There has always been a language barrier between An Mei and her daughter Rose Hsu. These two women have very different view on how life should be handled. In the Joy Luck Club, An Mei is trying to help her daughter Rose, who is currently going through a divorce. An Mei wants her daughter to save the marriage but she knows that it is completely pointless to do so. She understands that she needs to stick up for herself, and she does by getting a lawyer, and fight for the house she once lived in. Rose does not believe that her marriage is worth the constant miscommunication and one not understanding one another. Rose only wants the house, and An Mei wants to save the marriage because in Chinese tradition, that would be the only way to keep the …show more content…
When they lived with their grandparents they had many restrictions that they were not used to. They were not able to talk about their mom. A couple months pass and they have forgotten about who their mom was. Popo becomes very ill and An Mei’s mother returns home to take care of her. Ancient Chinese tradition states that if one of your family is very ill and has a small chance of returning to a healthy state, that the healthy flesh of one of the family members must be consumed in order to become healthy again. Therefore, An Mei cuts a piece of flesh off of her arm and puts it in soup for Popo to eat. “Here is how I came to love me mother. How I saw my own true nature. What was beneath my skin. Inside my bones” (p.40) At this point in the story, An Mei is recognized for her courage and her honor for attempting to save a family member by sacrificing her own skin and bone. Her daughter recognized how much she loved her family and what lengths she would be willing to go for her. “The pain you must forget, because sometimes that is the only way to remember your bones.” (p41) An Mei had a very difficult childhood, but in return taught her many good lessons about how life can change at any time and the most unsuspecting events can occur at any …show more content…
Opposing from An Mei, her daughter, Rose, had a completely different view upon the world and how she wanted to live her life. An Mei was born in china, whereas her daughter was born in the United States where she has been used to the American culture. She also has no interest in the Chinese culture or traditions as her mother. I believe that An Mei is upset that her daughter doesn’t follow in the footsteps as her mother, but Rose is so “gung-ho” about what she wants that she doesn’t even consider her families past. “This is not hope, not reason. This is your fate. This is your life, what you must do” (p134) When Rose was a young girl, her family took a vacation to the beach, and her being the oldest she was responsible for watching her younger sibling Bing. He had walked down a reef when her other brothers started to argue and then lead to a fight. As Rose was breaking up the scuffle, Bing had fallen into the reef and disappeared without any remains of his person. Her family notified the proper authorities and searched around the ocean for hours but never had the opportunity to trace him. The following day, the family rushed back to the ocean to ask if they had any clues or had found Bing. The authorities were not successful of finding any traces of
Throughout her childhood life her mother, Suyuan, was continuously pushing her to be her best. Jing-Mei purposely tried to fail at everything to prover to her mother that she could never become a great and famous person. Then after a piano recital that went horridly wrong, her and her mother had an argument and their relationship was never the same. Many years later Suyuan tried to give Jing-mei the piano that she had as a child. She refused the offer, but than a year later her mother died and Jing-Mei was cleaning out her mother’s house and decided to play the piano and she was surprised that she still knew how.
Mei-Li and Hong’s relationship starts happy and healthy, and everyone around can see. An example is shown, “At other times, when Mei-Li returned from her walks, there was a glow in her eyes that did not die for days” (108). During the beginning of their relationship, while Pei and Mei-Li were living in Auntie Yee’s girl’s house, Mei-Li would secretly take walks to meet with Hong. Mei-Li would always come home happy, and that happiness stuck with her. Mei-Li was in love with Hong.
She then uses these “new thoughts” and ideas to state that she “won’t let her [mother] change” her into the person she seeks her daughter to be. When Jing-Mei experiences a realization that she is her own person and not simply another part of her mother, she can embrace the comfort of knowing that she will not change for anyone, and is simply extraordinary for having her own thoughts and feelings. This reflects how Amy Tan can understand her thoughts and feelings about the hardships in her relationship with her mother as a way to connect more closely to her characters and make them more realistic in her writing (“How Amy Tan’s family stories made her a
(Tan 24). through this it can be said that Jing-Mei’s mother has a very different culture compared to
The application of a first person perspective better captures the events and their emotional significance. Tan writes of young adult Jing-mei Woo and her discovery and meeting of her half-sisters who were lost during war stricken times and had been considered
Jing-Mei’s American upbringing hindered her ability to understand her mother’s perspective – which was based on Chinese heritage – resulting in strong differences of opinion that led to arguments. In addition, since Jing-Mei and her mother failed to communicate effectively about their different perspectives, they became frustrated and upset with each other. The relationship between Jing-Mei and her mother was harmed by their emotional distance from each other. The absence of verbal affection between them translated to increased resentment and disappointment. Positive emotional connection between a parent and child proves vital in maintaining a healthy relationship in the face of
In Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club, mother and daughter relationships are put to the test. Four women meet to play a game of Chinese mahjong, keeping a tradition alive. Suyuan Woo, founder of the club, had a daughter named Jing Mei June Woo. Suyuan had two daughters which she expected both to succeed to her standards.
Thesis Statement about theme of literary work- In Amy Tan’s The Joy Luck Club, expressions of love and hatred are shown in multiple mother-daughter relationships resulting in negative impacts such as pain, bitterness, and regret because of their differing opinions. Support Point #1- Suyuan Woo guiltily leaves her twin daughters on the ground in China as she walks away in tears.
“After losing everything in China…She never looked back with regret. ”(Chunk 1 ¶3). Jing-Mei’s mother is a Chinese immigrant with the typical ‘everything is better in America’ mindset. Jing-Mei, being raised in America, had more of an American mindset. “You want me to be someone i’m not…I’ll never be the daughter you want me to be!”
In the words of Jing-Mei in the last line of the story, “Together we look like our mother. Her same eyes, her same mouth, open in surprise to see, at last, her long-cherished wish” (Tan 159). Throughout her life, Suyuan, their mother, held onto the hope that she would see her daughters again. In this hope, she named Jing-Mei in connection to her sisters, keeping the “long-cherished wish” that someday her daughters would reconcile and complete their family circle. The occasion that
An-mei’s mother was forced to be taken advantaged of and had no rights in society. An-mei saw her mom struggle with trusting other people and was never able to form a strong relationship with other people. She taught An-mei that she had to face all hardships of life without reacting in anyway to not make the hardship even worse.
Jing Mei is signed up to perform at a local talent show in front of her family, despite having no interest in playing the piano. Her performance of a piece ironically titled “Pleading Child”, as expected, doesn’t go well, which only makes Jing Mei and her mom’s perspectives of each other more negative. Ultimately fueled with hatred on Page 27-28, Jing Mei has a meltdown, thinking to herself, “My true self had finally emerged. So this was what had been inside of me all along.” Feeling both pressured and embarrassed by her family, especially her mom, Jing Mei, musically, feels powerless, and all of her might to be a prodigy disappears after her performance.
Daisy hopes that young Jing-mei will try to be her best at anything. The mother's encouragement shows how greatly important it is for her daughter to succeed. In any of her works, Amy Tan includes various Chinese cultural values. One value that is existent in every on of her pieces is family, for it is a very important aspect of Chinese culture that
As a whole, while the story was very depressing at times, it still has an underlying tone of family ideals, as the relationship between the mother and daughter still remained despite the arguments they had. In my opinion, I think the author’s message that she wished to convey was that despite any event that may occur, family members will always be there support you. This is shown in how, despite Jing Mei’s failures at becoming a prodigy, her mother still supported her and did not give up hope on helping her daughter becoming a successful person. As such, it strengthens the idea that “family will always be there for you”, no matter what hardships come their way. In addition, it helped to add a sense of togetherness in the short story, as it inadvertently revealed how much Jing’s mother actually loved her, despite her tough exterior.
Xie is a mother, a sister, and a grandmother to 4 children and 13 grandchildren. She was born in the winter of 1953 at a local province where the majority of the people are farmers. Till her mid-40s she immigrated to the US, in search of a better opportunity for her and her family. Xie was born to a dependent mother and strict father. Being the oldest of the five, Xie carried a burden for setting up correct role models for the rest of her siblings.