ipl-logo

The Devil's Arithmetic Movie Vs Book Analysis

935 Words4 Pages

Devil’s Arithmetic Movie vs Book Death, sickness, and torture among humans. The Germans were extremely cruel people during WW1. Jews were taken from their homes and put into concentration camps where they were forced to do work or die. In The Devil’s Arithmetic the tragedy and harshness of these camps was brought to life. Using real life details mixed with made up things, The Devil’s Arithmetic is a story full of suspense and truth that shows the pain and suffering in the camp. I believe that the book and the movie are good but the book is better. You can decide later.

In the book and movie version of The Devil’s Arithmetic, Hannah, the main character, goes to a family religious celebration for Jews known as passover. Hannah gets the privilege to open the door for the prophet elijah. When Hannah opens the door she is transported back in time to 1942. Hannah then has to live through the harshness of the concentration camps, like her grandpa and aunt did. Hannah figures out that she is living the life of her aunt Eva’s friend that passed away at the camps. She also gets to see her grandpa and aunt at the camp. In …show more content…

Aaron contributed to the story by adding a side of Hannah that suggests that she likes to tell stories. This is shown in the beginning when Hannah’s dad wants Hannah to tell Aaron a story to calm him down. In the movie this isn’t shown. Since this isn’t shown there is no real reason Hannah starts to tell stories at the camp. Another very obvious difference from the book to the movies was that in the book Hannah lived with Gitl, but in the movie Hannah lives with Rivka. Rivka was supposed to be at the camp before Hannah arrived. Gitl was supposed to be related to Hannah, not Rivka. In the book Rivka was at the camp way before Hannah was and wasn’t related to her. Gitl was a character that wasn’t even shown in the movie. Rivka was supposed to be a friend, not a

Show More
Related
593 Words | 3 Pages

Have you ever read a book and expected the movie to be amazing, then when you finally see the movie it isn’t even like the book? Well that’s what I felt like when I read The Devil’s Arithmetic. Both, the book and the movie, had similarities and differences. The book begins with Hannah complaining about how she doesn’t want to go to the seder dinner with her and that she doesn’t want to remember any more.

Read More
495 Words | 2 Pages

In the heart-wrenching novel "The Devil's Arithmetic" by Jane Yolen, the character Rivka serves as a powerful symbol of resilience and compassion, teaching valuable lessons to the protagonist, Hannah, and conveying the profound theme of self-sacrifice. Rivka, a young girl trapped in a Nazi concentration camp, exhibits remarkable strength and empathy; her actions and teachings leave an indelible impact on Hannah and the readers, reminding us of the enduring power of the human spirit and the importance of remembrance. Throughout the story, Rivka's selflessness shines through as she fearlessly takes risks to help others. Despite the bleak circumstances, she befriends Hannah, offering her guidance and solace; their connection grows, providing Hannah with a source of strength amidst the horrors of the camp.

Read More
619 Words | 3 Pages

“Now, now, wait a minute. Hold on. Don’t be rash. Let’s talk this over! Good-by, Braling.

Read More
53 Words | 1 Pages

In The Devil’s Arithmetic, Hannah is a 13 year old girl living in New Rochelle. Hannah’s character changes through the story. At the beginning Hannah was a stubborn, careless, and spoiled girl. Through the end of the story Hannah changes to a new person, due to the events she experiences and lives through.

Read More
756 Words | 4 Pages

What this means is that Hannah knows that she is alive and now knows how the “devil plays” with her mind. The manipulation has not tricked her and this is a point in which she can find light because her

Read More
659 Words | 3 Pages

Night: Journal Writing Humanity consists of qualities that make us human, the way we love, care, and have compassion for others. In this novel, I can read about how people got tortured, and treated so badly that they were completely dehumanized. As I read how the Germans treated the Jews, for example, having little to no compassion for them, torturing them, making them live under the inexplicable circumstances they did. It rose upon me many questions based on how and why did this happen.

Read More
450 Words | 2 Pages

The Devil’s Arithmetic, a novel by Jane Yolen, is very inspiring to me. It explains the feelings of not only just Hannah, but many others. It lets me know that in any situation, you can always persevere. Although this book can be sad, the sadness is powerful. It takes you to a whole new perspective of the Holocaust, not just through facts, but actually living it.

Read More
266 Words | 2 Pages

Dehumanization The Nazis dehumanized the innocent people. In the novel it showed what life was like during the holocaust. In the novel Night by Elie Wiesal, tells you the way that the Nazis dehumanized the Jewish race. They dehumanized the Jewish race by doing what they would do to animals. They burned them.

Read More
488 Words | 2 Pages

The Devil’s Arithmetic, one of my favorite books, is a historical fiction novel written by Jane Yolen. This novel is about how Hannah the main character goes through the daily life in a concentration camp, and she goes through the terror of seeing people get chosen and, taken away from their families to never be seen again. In order to survive Hannah has to make tough survival decisions and the important lessons that Rivka teaches Hannah; therefore, making these themes important to survival in the concentration camps. One main theme throughout the book is how she has to make some survival decisions. One decision she has to make is the decision to not speak out against the Nazi’s, for she might get chosen if she does.

Read More
917 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout Geraldine Brooks's novel, The People of The Book, the Sarajevo Haggadah is used to reflect many aspects of personality in the characters Herr Mittl, Lola, Hanna, and Zahra and to help Ruth understand what her religion means to her. The Haggadah is used to reveal that Herr Florien Mittl is a liar. It also marks a significant change in Ruti’s life and helps explore what her religion means to her. The characters, especially the woman who are connected to the Haggadah are often much like Hanna in more than one way. Brook’s uses these characters to force the reader to think about how much they are like Hanna which helps the reader understand Hanna’s character better.

Read More
690 Words | 3 Pages

The Holocaust was one of the most horrifying times in the world for Jews. In the novel Night by Elie Wiesel, he retells his terrifying experience and existence within a concentration camp that was nothing more than the destruction of human life. As a thirteen year old boy, Elie Wiesel becomes got trapped in a world of hell. Auschwitz, a death camp for all Jews, was controlled by the German soldiers. Within Auschwitz all freedom and humanity is denied.

Read More
846 Words | 4 Pages

Through the development of the New World came hardship and war with not only the British but also the Native Americans whose land we cruelly took over. One source that discusses these times is the historical documentary “500 nations”, narrated by Gregory Harrison and produced by Kevin Costner, which first aired in April 1995. The film talks about the life of Native Americans while the Europeans came over. Another source that discusses the Indians hardships with the Europeans is the textbook A People & A Nation published in 2008 by Cengage and written by American Historian Mary Norton and Professor of History at Harvard University Jane Kamensky. Lastly, the primary document in Cengage Mindtap, “President Jackson Reports on Indian Removal” in

Read More
856 Words | 4 Pages

This quality of Hannah’s is more evident as the story

Read More
733 Words | 3 Pages

Watching a movie after reading the same book you will notice that are differences. In the secret garden book and movie there are a lot of differences. In the movie her parents die in an earthquake but in the book her parents die of an illness going around India. The book describes Colin’s eyes as wide in the movie his eyes are wide. Mary find the key in the dirt in the book in the movie she finds the key in her aunts room.

Read More
725 Words | 3 Pages

This makes the themes of belonging and family even more prominent. Foreshadowing is used within these flashbacks, as the events that occur in these begin to mirror those happening to Taylor. Readers discover that Hannah has also struggled with belonging, as in chapter 14 Hannah (Narnie) speaks of how she doesn’t know what to do since Webb’s disappearance. This foreshadows Taylor’s journey, as losing those close to her resulted in her lack of self-belonging.

Read More

More about The Devil's Arithmetic Movie Vs Book Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document