ipl-logo

Ethical Issues In The Movie Wit

1423 Words6 Pages

The movie Wit (Bosanquet & Nichols, 2001) focuses on Dr. Vivian Bearing, an English professor who is diagnosed with an aggressive form of ovarian cancer. It chronicle’s Vivian’s experiences with her health care team up until her death. Throughout the movie her doctors, Doctor Kelekian and his fellows, most notably Jason, make many errors while treating Vivian. They communicate with Vivian in ways that make her feel overwhelmed and uncomfortable, violate ethical principles by ignoring her autonomy and not sharing critical information about her health with her, and failing to addressed her spiritual needs. Vivian’s nurse, Susie, does her best to care for Vivian. She incorporates Swanson’s (1991) “Empirical Development Of a Middle Range Theory of Caring” processes such as knowing and being with, into her care and upholds patient advocacy, but she too makes mistakes that hinder Vivian’s wellbeing. Communication In the beginning of the movie, Doctor Kelekian …show more content…

This is an important issue because by trying multiple techniques to get Vivian’s heart pumping again, such as CPR and electric shock paddles, he violates the ethical principle of autonomy. He refuses to respect what the patient has decided is best for her mind, body, and soul and instead steals her right to that decision away from her. It is clear that this was a deliberate act because Susie exclaims that the order was put in a day before and he even looked at it himself (Bosanquet & Nichols, 2001). He was not lazy and forgot to check her chart, he knew the order was there and made a methodical choice not to abide by it. His motivation to revive her is to keep her alive because she aids his research. This shows that Vivian is being cared for by people who prioritize her disease over her

Show More
Related

  • Of Tomcick V. Ohio Dep T Of Rehabilitation And Correction

    675 Words  | 3 Pages

    The medical staff’s ethical principals were non-existent. Unfortunately since Tomcik was in an institution therefore she had no means of autonomy. She was not able to effectively make her own decisions regarding how she was to be treated. The healthcare staff did not use moral judgment throughout her care. She was ignored and not given the proper care that was needed.

    Read More

  • Margret Edson's Wit

    385 Words  | 2 Pages

    "The Patient as Text: Literary Scholarship and Medical Practice in Margret Edson's Wit," by Ann Henley, is a critical essay claiming teachers of literature and medical professionals should asses their efficacy in conveying to students and patients the "simple human truths" that dignify life and death. Henley how both professions use language as inhibitors to avoid meaningful personal communication and to treat their subject of research as nothing more than an object. Henley describes how words are the tools of power, not only for literary scholars but for the medical professionals as well. Kelekian also uses a ton of medical terminology, not to inform Vivian, but to "obfuscate". Which reminds Vivian of how she too uses the language as a teacher

    Read More

  • Duryea-Gode Disease In Octavia Butler's The Evening And The Night

    1210 Words  | 5 Pages

    Through the language in this scene, Octavia Butler emphasizes the importance of Lynn and her pheromones in Alan’s decision to go to bed with her. Although some readers may argue that the pheromones only serve as controls for patients in the DGD ward, this is incorrect because they actually serve as an important form of communication between DGD sufferers, specifically Lynn and Alan. This form of communication is important because it provides DGD sufferers with a reason for “staying alive” (Butler,

    Read More

  • Narrative Techniques In Margaret Edson's Wit

    1254 Words  | 6 Pages

    This could prove to be very unappealing to the audience, but yet Edson doesn't hold back on building Vivian's character to be more difficult for the audience to receive. I think by going about the main character in this way, Edson poses the question of whether or not an audience can empathize with someone that is unable to do so herself. Edson pushes the audience to recognize that Vivian shouldn't be any less deserving of understanding because she is not the typical saint-like cancer patient. Edson doesn't waste time with introducing the audience to Vivian in a one on one manner by basically destroying the forth wall.

    Read More

  • The Lees

    1435 Words  | 6 Pages

    Even though the medical community thought the Lees were doing everything to worsen Lia’s condition by stopping all medication, the reasoning behind their actions shows otherwise. During Lia’s critical condition the Lees had decided to go ahead with withdrawing her medications even after being informed of the possible dangers of doing so, “Nao Kao demanded that Lia’s subclavian line to be removed, and all her medications discontinued. Parents understand that the antibiotics are fighting a severe infection and that without medication Lia may get her infection back and die sooner. They understand that once we remove IV, a new line will NOT be replaced” (175). Although it sounds bad to want to put an end to the medication Lia was receiving, the Lees seemed to think that Lia was so sick she might die, and wanted to stop treatment because they thought the medicine is what was killing her.

    Read More

  • Compassion And Austerity In Margaret Edson's Wit

    512 Words  | 3 Pages

    Even though Vivian seems to be very passive, both compassion and austerity impact her in a different way because austerity leads to being scared and compassion leads to being

    Read More

  • Edson And John Donne Poetry Comparison Essay

    558 Words  | 3 Pages

    Vivian is smart, ironic, quick thinking and capable of keen perception, she has wit. However, her wisdom that is useful in her chosen profession of teaching is insufficient when she must cope with her illness and treatment. As she grows weaker and closer to dying, Vivian comes to rely on her nurse, Susie, who sees Vivian's suffering and fear, and who responds with empathy and care. When Vivian sees that her death is near, she realizes the significance of these

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Vivien Bearing

    1369 Words  | 6 Pages

    Throughout the movie, Vivien engages in flashbacks and reminisces her most memorable moments in the past. She too had her monologue with the viewers, as if she was recording the whole treatment and sharing it with her audience. She had her deepest realization from while she as on the hospital alone. From being a ruthless professor she then realized that all what she did could and have a “payback”. She suffered and fought the side effects of the treatment alone.

    Read More

  • Nancy Mairs On Being A Cripple Essay

    807 Words  | 4 Pages

    This quote shows that even though Mairs sometimes has difficulty accepting her illness, she knows that there is a growing acceptance of people who must deal with the difficulties that she faces. This ultimately lends a hopeful and positive tone to an otherwise serious and depressing section of her essay. This contrast in tone, but general feeling of hope is key to the type of emotions that Nancy Mairs is trying to educate her readers about. Mair is successful in using multiple rhetorical strategies to connect with the reader.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis: Fink's Recovery

    455 Words  | 2 Pages

    This seemed a bit obvious or maybe she saw she could have and would do more for the victims she let die. I also understood that in most cases when the morphine was injected, no one stayed with the patient until they passed. They died scared and painfully alone. She changed the ways we will handle a tragic day that was Katrina. LifeCare was irresponsible.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Fault In Our Stars

    2044 Words  | 9 Pages

    At this meeting they are discussing Hazel’s condition and reviewing her plan of care. Additionally, Hazel’s mother is expressing her concerns about her daughters behavior and she feels Hazel is “depressed.” Dr. Maria reviews various medical options to care for Hazel’s feelings of being depressed. She also suggests Hazel attends a local support group of other young people who are living with or surviving cancer.

    Read More

  • What Are The Ethical Issues In The Movie Set It Off

    649 Words  | 3 Pages

    Set It Off, directed by F Gary Gray, is an action and thriller film that was produced in 1996. The film is based on African American women struggling during an economic crisis. It stars four women as bank robbers; Queen Latifah as Cleo, Jada Pinkett as Stony, Vivica A. Fox as Frankie, Kimberly Elise as Tisean. During this film, there is a lot of killing and crimes being committed. Cleo is a lesbian with a girlfriend that is having a difficult time providing for her son.

    Read More

  • Chemotherapy In Margaret Edson's Wit

    1306 Words  | 6 Pages

    Shortly after she’s admitted for her first cycle of chemotherapy and as she is being scrutinized by one technician after another, she remarks, “Now I know how a poem feels” (16). Furthermore, the doctors seem to take less and less notice of her pain and diminished capacity as the chemotherapy weakens, and she develops a growing awareness that she has become no more a series of signs, an object of “obsessively detailed examination” (40). Vivian, the author of painstakingly researched and widely heralded literary criticism understands all too well that cancer has made her little more than the object of a study that will bring celebrity status to Kelekian and Jason when the results of the study are published. But, she reminds herself, the article “will not be about me, it will be about my ovaries… What we have to come to think of as me, is, in fact, just the specimen jar, just the dust jacket” (53).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Movie Wit

    977 Words  | 4 Pages

    One of it is the proper way of upholding patient 's rights when it comes to medical research. As a nursing major, I am aware that it is one of my ethical responsibilities to ensure that utmost care and treatment are provided to my patient 's advocate which means that we should stand and do something when we see malpractice being done to our patients. The doctors used Vivian as a research subject, but her nurse Susie struggles to guarantee the most beneficial care and treatment is provided for her. This film depicts the significance of advocating and fighting for patients as well as their rights in order to ensure that they are receiving optimal medical treatment.

    Read More

  • Philadelphia Movie Ethical Issues

    640 Words  | 3 Pages

    Philadelphia, a film released in 1993 starring Tom Hanks and Denzel Washington was one of the first major films to cover controversial sexual health issues in the United States. After the AIDS epidemic in the 1980s, the media feared to exploit the deadly disease and issues concerning sexuality and sexual health were continued to be viewed as taboo. The film aims to depict the current issues (in 1993) dealing with HIV/AIDS, homosexuality and homophobia discrimination and the lack of knowledge and prejudices that accompany those issues. Tom Hanks’s character, Andrew Beckett, is a young and driven attorney that made partner at a high-powered law firm. Beckett conceals his sexual orientation as a homosexual male and his HIV/AIDS status from

    Read More

More about Ethical Issues In The Movie Wit

Open Document