ipl-logo

Religious Discourse In Relation To New Reproductive Technologies

1048 Words5 Pages

Religious viewpoint
In order to understand a religious discourse in relation to new reproductive technologies, a key concern is centred on the debate around ‘at what point’ is an embryo considered a human being?
Many people’s views and opinions about reproductive technologies stem from their conclusions regarding abortion (Evans 2010). Put simply, Evans (2010) argues that there is an inclination for religious people to oppose to RGT and their applications of them, more than secular people. Traditionally, a Christian view is to protect the foetus as a person from the moment of fertilisation, with the view that this is the point of the beginning of a human life. Therefore, a conventional Christian perspective considers new reproductive technologies …show more content…

Human genetic engineering, what was once considered a futuristic possibility and in the realm of science fiction (Evans 2010) is now becoming a mechanism to alter the genetic characteristics of an individual that will now be passed through the germ line, from one generation to the next. We are essentially changing the genetic makeup of the human species (Evans 2010). With IVF and HGE, is it morally correct to make radical genetic selections and changes that inevitably will influence the lives of future generations?

Veatch, Haddad and English (2010) argue that this is the most fundamental issue that faces reproductive technologies, whether or not interfering with ‘the genetic and birth process is ‘playing God’’ in an unacceptable manner. They further state that the rapid developing reproductive technologies have the potential to change the nature of the human species and the process of reproduction (Veatch, Haddad and English, 2010), which can be considered to extend beyond what ‘humans should be permitted to do’. Thus, the extent to which humans can manipulate genes should take into consideration the ethical points previously addressed in this essay and should be controlled and managed through a standardised …show more content…

In an unregulated environment these issues present serious threats to the fabric of society.
Regulation by it’s nature is a framework to define, protect and preserve ethical practice across society and it’s engagement within itself.

Ireland in comparison to other countries such as United States and the United Kingdom are slow regarding the institutionalisation of bioethics, public debate and regulation surrounding RGT. This may be linked to generations of religious influence of the Catholic Church on society in addition to the Irish state’s preoccupation with establishing a ‘pro-life’ ethos while many EU countries were solidifying formalisation and regulation of bioethics in the early 1990s (Conrad 2001, Smyth 2005 as cited in McDonnell and Allison 2006). However, despite the decline in the authority of the Catholic Church in Ireland, there seems to be an apprehension about opening up the bioethical debate (McDonnell and Allison

Show More
Related

  • Abortion Vs Pro Life Essay

    1259 Words  | 6 Pages

    Abortion has been a controversial charged topic that encompasses complex ethical, moral, legal, and even religious dimensions. The debate surrounding abortion largely revolves around two opposing positions: pro-choice and pro-life. Proponents of the pro-choice stance argue that the decision regarding pregnancy should rest with the woman who is carrying the baby, emphasizing the importance of women's reproductive rights and bodily autonomy. On the other hand, advocates of the pro-life perspective prioritize the inherent value and right to life of the unborn fetus, advocating for its protection and preservation. Given the diverse and often conflicting opinions on this matter, the question of whether a pregnancy should be dependent on the choice

    Read More

  • Csikszentmihalyi's Essay: The Future Of Happiness

    1008 Words  | 5 Pages

    As technology improves, so do human capabilities of altering nature, which in turn creates increased responsibility. This directly relates to genetic engineering, which is beginning to morph into a reality. There are advocates for both sides that convey their personal opinions about the hypothetical results, but neither is clearly superior since both arguments speculate upon an unknown future. Hungarian psychologist, Mihaly Csikszentmihalyi, outlines this topic in his essay “The Future of Happiness,” which focuses on the history of selective breeding and compares the goal of happiness with genetic engineering. Csikszentmihalyi alternates between viewpoints regarding genetic engineering but presents a perspective dominated by warning.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Not Your Incubator

    1119 Words  | 5 Pages

    This image highlights the objectifying nature of anti-choice ideas. Using the word “incubator”, I conjured the image of a caged chicken with their egg amongst a bed of straw. Rather than debate when “life” begins, I felt the abortion debate should focus on observable realities. Fertile women can become pregnant without their consent. One does not agree to the implantation of a zygote.

    Read More

  • Strange Creatures By Susan Blackmore: An Analysis

    1824 Words  | 8 Pages

    Designer genetics to create a baby after careful selection is a meme, and “we can say that memes are ‘selfish’, that they ‘do not care’, that they ‘want’ to propagate themselves, and so on, when all we mean is that successful memes are the ones that get copied and spread, while unsuccessful ones do not” (Blackmore 37), and some may consider this genetic modification to be a successful meme which is why parents are so willing to try it. By using technology in this type of way, it may possibly benefit some if it is spread for good causes, such as helping a baby be born without a disease that is known to run in the family so the parents won’t have to see their child go through pain. Many parents put their faith in “23andMe” and their technology because it is their last hope to be able to conceive a child without them having to worry about any debilitating disease or disabilities and since this procedure would be implicated even before the child is developed, there would be no questions of morality. However, some people might take advantage of this new technology and use it for nothing more than creating their fantasy child, as they start to choose non-health related traits such as weight, height, gender and eye color.

    Read More

  • Controversy: Embryonic Stem Cell Debate

    577 Words  | 3 Pages

    To convince the audience that embryonic stem cell is unethical, Marwick explains, “ that the research involves the destruction of an embryo.” And to prove that “ a child 's life is important,” he reminds the audience that an embryo is valuable and worth protecting. Marwick’s evidence also reflects his knowledge. When arguing that the research should not be funded, for example, she mentions examples, such as the restriction against funding stem lines. And when putting forward his belief that an embryo is a gift cites Walter, an expert authority on Bioethic.

    Read More

  • Essay On A Defense Of The Moral Principles Of New Eugenics

    3313 Words  | 14 Pages

    Dylan Crowe Ms. Cross EH103-01 27 March 2022 A Defense of the Moral Principles of New Eugenics Eugenics was once a well-respected and accepted scientific field, yet, now, it is viewed with scorn and distrust. Throughout the early twentieth century, the ideas of eugenics were widespread, with many nations, such as the United States, implementing various elements of it with the goal of enhancing their nation's populace. However, during the 1940s, it became untouchable after some began questioning the ethics and morality of improving humanity through selective breeding and the methods used by Nazi Germany in furtherance of genocide and racial hygiene.

    Read More

  • Genetic Engineering In Brave New World

    320 Words  | 2 Pages

    As the penman predicted, the mankind is now in the process of putting on the analogous paradigm to the control of mother nature (Mazzoni). Literally speaking, people are now engineering nature. They try to create and produce new forms of life by making interventions on the microcosmic level. With genetic modification, people climb to a new, highest level of genetics. The cloning industry as well as genetic engineering are advancing so fast that it would only take a short time until people would feel the power and would misuse them on their own account (Schumacher).

    Read More

  • Why Is Gattaca Unethical

    1100 Words  | 5 Pages

    Ethics of Genegeneering Investigate and discuss how a society based on producing ‘designer babies’ may or may not create more happiness and greater benefits for the greater number of people. Refer to the film Gattaca, Jeremy Bentham’s Hedonic calculus, the principles of Utilitarianism and the work of Emmanuel Kant in your discussion. One of the most interesting biomedical advances in recent years, which also brings about great social repercussion is preimplantation genetic screening, which has two uses, producing babies free of genetic or hereditary diseases and the production of so called ‘designer babies.’ The 1997 film Gattaca addresses the ethical issues as well as social repercussions brought about from preimplantation genetic screening

    Read More

  • The Immortal Life Of Henrietta Lacks By Rebecca Skloot

    1118 Words  | 5 Pages

    The deliberation of bioethics in human cell and stem cell research has flip-flopped altercations between whether stem cell research corrupts the future or if basic ethical uses in clinical research are being held to its standards. The idea of having genetically altered drugs and cells sits with people the wrong way, and with that they have come to the decision that cell research will cause more problems than it stopping them. However, while a majority of people and scientists believe genetic engineering is an evil corruption of nature’s course, genetic engineering has the greatest potential to do something great for our future, but it is our moralistic responsibility to follow the rules of bioethics. The author of The Immortal Life of Henrietta

    Read More

  • Rise Of Eugenics

    1753 Words  | 8 Pages

    The Rise of Human Genetic Modification? There are many controversial issues throughout time that have risen and led countries to disagree to with one another worldwide. Eugenics and genetic engineering on humans is a topic that many believe crosses a major ethical boundary. Many scientists and ethicists believe that gene editing on human genes is unethical at certain degrees and it should not be done until the proper precautions have been overlooked and restrictions are made.

    Read More

  • Essay On Gene Editing

    1370 Words  | 6 Pages

    Editing of the human genome in the past has been only a sight seen in dystopia works such as Brave New World. Now, genetic enhancement is a prevalent today and people are beginning to realize the issues that can arise from creating these designer babies. Gene editing can be helpful to eradicate life changing disabilities. Yet, the term disability does not correctly label these differently abled people, as the idea of what is considered disabled has changed overtime. To fully understand the consequences and implications of genetic selection and enhancement of human embryos, society must mature and declare lines of what is and is not ethically moral.

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Genetic Enhancement Of Children

    836 Words  | 4 Pages

    Genetic enhancement of humans, defined as the modification of non-pathological traits by transfer of genetic information, is a controversial issue with a broad spectrum of ethical positions. It is not difficult to imagine a future where reproductive technologies to improve the quality of the human species are routinely implemented, however there are a myriad of ethical issues that lead to different complexities, and therein answers, as to whether they should be. In this paper, I contend that even if the means of technology are available to increase the capabilities of the human mind in terms of intelligence, doing so must be done with caution and all consequential effects on the life forms that will result must be seriously considered. Reprogenetics,

    Read More

  • Abortion Persuasive Speech Outline

    593 Words  | 3 Pages

    Why are we so against arranged marriages but so for a woman keeping a child she doesn’t want or can’t support? Thesis Statement The stigma and laws against should be lifted because it should be solely the parents’ or woman’s decision, it has been beneficial in many cases and the betterment of the life already being lived should take residence over the embryo’s possible life.

    Read More

  • Argumentative Essay On Abortion

    1663 Words  | 7 Pages

    One of the furthermost essential issues in biomedical ethics is the controversy around abortion. There’s a long history on this controversy and it is still critically debated among researchers and the public in both terms of morality and legality. Some of the basic questions argued that may perhaps characterize the importance of the issue: Is abortion morally justifiable? Does the foetus/embryo/zygote have any moral and legal rights? Is the foetus a human being and, if so, should it be protected?

    Read More

  • Reproductive Technology In Brave New World

    930 Words  | 4 Pages

    Through differences and similarities Brave New World, written by Aldous Huxley, shows the future for reproductive technologies. While this novel was written in the 1930’s, the ideas used in the book are actually used in the modern world. Reproductive technologies are used to treat infertility and increase reproduction in different ways and some are used as contraceptives. Through the use of modern reproductive technologies Huxley gives a more controversial view about the use them, some of the few that brought attention were the use of contraceptive pills, test-tube babies, and the process of in vitro fertilization. Even though contraceptive processes have been around since the 1500’s, the first birth control pill came out in the 1950’s.

    Read More

More about Religious Discourse In Relation To New Reproductive Technologies

Open Document