to decide in favor of the school because “A high school assembly or classroom is no place for a sexuality explict monologue.(Doc. E)”it was well within parameters of the school to punish him for using obscene and indecent speech at a school event as mentioned in document E earlier “The first Amendment does not prevent the schools officials from determining them to permit a vulgar and lewd speech such as the respondent's would undermine the school’s basic educational

    Read More

  • First Amendment Free Speech Analysis

    651 Words  | 3 Pages

    The primary step in First Amendment free speech analysis is to determine whether the statute is conduct based or content neutral, and then apply the proper level of scrutiny.(Burson v. Freeman, 504 USC 191, 197-198). The limitation of sex offenders’ ability to access certain commercial social networking sites is content neutral. There may be certain times that where the government’s regulation has an incidental affect on expression. A regulation that serves purposes unrelated to the content of expression is content neutral, even if it has an incidental effect on some speakers or messages. (Renton v. Playtime Theatres, Inc., 475 U.S. 41, 47-48 (1986).)

    Read More

  • First Amendment Case Study

    698 Words  | 3 Pages

    The first amendment, which protects amongst other things our freedom of speech, is tantamount in “preventing the majority from imposing its views on [the minority]” (481). However, in this famous case the will of the majority, the Boy Scout of America leaders, leading to the exclusion of the minority, James Dale, from based on his openness about his sexual orientation which conflicted with the beliefs of the scouts at the time. Despite the fact that he was free to speak about his orientation with newspapers and whomever he wishes in general, the ideas were seen by the Scouts as an affront on their “morally straight” requirements which is also protected under the first amendment. This raises two integral questions about the nature of our fundamental

    Read More

  • First Amendment Essay

    1326 Words  | 6 Pages

    The legality of these orders was challenged in court, with courts ultimately blocking the ban from going into effect. These debates highlight the ongoing tension between free speech and regulation, particularly in the context of new and emerging technologies. While the First Amendment provides protections for freedom of expression, the challenges posed by social media and other online platforms raise important questions about how to ensure that these protections remain relevant in a changing media

    Read More

  • Freedom Of Speech: The RAV V. St. Paul Case

    764 Words  | 4 Pages

    Everyone loves having the ability to voice their opinions without restrictions. This right is called Freedom of Speech, taking this away from Americans would be the equivalent to causing WWIII. People often use this right to defend themselves when stating opinions However, how long does it take before Freedom of Speech simply becomes Hate Speech? Written in 1789 the Bill of Rights contains about 27 Amendments, these were soon ratified down into the 10 Amendments we’re familiar with today. Amongst these amendments is the 1st amendment, which grants us some of our most important rights as humans.

    Read More

  • Censorship Of The First Amendment Essay

    865 Words  | 4 Pages

    One of these cases is Patterson V. Colorado. Patterson published comics and articles about the Colorado Supreme Court. These comics criticized the judges of that court, and questioned many of their motives. Afterwards, Patterson was charged with contempt. He quickly moved to void the information by citing local law, the Colorado Constitution, and the Fourteenth Amendment of the constitution.

    Read More

  • Freedom Of Speech In College Essay

    905 Words  | 4 Pages

    The idea of free speech on college campuses and the complications of it stem from those on campuses expressing views that don’t align with popular views. Implications for students who use the idea of free speech as a method for hateful actions and comments should be reprimanded, but the question remains as to whether schools should enforce tougher limitations. The freedom of speech on college campus expands to the freedoms of religion, assembly, press, and protest as well. Freedom of expression allows students to show their own political, social, and cultural views. Removing freedoms of speech and expression have consequences deeper than surface issues.

    Read More

More about Ashcroft V. Free Speech Coalition Case Study

Open Document