The Giver Compare/Contrast Essay When some people hear the words ‘perfect society’ what do they think of? Take a look at our society, then take a look at Jonas’s society, between our two societies there are some comparisons and a vast amount of differences. For instance, the rules are different, as well as their family units and their individuality.While our society is more on the modern side, Jonas’s society is plainer. When it comes to the rules in our society, we don’t normally think of rules that are very extreme. For instance, in The Giver, if someone made three mistakes they would be released. “The rules say that if there’s a third transgression, he simply has to be released”(Lowry 9).In our society, if we made three mistakes, we would probably get in some type of trouble, but we would more than likely not be sentenced to death.Even our school systems work differently than theirs. “The classes were the same: language and communications; commerce and industry; science and technology; civil procedures and government.But during the breaks for recreation periods and the midday meal, the other new twelves were abuzz with descriptions of their first day of training”(Lowry 89). This was an example of how they do not change their classes until their training begins. There was another rule for when someone disrupted their class, that they would have to deliver an apology phrase to their class, and then the class had to say that they accepted their apology.For example, Asher
Pale Eyes When daily life is controlled, it is possible some people wouldn’t have the ability to see color and most parents wouldn’t love their children just due to the fact that it was not the way they were “programmed”. It may get a little frustrating after awhile... if someone even noticed that something was off. In the science fiction novel The Giver by Lois Lowry, there is a twelve-year-old boy named Jonas. He is named the new Receiver which is a very respected and high-end job in his community. This job also introduces him to a man that he calls the Giver.
The novels Code Talker and The Giver contain main characters that have a share in their similarities and differences. At a glance we see the characters as different in every way possible, but when you look deeper and think harder you start to notice that they are similar. Jonas from The Giver stands out among the dark eyed people because of his light eyes, and Ned Begay from Code Talker stands out because of his heritage. Learning to be different shows the readers that being original is good, but being unique is outstanding.
Weather it comes to saying “hi” to an employee when you walk into a store,close the door behind you when you walk out of a room, or even simply washing your hands after using the restroom, society, stereotypes, and the media can mold and shift your ideas, morals, and opinions rapidly. For example in the novel “The Giver”it illustrates that Jonas the protagonist lives in this somewhat “perfect” community where there are no mistakes (tolerated) and no emotion other than happiness. However, one may disagree and say “social norms help us and teach us new things”. In reality the “teaching” could be something bad but no one would know because they are already blinded by their previous words and are clueless. In Jonas's Community they live in
Jonas’s society is extremely different than the one we live in today. The first difference between The Giver and our society is the number of family members. In the book they can only have two kids, one boy and one girl; however, in America we are free to have as many kids as we would want. The second
Many people have different meanings of perfect. In The Giver society they want everything to be perfect and that 's where there differences apply. There is no individuality between the people in this society. In The Giver’s society the people are being watched for mistakes and perfection so the society looks perfect. The society is very strict on what people do and how they do it.
In The Giver, Lois Lowry shows her readers what it is like to live in a society with no diversity, no color, and no freedom. In this society, there is a twelve-year old boy, named Jonas, who finds the truth about life outside of his community. He does not have the option of choice, and he is stuck in a futuristic world of “sameness”. Jonas’ world is dull, and he wants to change it because it does not have the amazing features and opportunities that he learns about. In this story, Lois Lowry is warning her readers that too much conformity can lead to no freedom and no true happiness.
The giver by Lois Lowry- Analytical essay ________________________________________________________ What if we lived in a world of peace and equality? What if we lived in a world with no differences? A world with no social classes and inequality. That sounds pretty amazing doesn’t it?
In the Giver people are not allowed to make decisions, the author does this to comment on our worry of mistakes. In Jonas's society people are not given choice in their life the Giver said this is because, “‘He might make wrong choices.’” (Lowry, 98). In the community
Finally, the two societies also differ in the way gifts are given. Presents or privileges are pre-selected by age in Jonas’s society. For instance, Ones receive names and family units, Nines receive bicycles, and Twelves receive job assignments. On the other hand, in modern society, people are given presents based upon their personal interests.
Stop, think about this for a moment. You are in a community that cannot see color, has no feelings, no choices to be made on your own, and no diversity between each other. How would you feel? Jonas, a twelve year old boy and the Giver have to live in this community knowing all this. As they live in this futuristic dystopian community they share memories of the past and what is elsewhere.
“Perfection is shallow, unreal, and fatally uninteresting” (Anne Lamott). Can you picture our world as a perfect society? For perfection to be achieved everything would have to change. Through the book, The Giver, Lois Lowry shows how a perfect society is not always ideal for everyone. The rules of the society portrayed include a discipline wand, chosen spouse, and release.
The Giver What would life be like without empathy, diversity and memories? Life would be much like The Giver Community. The Giver is about a boy named Jonas who lives in a community that takes place in the future. This community believes in Sameness. Sameness has taken away values such as empathy, diversity, and memories for a peaceful, stable community.
The perspectives introduced by Kurt Vonnegut Jr.’s “Harrison Bergeron” and Ursula K. Le Guin’s “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” consist of extreme conditions that depict the future of a perfect world. Vonnegut Jr. and Le Guin ’s stories involve the futuristic, utopian societies that later mutate into the complete opposite of what originally started as the ideal community. “Harrison Bergeron” and “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” also include the corruption and the negative change that anger the authorities due to a specific individual that lives within the community. Vonnegut Jr.’s “Harrison Bergeron” and Le Guin’s “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas” have excessively significant symbols that surface, revealing people’s intense desires
Imagine living in a perfect society. No pain, everyone is equal, and perfect laws that every person follows. Now imagine being exactly like every other person with all your daily choices being made by someone else for you. In the book The Giver by Lois Lowry, this is exactly how they are living. The author writes about how Jonas’ perfect society is not so perfect after all.
I think that the Community described in "The Giver" was extremely micromanaged by the government, or in this case, the Committee of Elders. This micromanaged place made me feel very perplexed, because it made me wonder who would ever agree to live here or live such a life. By "such a life", I mean such a life where one does not have much leeway to make a choice of their own. For example, peoples' jobs are chosen for them by the government. I also found it strange how Jonas is fascinated by eye color, and even embarrassed, when he sees Gabe's eyes and realizes that his own eyes are the same color.