Arnav Chamunya
Contact Sports Are Not Worth the Risk
According to Stanford Children’s Health, 30 million kids play organized sports each year, with 3.5 million of them requiring medical attention each year. Sports have been a favorite pastime since ancient Greece, and many young adults consider their participation in sports as their future career. However, sports, specifically contact sports, are seeing a decline, regardless of the perceived benefits. Contact sports, which involve physical contact with other players, have been associated with the highest level of injury. Since the risks of injuries are very high, many parents are worried about their children's mental and physical safety. Despite the positive effects, contact sports are not
…show more content…
This viewpoint can be supported by professors. According to Dr. Marika Lindholm, a professor at Northwestern University “Sports psychologists are in high demand because parents, coaches, teams, and schools put undue pressure on young athletes to perform well every time they step on the field, court, or track” (Lindholm 2). Letting children participate in contact sports while already under massive amounts of pressure due to academics can have disastrous mental health consequences. Pressure can easily manipulate athletes with the best mental health. They can turn into scared, helpless individuals that feel that everyone is against them. Thus, contact sports are not worth the risk of becoming distant from everyone else you love. Many experts also agree that contact sports can weaken the confidence of kids. According to Dr. Marika Lindholm, “Too often, a win-at-all-costs mentality devastates young athletes” (Lindholm 2). Allowing children to tie their mental health to sports can seriously harm their well-being. Whenever a kid who loves to win loses, it can destroy their self-esteem. They might blame themselves for their team losing and would experience a great deal of sadness and depression and perceive themselves as a failure, especially if it is a big game like a championship. In the end, this would destroy any happiness they feel and they would always feel like they are less compared to others, (which …show more content…
Research confirms that sports can prevent children from falling into depression while also healing from their trauma. According to Dr. Molly Easterlin, “...kids who had participated in team sports were significantly less likely to receive a diagnosis of depression or anxiety and less likely to test positive for depressive symptoms” (Neilson 2). Based on this information, it might be concluded that sports are good for children because it lets kids stay happy and have a lower chance of slipping into depression. Unfortunately, in reality, it is more likely to further injure a child’s well-being by destroying their mental and physical health. If an athlete is constantly being hit in the head, they can develop serious illnesses, such as Alzheimer’s, CTE, and Parkinson’s disease- all very serious terminal illnesses. Additionally, there is also the risk of broken bones due to the impacts of other players in contact sports. Also, the mental trauma experienced from pressure from the crowd, coaches, other players, and their parents might be overwhelming. This in turn can reduce an athlete’s mental well-being even more, putting them at risk for future traumatic injuries. Contact sports are still not worth the risk despite the numbered positive effects claimed by their
Statsky’s Argument is Not Explored Broadly Enough In the article “Children Need to Play, Not Compete” by Jessica Statsky, the author describes how the competitiveness of organized sports that have been popular among many young American children in recent years can have damaging effects on their physical or psychological well-being and proper development. Statsky said an apparent disadvantage of competitive sports is young children’s vulnerability to physical injury. For instance, she mentioned about Professor Tutko’s claim that many contact sports such as tackle football are physically harmful for young children. Besides that, children’s fear of getting hurt can also discourage them from engaging in sports activities as she refers to
“He’s at the 40, 30, 20, 10! Oooh, I don’t think he’s getting up from that hit.” Recreational and professional football players are fun to watch, but these players have higher risks of injuries, that they are willing to put on the line. As a soon to be parent, I would hesitate to let my son play football because of the obvious warning signs shown, consequences of playing, and the devastations of the injuries. On the stands, fans are going crazy and enjoying their time watching two hundred to four hundred pound men aggressively beat each other.
In “Children Need to Play, Not Compete.” Jessica statsky brought forward a pressing issue of competitive sports that has now become a part of our lives. Statsky claims that these competitive sports have a harmful effect on a child’s mind. The extreme physical pressure is quite damaging as well. The injuries children face can sometimes take forever to heal itself.
This means that the games for children need to focus more on their pleasure and enjoyment rather than on the competition. Competition only makes children bound to be winners. It also discourages sportsman spirit. Instead of being a source of healthy growth, these competitive sports have started becoming the source of depression for children when they don’t fulfil the expectations of their parents. These sports should enhance the sportsman spirit in children and must be beneficial for their mental and physical health.
Without a doubt, there has always been a great risk of injury while participating in contact sports. The participants involved in any contact sporting event are always susceptible to being injured. These participants are completely aware of the everyday risk, but the energy that these sports bring, keep them going regardless. Over the years, there have been countless numbers of injuries due to the nature of these sports, but still millions of people young to old gain interest everyday. While people young to old are gaining interest everyday to contact sports many parents of young children are being faced with the issue either to allow their children to participate in often dangerous sports.
The first reason is that concussions can have life-altering negative effects. Next, contact sports contribute to the mental illness of aggression. Lastly, Chronic Traumatic Encephalopathy or CTE. Finally, we will address the counterclaim that contact sports are totally worth the risk.
Contact sports have more negative effects than positive effects and due to this kids should stop playing contact
Football, although fun and exciting, plays an immense role in many long term health issues especially for people who start at a young age. The sport’s injuries include long term health issues such as chronic encephalopathy, ALS, Alzheimer’s disease, and dementia; it also can be a reason for domestic violence, and on some occasions, unnecessary death. There are many factors that can persuade parents to believe that football is a safer sport than it was before, but the long term effects of a simple injury from the sport outweighs it all. In Ed Riley’s article, High School football’s benefits outweigh risks, Riley talks about the concerns that any parent would have when it comes to their child playing football.
Contact sports involve touching, hitting, or banging other children, which is often why children get hurt in these sports. Among teens, concussions and death have happened. While these sports increase the strength of teenagers as they partake in a school activity, the risk of injury and death is great. The health benefits of contact sports do not outweigh the risks of playing them. The leading causes of death and accidents in sports are caused by concussions.
2.6 million sports related emergency room visits a year; 25,376 children under 19 sent to the emergency room for traumatic brain injury each year (Merkel). Contact sports, a sport in which the participants necessarily come into bodily contact with one another, like football have become more popular among children and they have started to play the sport at earlier ages as well. Although physical activity is beneficial in many ways, contact sports creates many health risks: concussions, chronic traumatic encephalopathy, brain damage, broken bones, and broken growth plates. Because of all of these risks, contact sports should be banned for people under 18. To begin, contact sports should be banned for children under 18 because of the risk of
Children experience more harmful negative impacts, rather than beneficial positive ones, such as being at a constant risk of severe injury, wanting to opt out of sports early, and being under high levels of stress and anxiety. These impacts could lead to children being injured for an extended amount of time, children being inactive and unfit later in life, children dropping out of school, and many other catastrophic circumstances that children should not have to put up with. The opposing side suggests that children who participate in competitive sports experience positive impacts, such as staying healthy and in shape, and having positive psychological benefits. In some instances, these impacts may be true, however families with a child athlete opted for fast food, ready-made meals more than those of families who did not have a child athlete. Also, while competitive sports provide some psychological benefits, it has also been proven that they can cause stress, anxiety, and ultimately, attrition for the young athlete.
Summary In “Children Need to Play, Not Compete,” Jessica Statsky tries to demonstrate the negative effect of organized sports on the physical and psychological health of growing child. She claims that the games are not festive but they end up in the wrong development of a child’s brain. The coaches and parents have high hopes for their children that result in the pressure building. This changes the purpose of sports from teaching tolerance, teamwork and sportsmanship to merely winning by all means.
“In the U.S., about 30 million children and teens participate in some form of organized sports, and more than 3.5 million injuries each year” claims Stanford Children’s Health. It’s definitely true that competitive sports can cause all sorts of injuries from big to small. The media teaches people simply that sports leads to horrific injuries and can cause stress, but what the mainstream media hardly discusses are the great benefits of competitive sports. While there may be some negatives to competitive sports, that’s just life, and to add on to that; there are plenty of benefits which are sure to override to media’s facts. Kids should play competitive sports because competitive sports teach children powerful life lessons, contributes to their social and mental stability, and because of the physical gain competitive sports provides.
In the world, there are many arguments around. But the biggest argument people are questioning is: are sports good for you or are they a bad chance for a concussion. Your choice, is the wrong choice. Sports are better than sitting around with nothing to do. But not just for one day, everyday!
Children tie their sports performance to their self-esteem according to “The Pros and Cons of Youth Sports Aren't Only Physical”, and this could be very bad. “Who your child is as a person shouldn’t be tied closely to the ability to hit home runs or score touchdowns. If it is, that’s a guaranteed set-up for feelings of failure and low self-esteem” (Lindholm par. 3). Children that may be linking their self-worth to sports can make them not like it and make it an unenjoyable experience for them. While low self-esteem is one problem with sports, “The Pros and Cons of Youth Sports Aren't Only Physical” explains that high self-esteem could be another issue.