"The Open Boat" Through the Lens of Reader-Response Theory: An Analysis
Collin B.B. Riley
Ivy Tech Community College
ENGL 215: Rhetoric and Argument
Dr. Varner
May 1, 2023
ABSTRACT
This essay analyzes Stephen Crane's short story "The Open Boat" through the lens of Reader-Response Theory. The essay is divided into three parts: Part One outlines the key features and methodologies of Reader-Response Theory, including its history and important figures. Part Two conducts a Literature Review of "The Open Boat," examining how scholars have historically interpreted the story and what debates exist within the scholarly community. Finally, Part Three offers an interpretation of the story, drawing on the research conducted for parts one and two.
…show more content…
Despite the bleakness of their situation, however, the men in the lifeboat never give up. They persevere in the face of adversity, using their wits and their strength to stay alive. This determination is reflected in the story's narrative structure, which is marked by a series of highs and lows. Just when it seems that the men have finally given up hope, they are buoyed by discovery or a moment of camaraderie. This structure reinforces the idea that survival is a constant struggle and that even small victories can make a difference. At the same time, however, "The Open Boat" is not simply a survival story. It is also a meditation on the meaning of life and the human condition. As the men grapple with their mortality, they are forced to confront the question of what it means to be alive. They are struck by the beauty of the world around them, even as they are overwhelmed by its power. They find moments of camaraderie and connection, even as they are isolated from the rest of humanity. In this way, "The Open Boat" is a story about the struggle to find meaning and purpose in a world that can be both beautiful and …show more content…
The men's connection is tested by their circumstances, and there are moments when they turn on each other in frustration and despair. This underscores the idea that human connection is not always straightforward and that it requires effort and understanding to maintain. In terms of its style, "The Open Boat" is notable for its spare, minimalist composition. Crane's writing is marked by its precision, as he uses simple language to convey complex ideas. This style is particularly effective in conveying the harshness and beauty of the natural world, and it helps to create a sense of immediacy and urgency in the story. Overall, "The Open Boat" is a powerful and thought-provoking work of literature that continues to resonate with readers today. Its themes of survival, human connection, and the search for meaning are timeless, and its vivid imagery and unique narrative structure make it a true masterpiece of American literature. Whether read as a work of naturalism, existentialism, or simply as a gripping tale of survival, "The Open Boat" is a story that will continue to captivate and inspire readers for generations to
The reader is able to feel empathy for the passengers, and the German U boat Captain. It is really a great experience for the
By using helplessness in the story, Richard Connell creates suspenseful situations. At the beginning of the story, Rainsford falls off the yacht and is left in the ocean. Nobody hears his cries for help, as they are “pinched off short as the bloodwarm waters of the Caribbean sea closed over his head”(15). While reading this, the reader feels the hopeless situation as they watch Rainsford struggle. The desperation is doubtless; the readers are hoping the yacht will notice he is gone and will come after him, but knowing that it probably will not.
‘Do you think there are any people on the boat, Papa?’” (McCarthy 221). This imagery is evidence that the boy and his father are constantly aware of issues that each task may bring, even if the environment seems to be quiet and free of danger. The father has taught the boy to be cautious of all people due to the fact that when
What did the narrator do in light of his experience on the sailboat? Do you think his reaction is a typical one of someone facing their
Primarily by how unbelievable the plot progression would be for them to float the entire trip in their boy-made barge. However, regardless of Horton’s unlikely simple intentions, the people on the boat are symbolic of the people that have yet to undergo change. This is a very comparable change that Erik is currently undergoing. The mistreatment that Erik faces displays the necessity to change into a better, caring person. These rascals show how important being a caring and devoted person is and ultimately reinforced these behaviors in Erik.
The setting and plot escalate the story by having the strange ship, the men being trapped, and the battle with the rats. One day while the men are in the light house they spot a ship heading towards the island. They couldn’t recognize the ship at first making is a mystery to them. When they discover that it belongs to a famous crew it started to create questions about why nobody was aborde. The crew at the lighthouse found out soon and yelled, “The rats!”(43).
On one dreadful night an enemy ship crashed into Kennedy’s boat resulting the boat to go up in flames, torn apart, and a stranded crew. However, Kennedy did not let these things interfere with getting remaining men to safety and out of harm’s way. After hours and hours of constant swimming and extreme dehydration, Kennedy somehow manages to get to an island along with his friend Ross. John Hersey portrays Kennedy as a courageous individual. The audience becomes well aware of the hard work that he puts in.
Imagine if you were born into a country filled with poverty, fear, anxiety, despair and sorrow. The pain and suffering you would go through every day was so violent that you and your family had given up on all measures of hope. Every day you would fear persecution and you couldn’t even feel safe in the comfort of your own home. But what if there was a sliver of hope of escaping this drama occurring in your homeland by leaving by boat. All this drama gone in a flash, wouldn’t you want to try?
Utilization of the mother’s “maiden name” for the boat is signifying the continuation of legacy and tradition. Macleod’s portrayal of the name being “stenciled in black” (224) while the entire boat is light green is contrasting in the sense that black connotes negativity and light green is symbolistic of life. The boat is representative of the father and within the father’ life, the mother has limited the father into obligations and not advancement. Unchanging view of the mother: “She despised disorder in rooms and in houses and in hours and in lives”. Macleod’s referral to “in hours” signifies that over time the mother prefers upholding of traditions and approves merely duties and nothing beyond the routine.
This along with Freeman’s use of emotional phrases makes the audience feel guilty, angry, and sympathetic toward dying oceanic creatures. For example, within the sixth paragraph there is a sentence that states, “look to the tragic tale of Pacific bluefin tuna, that’s been whittled down to a woeful 2.6 percent of its historic population” (Freemen). The words “tragic”, “whittled”, and “woeful” are all words that appeal to the emotion of sadness. These strong words make people feel concerned, compelling them to take action toward saving marine life.
Furthermore, the aspect of discovery can also be conveyed in a different ways. The fact that sometimes people, like myself, are being forced to find a new place which can result a negative and positive emotional impact, or future possibilities. In ‘The Little Refugee’, Bruce Whatley illustrates a small shabby boat jam-packed with worried people who are desperate to find new life and hope, whereas Hurley’s his discovery was being forced by his inner-life. Dull and grey-black smoky colours symbolize the overwhelming fear as seen through the body language of the people. And the dominance of the stormy clouds adds to the uncertainty, and the salience draws our eyes to the boat, helping us to easily relate to the terrifying encounters.
The Danger That Lies In The Sea of Self Sacrifice By Mateo Bochinski The capacity of one's ability to self-sacrifice is often measured by their actions in a situation of instability. Whether one can withstand the situation with a degree of resilience or shatter under the burden is dependent on the person’s way of life and their ideas of fulfillment. For a parent the overwhelming desire to sacrifice for the well-being of their family, is thought to play a role in fulfillment. However, the short story “The Boat” by Alistair Mcleod exemplifies the potential self-sacrifice can have in the role of destruction. Through the narrator's (the son’s) account, the story follows the life of a rural fishing family with set beliefs and values instilled
The Captain says, “Sacrifices are a part of life.” As a human, we don’t know the main purpose of life if you don’t experience this kind of attitude. To sacrifice for something, or someone to be a better version of ourselves. The story is interesting, entertaining
As a 17-year-old child that the author was, and according to our own experience, the path from young to mature is filled with all kinds of trauma, this process is also usually involuntary, and there is no escape. I believe the author is using the voice of the boat to express his current situation: although tormented by numberless trauma, somehow he fails to mature, live the life that is still full of trauma, and he thinks this is not wrong. Maybe because Rimbaud did not want to fit in the rest of the world, he did not want to be categorized as one simple concept. But all those descriptions of natural views cannot be treated as any form of trauma, because they are full of colorful description and are often used to bring joy to the reader, they are usually used to impress
The Boatswain is foul-mouthed, and angers those of royalty, even Gonzalo who reminds him that the king is on board the ship. Despite this, the Boatswain ignores all the non-sense of praying or giving respect to the upper-class, and relies on his natural instincts and expertise on how to keep the boat steady. This shows readers that no matter what religion,race, or class you are, humanity is on all the same level when it comes to toying with death. The