In the film “Life is beautiful”, we meet a father and son who get sent to a concentration camp. In the novel Night by Elie Wiesel, we are also introduced to a father and son that get sent to a concentration camp. These two stories both share some similarities and some differences. “Life is Beautiful” can come off as a bit problematic because the story is not very similar to how life actually was in the concentration camps. In this essay, I will be explaining the similarities and differences between the two stories but also explain how the film can be somewhat problematic. Since the two stories told are alike, we can dive down and find how they correlate with each other. The fathers and sons are Elie and his dad Schlomo and Roberto and his son Giorgio. As I said before, both stories are told about a father and son duo who try to make it out together but the father ends up dying. Another similarity is how strong of a bond the fathers and sons have. They keep each other going through hardship but in different ways. They helped their fathers not give up in unimaginable ways. …show more content…
The film is obviously a fictional film while the book is a real story of Elie’s life in the concentration camp. Elie’s father Schlomo does not try to hide the horrors of what was happening inside the camps. This also has to do with the age and maturity of the sons. Elie was older and did understand what he was seeing while Roberto knew he could mask what was going on because Giorgio was only four. The ways they help their fathers are different, Giorgio helps his father by being pure and giving him hope while Elie pushes his father to keep going and holds him accountable for the work he
Another comparison seen is both main characters, as protagonists, are giving up their personal property and supplies, along with putting their own lives at risk in order to help others. In Night, Elie is constantly concerned about his father’s safety, even when he could be making sure he survives himself instead, as he explained after talking to the Blockalteste, “He was right.
And the development of Elie and his dad's relationship. Elie and his dad's relationship developing is an important part of the book, because although they endured many dreadful things, it brought them closer together. This is important because they depended on each other and could not have gotten through the camp without each other. This topic is introduced
Elie questioned and changed both relationships with his fathers when facing immense hardship. The difference between the deterioration
In the book Night by Elie Wiesel, the author describes his personal experience of the Holocaust from his teenage years to his liberation from one of the most horrific concentration camps, Auschwitz-Birkenau. The book is a haunting depiction of the atrocities committed by the Nazi regime, bringing to light the horrors of the Holocaust and the inhumane treatment of its victims. The book begins with Wiesel’s life in a small village in Transylvania, where he and his family are forced to move into a ghetto after the Nazis invade. The author narrates the brutal and dehumanizing conditions of life in the ghetto – lack of food, water, and sanitation, overcrowding, and disease.
Elie and Alfred suffer in different ways and face different losses during WWII. Elie’s suffering began when he was interned in the concentration camps with his father when he was 15, while Alfred’s suffering began when he was separated from his entire family and placed into hiding when he was only one year old. Elie struggled in the camps for one year, while Alfred was in hiding for around two and a half. Elie lost his mother and one of his three sisters, while Alfred lost both of his sisters. Despite these differences, both acknowledge the role of chance in their survival.
Keira Federow English I Mr. Mayer 14 February 2023 Night and Life is Beautiful: Unconditional Love for Fathers In the memoir Night by Elie Wiesel and film Life is Beautiful by Roberto Benigni, both father and son relationships change in order to cope with the horror they witness at the Holocaust camps. The Holocaust was the mass slaughter of European Jews in Nazi concentration camps during World War II. Both works take readers and viewers through these concentration camps: Night takes readers through Elie Wiesel and his father’s journey to freedom, and Life is Beautiful takes the audience through the tale of Joshua and his father Guido as they play a game to distract them from camp life.
Through the unforgettable moments in Elie Wiesel’s book, Night it explains what the holocaust did, and how the Germans made it possible to question humanity. It displays Elie’s relationship with his father; Relationships helps the mind prevail through tough situations; They can be powerful and can influence one to keep hope for the future. Elie Wiesel describes his experiences in the numerous Auschwitz concentration camps. Elia and his father had their mind set to get to survive the camps as soon as they knew what was truly going on. Elie and his father’s relationship was instantly strengthened when Elie did not have to go with his mother, Elie describes “His voice was terribly sad.
The parent-son situation has changed for Elie, and Elie now has to take on the responsibilities to care and tend to his father in order to ensure he will survive against the other camp inmates as well as the camp itself. This lack of being able to be cared for by someone else and now having to handle the hardships of caring for someone else greater than him as well as himself exemplifies how Elie faced severe burdens that shook his
“Never shall I forget that night, the first night in camp, that turned my life into one long night seven times sealed” (Wiesel 34). In both Night and Life is Beautiful, the Jews encounter their first night at the concentration camps and although their experiences during the Holocaust may be different, they still share this same gut wrenching feeling of what the beginning of pure Hell is like. Night is an autobiography written by Elie Wiesel and translated by Marion Wiesel. It was published in 1955 after vast copies and constant rejection. Wiesel felt a responsibility to share not only his story, but the story of many others who are not as lucky as him and have the opportunity to tell everyone what they went through.
His father needed him the most in this moment, but he left him for dead. The younger Elie would’ve sprung up in the defense of his father, after his experiences of the sons in concentration camps he decided to leave his father for a gruesome and brutal