'Peter Pursued Western Ends by Eastern Means' Discuss.
Peter the Great undoubtedly attempted to implement a heavy amount of Western culture into Russian society, so much so that it split Russia under his reign into two camps; the Slavophiles traditionalists who hated everything Peter was doing to ‘their’ Russia, known as the ‘Muscovites’, and those that supported the Westernization of Russia that Peter attempted to implement during his time in power, know as the Petrins. But how did Peter achieve these reforms or ‘Western ends’? And why have his methods doing so made historians claim that he achieved them through the traditional means any other Eastern ruler at the time would have used?
‘Western ends’ or Westernization is commonly seen as
…show more content…
These are the methods that a number of historians have claimed Peter used during his time as Tsar of Russia as a means to get what he wanted, the only way he knew how. ‘Eastern means’ of ruling a country are often viewed as autocratic, brutal, centralized, and without a limited monarchy, meaning that the King, or Tsar of the country has absolute power to rule and govern over the people, and the country. ‘Eastern means’ would see great power placed in faith, and the church as a strong player in the governmental goings-on of a country, and the upper and ruling classes being powerful and god-like in comparison to the rest of the country. Being autocratic and brutal is often the common view of most Eastern leaders all the way up until the mid-20th century, however this could be seen as a generalization, and almost a cliché as it was and is still what most Westerners expect from an Eastern leader. However, it could certainly be said that Peter was somewhat different than most the Eastern cliché that has come into fruition, although he still led with an iron-fist over his people, he avoided some of the traditionalist features of an Eastern state such as the church and the ‘Boyars’, he effectively despised everything that his son Alexis embodied, the traditional Russia, the Russia that Peter wanted to …show more content…
Peter the Great led the first westernization of Russia in history, permanently changing Russia and its culture permanently. By the time Peter came to power in the late seventeenth century, Russia had fallen behind Western Europe in terms of becoming a modern society. Technologically, and culturally Russia was centuries behind, it had had no Renaissance, no Reformation, and no Scientific Revolution unlike the West. Russia was effectively seen as medieval Europe, with little to show for itself compared to its far advanced neighbor. This is what Peter wanted to change whilst in power; he wanted to achieve ‘Western ends’ of modernity in anyway possible. One of the ways he did this was by Westernizing Russian governmental, and military dress; he ordered the entire military, nobility, and court to shave, even going as far to shave the more reluctant nobles himself. He required them to dress in Western style clothing, and commanded to remove their shoes before bed or face a ‘mild punishment’, this was because it was common practice for Russians to wear shoes in bed, which was seen as ‘barbaric’ by Western Europeans. Peter also reformed religion in Russia, he replaced Orthodox schools with Secular ones, and his encouragement of science and state-run education only accelerated the Church’s loss of authority. He also ordered new shipyards, sea fortresses, and ships after his
Have you ever been looking for someone that did not even know? In Ender’s Game, Orson Scott Card uses conflict between Ender and his siblings and classmates to show why Ender was chosen for Battle School. In the book, the government is searching for the perfect child to someday become the military leader and defeat the buggers. The leader has to have brutality but also have empathy. One household has their first child named Peter.
In the beginning of the book, he is portrayed as a villainous manipulator who bullies Ender on his quest for power and control. Later in the book, though, the reader comes to comprehend his motivations and recognizes that he possesses the capacity for both good and evil. Peter's intelligence and ability to think strategically are two of his best attributes. The novel's protagonist, Ender, acknowledges Peter's abilities in this area, saying, "Peter was smart, and he was already planning ahead" (Card chapter 5). This is a great trait for him especially since he interacted in a political environment where war was also a common
Peter the Great came barreling through Russia as tsar from 1721 to 1725, bringing with him a slew of economic, social, and political reforms that are argued to have made Russia a great nation once again. Prior to his reign, Russia had endured many difficulties, from Ivan the Terrible’s chaotic reign to the great Raskol to the time of troubles. Peter the Great is credited with prompting Russia to rise once again as a great nation through great institutional reforms, particularly surrounding military-based industrialization. Despite how highly regarded Peter the Great is in Russian society, historians like Marc Raeff argue that Peter the Great’s reign “was to tear Russian society apart, leaving behind a legacy of uncertainty and insecurity that
He built an army of 210,000 men and a navy from scratch (Doc4). He was a feared leader an was disliked because of how he ruled. Peter had a goal of conquering the Baltic sea because of the warm water to trade. In attempt to reach this goal, the Swedish King, Charles XII, defeated him at Narva (Doc 2). To overcome his defeat he improved his armies and worked even harder for mastery of the Baltic.
This is most of the great, cultural achievements of Peter The Great in Russia. Peter The Great was a great role model and military leader. Although Peter impacted Russia negatively and positively through westernization and opening Russia to the West(Riasanovsky 1). Overall Peter had huge impact on
The church would reinforce his authority and refer to him towards the people as the ‘Little Father’. The church was extremely influential in that era and ensured that peasants and working class, who were at the bottom of the classist system, were aware that challengers of the tsar were an insult to God. It was therefore hard to go against the Tsar, despite his rule being unfair to the poor. This leads on to Russia being hard to govern under tsarist rule due to autocracy. In his coronation speech in 1894, Tsar Nicholas said he will ‘uphold the principle of autocracy as firmly and unflinchingly as my late and unforgettable father’.
Also, during this time period, Frederick William I transformed Prussia into a military state. To become an absolute ruler, Peter the Great made many reforms throughout Russia. However, all these absolute leaders had the same goal. Even though they reigned over different countries, they all strengthened their armies, raised taxes, and unified religion. One thing that all absolute rulers did was increase the strength of their army.
Peter the Great and Louis XIV were both the greatest rulers of their times. Both of them were autocrats having unlimited power and on the contrary both of them were absolutists. Louis XIV was the ruler of France and nicknamed “The Sun King” and Peter the Great was the ruler of Russia. Although Peter the Great and Louis XIV has some different successes, they had several noticeable similarities such as power, buildings, and armies/economical growths. Peter the Great and Louis XIV had similar successes in their famous buildings.
In what ways, and with what success, did Alexander II attempt to modernize Russia and preserve imperial power? Tsar Alexander II started was coroneted in 1855, during the Crimean War. He ended the war and negotiate the peace, which was a failure for state and shock for society. That made an atmosphere in which he could introduce required reforms. In years from 1855 to around 1870 he tried to change the Russian backward Russia into powerful European country, which could be compared to the West.
4. External Pressures on the late Ming, Early Qing: Mongols and Manchus: This was an issue because the pressure of the Mongols and the invasion by the Manchus led to the end of the Ming Empire. The late Ming Empire was under pressure in the North from the Manchus and the Mongols. In the late 1500s, large numbers of Mongols were unified by their devotion to the Dalai Lama. A military leader named Galdan restored Mongolia as a military power around 1600.
I believe that Ivan the Terrible was more of an absolute monarch than Peter the Great. I do not think he was a more fair or morally correct ruler, but I do think he was more powerful. He had absolute power controlled by fear and divine right, while Peter the Great only had divine right. Also, the fact that he controlled by fear is really what caused him to have more power. People are likely to do almost anything when they are avoiding being injured or killed.
Peter is ruthless becasue he feels no emotions or regret in killing/murdering his parents due to not getting his way. Peter’s father, “forbade him to take the rocket to New York”(6) and his father decided to turn off, “every machine his hand could get to”(9), which had an impact on him resulting in his plan to murder his parents without
Thus Russia applies a technique of looking for Western faults while ignoring or shadowing its own deficiencies. This model could earlier be also reflected in more constructive forms as it existed as a mission of the improvement of various Western accomplishments due to the Russian/Soviet inability to offer its own break-throughs. As demonstrated by semiotician Yuri Lotman, Russian thinkers claimed a better understanding and implementation of the Greek doctrine than the original Orthodox Christianity (the Byzantine Empire acting at that point as an equivalent of the West). Later, the Russian interpreters of the French enlightenment once again claimed their better understanding of its main principles than the French. The Bolsheviks also borrowed their main tenets from Western socialist and communist doctrines and then altered them to suit their purposes and presented this alteration as an improvement (Lotman 2002,
Peter ruled Russia jointly with is brother Ivan V from 1682 until 1696. Peter inherited a country, which was greatly underdeveloped. He reformed his army, built a strong navy, secularized schools, reformed the Orthodox Church and introduced several territorial divisions. He developed the country’s commerce and industry, modernized Russian alphabet, and introduced the first newspaper. He also reformed the government and its foreign policy.
The book Peter and Wendy written by J. M. Barrie has many contradictions. On the one hand, it is a playful story about the innocence and joyfulness of childhood. But, on the other hand, it is at its core about the necessity of adulthood. Throughout this argumentative essay, I will try to find out whether Peter and Wendy is a celebration of perpetual youth or an elegy.