Edward
Mrs. Axtell
English -ELA 8
7 February 2023
The Giver Essay
“The life where nothing is unexpected or inconvenient or unusual. The life without colour, pain or past” (lois lowry) In this quote lies the very fabrication of The Givers community and what has happened due to sameness. Due to this quote there is so much to deduct and show for comparing and contrasting.
When we look at The Giver’s community there is one key difference from our community: the lack of distinctness. With that being said we have to compare the importance of being as we are now, and to the importance of being safe and protected from danger. So I am here to compare the families of The Giver compared to our families in our community as we are now, as well as, comparing the books from their community and our community.
…show more content…
(Lois Lowry pg.11&12) This is not the same as our community. We do not have the same limits but it is advised in our community to not have too many children.WHile our families show love through varying ways… We always have loved each other, But in The Giver we can see that love is an outdated word that is replaced by proud or glad as told by this quote “He had rehearsed them in his mind all the way from the Annex… [and]... “Jonas. You, of all people. Precision of language, please!” (lois lowry
The Giver - Think About What You've Read Write at least five sentences for each one! 1. Somehow, you come upon Jonas’s Community…a group of people living peacefully, with no poverty, no suffering, no pain, and no war. Should you tell them about pain and war and all those bad things, or not? List the arguments for telling them, and then list the arguments for not telling them.
Or unusual. The life without color, pain or past”. Because in the society of The Giver people are not different, they do not make choices or decisions. Everything is chosen for you. They are protected from everything both good and bad.
In the book "The Giver," the theme of sameness vs difference is a central theme. The community in which the protagonist, Jonas, lives is built on the principles of sameness, where everyone has the same clothes, houses, jobs, and even memories. The community values conformity, predictability, and stability over individuality, creativity, and change. This concept is emphasized in the quotes, “We’ve never completely mastered Sameness” and “Our people made that choice, the choice to go to Sameness.”
The Giver is based upon a society in the future that has eliminated most forms of individuality. The Council controls everything that the people in this society are allowed to do. The Council has put an end to anything that may cause their people any type of pain or emotion. These people are no longer allowed to make any decisions of their own, the Council determines everything to
Have you ever wondered if there could possibly be a community where no one has any idea of normal everyday things? Well then the Giver is just one example. The Giver has a long history, and it all started with Lois Lowry’s dad and how he forgot his memory of any bad thing and Lois Lowry started thinking what a Community would be like without any painful memories and she came up with The Giver. The Giver revolves around a young boy named Jonas who was chosen to be the new Receiver of Memory which is the highest honor in his community. While Jonas is training he gets all of the memories that everyone else in the community has and then starts to think why can’t other people have these memories he then comes up with a plan to escape the community
“We gained control of many things. But we had to let go of others” (Lowry). In other words, this means that to get what you want, you have to get rid of other things you have. Although there are many similarities between The Giver and our society, there are a lot more differences like families, rules, and personal freedoms. For starters there are many differences with families between their society and our society.
The Giver Essay The society of The Giver by Lois Lowry is a utopian society. They don’t have to make hard decisions, they don’t experience real pain and sorrow, and everything is provided for them. The Giver’s society could also be a dystopia because they don’t get to experience love or real feelings. One reason The Giver is a utopia because they do not have any choices.
Would you give up love and true happiness for a life without pain? In the dystopian novel The Giver, written by Lois Lowry, strong emotion is sacrificed for a peaceful environment. The depicted community at first appears to be a utopia, where hate and discrimination are abolished, but the emotionless society is quickly revealed to be dystopian as the story continues. They live in a world of sameness; there is no hunger, suffering, or war, but also no color, diversity, or sensuality. The protagonist, a twelve-year-old boy named Jonas, uncovers the truth about his community when he is assigned to be the Receiver of Memory, and acquires the memories from the past from an elder called the Giver.
Literary Analysis: The Giver Imagine a world where everything seems perfect but truly it is not as pleasant as it appears. In The Giver by Lois Lowry shows us a community in the future with no feelings at all. Jonas a twelve year old boy knows his life as it is and one evening he learns the truth about the community. Jonas set’s off into a adventure to change it all. Character,conflict,and symbolism makes the reader see thru the eyes of a twelve year old in a place of slavery disguised without anyone knowing it.
One of the main themes in “The Giver” is the importance of individuality. The people in the community are not given any freedom to be individuals. They are not allowed to be different, and this creates less understanding of the world. This is why the community needs a receiver to understand these things for them.
Another that changes the conflict of the story is Asher. As said in the quote: “What's wrong, Jonas it was only a game, Fiona said, you ruined it said Asher in an irritated voice” page 168 this shows that Asher is with the rest of the community (having no knowledge of before). In the movie there's also a part like in the novel (conflict wise) where Asher tries to block Jonas from escaping. This shows Asher doesn’t know what Jonas is doing is good and he’s with the rest of society. This is the part of the Giver where the conflicts are the same (man vs society).
While a dystopian society may seem perfect, the novel represents the limitations and expectations of an ideal community. The Giver displays the similarities and differences of our modern world versus the “flawless” model of a perfect society. In a perfect society, everyone must be the same. To make sure of synchronization in the community, there must be discipline.
Claude Mckay words, “If a man is not faithful to his own individuality, he cannot be loyal to anything” (qtd. Brainyquote.com). Without the sense of individualism, society would not grow and become independent, some might end up relying too much on others and become a burden or disloyal. However that is not all a waste, some people forget due to age and not a lack of individuality which Lois Lowry’s father can be an example. Her dad became senile and forgot about her sister's death; this inspired Lowry to write the novel The Giver. The narrative is a dystopian modern young adult novel about a twelve-year-old boy named Jonas who is a receiver of memories.
The Perfect Place The society Lowry depicts in The Giver is a utopian society; a perfect world as envisioned by its creators. It has removed fear, pain, famine, illness, conflict, and hatred, all things that most of people would like to eliminate in today’s society. In this utopian community, major problems are rare, only minor problems such as scraping your knee would happen. Even when this would happen there would be medications sent to them.
Pg. 8-”Two children -one male, one female-to each family unit. It was written very clearly in the rules.” This quote shows clearly how in each family unit in the community can have only one boy and one girl. Elsewhere would be a better place to live in than the community because Elsewhere has no rules that say that a person can have limited children.