Virginia Plan Vs New Jersey Plan
In the year 1787, in the United States, the constitutional convention meet to solve the problems from the original constitution, the articles of confederation. There goal was to either write a new constitution, or amend the original constitution with a stronger central government. When the convention first started, the representatives from Virginia took a leading role and proposed the first plan, known as the Virginia Plan. With this plan, it was proposed that the articles of confederation be completely replaced with a new constitution. Many states opposed this plan and the representatives from New Jersey proposed a new plan, known as the New Jersey Plan. This plan proposed that the article of confederation was amended, instead of completely rewritten. Both of these plans had opposition and it was clear that some compromises needed to be made on both sides. On May 25th, 1987, the first official day of the Constitutional Convention, Edmund Randolph, one of the representatives from Virginia, proposed a new constitution in the Virginia Plan. This plan wanted to strengthen the national government with three branches, the bicameral legislative branch, the executive branch, and the judicial branch. The Virginia Plan also wanted to get rid of the one-state/ one-vote system, and have them number of …show more content…
This plan proposed that there would be a unicameral legislature, which would give each state one vote, just like the articles of confederation had. There would also be an executive branch with more than one officer that held little power, instead of just one president, and a supreme court. Since this plan kept the one-state/ one-vote system, it was strongly supported by small state. This plan also had opposition, and it was clear that a compromise needed to be made between the Virginia Plan and the New Jersey
Compare And Contrast The Virginia Plan Vs New Jersey Plan
309 Words | 2 PagesIn 1978, two plans were put forth regarding how each state in the union would be represented in the national legislature. The two plans put forth were the, “Virginia Plan” (which favored big states), and the “New Jersey Plan.” (which favored small states) Edmund Randolph of Virginia proposed the Virginia plan. The plan laid out a system in which states would be represented in the national legislature based on their population and/or by how much revenue they contributed to the national government.
Compare And Contrast The Virginia Plan Vs New Jersey Plan
203 Words | 1 PagesThe Lower house would be elected by the people, but the Upper house would be elected by the Lower house. The New Jersey Plan explained that the Executive Branch would be chosen by Congress, and the elected individuals would only serve a single term. Some people were subject to recall on request of state governors.
Compare And Contrast The Virginia Plan Vs New Jersey Plan
370 Words | 2 PagesI believe that the Virginia plan is much wiser than the New Jersey plan because it was proportional, or corresponding in size, to the population in state. The best plan is this one because it has two legislative houses (Bicameral), the Senate and the House of Representatives. We each get to vote for the representatives we want. The New Jersey plan only has one Legislative house (unicameral) and it only gets one vote for each state this is what deprived the smaller states from equality. The New Jersey Plan had so many disagreements that it had to appoint a “grand committee” and then it was known as the Great Compromise (An agreement between two or more sides in which each side gives up what some of what it wants).
How Did The Virginia Plan A New Constitution
315 Words | 2 PagesFinal Exam Part I: QA2 The Virginia Plan a New Constitution The Virginia Plan proposed a new Constitution designed as a republic and a strong national government. The most distinguished feature of the plan created structural changes as well as delegated sovereignty to the Federal government and the people. This transfer of power diminished the role of the States in the national government. The Virginia Plan structurally replaced the unicameral Congress by separating federal power among three branches of government, a bicameral legislature, an executive and a judiciary.
Difference Between Virginia And New Jersey Plan
1276 Words | 6 PagesIn Virginia plan some of the specific powers include, that the national legislature to consent in all situations to which the separate states are unskilled or in which United States consistency may be disturbed by the claim of individual regulation and also assign inferior tribunals. The executive has the power to carry into execution of national laws, and to adverse any legislative act which shall not be passed after wards unless through permission from two third of each branch of national legislature. The judiciary has the power to handle all the circumstances regarding collection of national revenue, impeachment of any state, officers and questions that comprise of national coherence. In New Jersey plan some of the powers that are presented are partially similar to those in Virginia plans but not completely
Compare And Contrast The Virginia And The Constitutional Convention
333 Words | 2 PagesThe Constitutional Convention resulted in many different plans and ideas. The Virginia Plan was proposed by Edmund Randolph, but written by James Madison. The plan stated that people should have representation based on how many people are in their state. Essentially, this boils down to representation based on population. The New Jersey plan was proposed by William Patterson.
The Virginia (Large States) Plan And The New Jersey
595 Words | 3 PagesThe main divisions at the Constitutional Convention were known as “The Virginia (Large States) Plan” and “The New Jersey (Small States) Plan.” The Virginia Plan was introduced by Governor Edmund Randolph of Virginia, on May 29, 1787, at the convention and was prepared by James Madison. Madison, who was a “member of the Continental Congress” (Howard, 2008, p. 12), had faith in the Virginia Plan and thought it would be the best proposal to enforce the laws and assist the government in collecting taxes from the people (Library of Virginia, n.d.). The Virginian delegates planned to “rid the country of the Articles of Confederation, develop two houses of Congress, enact a federal judiciary, give Congress the right to elect a president, and to allow Congress the right to veto the actions of the state” (Schultz, 2010, p. 125).
Pros And Cons Of The Constitutional Convention
744 Words | 3 PagesLora Reed Ontiveros P. Sci 180 01 July, 2017 The Constitutional Convention In February of 1787, Congress decided that a convention should assemble to amend the Articles of Confederation. The Constitutional Convention was held by a small body of well-respected delegates in the Assembly Room of Independence Hall in Philadelphia, to inaugurate a new union. This convention ultimately impelled three crucial proposals, the Virginia and New Jersey Plan, and the Connecticut Compromise, which led to the nation’s fist Constitution.
The Virginia Plan Was A Constitutional Convention In 1787
998 Words | 4 PagesThe Virginia Plan After events such as the Shays’ rebellion, in 1787, the founding fathers then called in place a constitutional convention to discuss the Articles of Confederation and its future. The constitutional convention on May 25th, 1787, was the beginning of many long and tension filled months that would be needed to articulate the Constitution we know of today. The convention ended on September 17, 1787. During that period, there were many plans that were discussed and argued. The first one mentioned was the Virginia Plan also known as the Randolph Plan, by Edmund Randolph.
One Of The Plans Presented At The Constitutional Convention
1077 Words | 5 PagesOne of the plans presented at the Constitutional Convention was the Virginia Plan. Virginia delegate Edmund Randolph presented this plan at the beginning of the Convention. He, George Washington, and the other Virginia delegates came up with this idea while waiting for the Convention to begin. They came up with the Virginia Plan because the Articles of Confederation had many problems associated with it and the delegates wanted to fix them.
What Are The Articles Of Confederation Related To The Formation Of Government
657 Words | 3 PagesThis proposal was presented in the form of fifteen resolutions that detailed reasons why the Articles of Confederation should be radically altered and plans for a strong National Government that could collect taxes and make and enforce laws. This was also the first document to produce a separation of powers into an executive, legislative, and judicial branch in a national government. Moreover, there is a feature of a bicameral legislature, which is two houses consisting of the House of Representatives and the Senate would be based on state representation. The people of each state shall elect the first branch of the national legislature, and those that are selected shall select people in the second branch. The national legislature shall have the power to elect a national executive with the authority to execute the national laws and taxes.
Compare And Contrast The Articles Of Confederation
455 Words | 2 PagesThere was no regulation of trade and each state printed its own currency. This resulted in an un-stable and inconsistent economy. In 1787 55 delegates from the states met with the purpose of amending the Articles of Confederation. What actually took place that day was the creation of something that would remain our governments foundation for many years. The question facing the delegates was what should the new government be based on? There were two plans that were considered, the New Jersey Plan and the Virginia Plan.
Constitutional Convention Dbq
844 Words | 4 PagesThe Constitutional Convention was a meeting held in Philadelphia in 1787 to frame the Constitution. During this convention, the thirteen original states or colonies were the first to ratify this document. Under the Articles of Confederation, many leaders believed that the central government did not have enough authority. Therefore, instead of amending the Articles of Confederation, delegates, from different states, drafted a new written document with rules and regulations for a new federal government. In this government, three branches of government were formed: legislative, judicial and executive.
The Three Compromises Made In The Constitutional Convention
1593 Words | 7 PagesObviously, smaller states were not pleased with that plan. They thought that larger states could easily overrule them in congress. So William Paterson created a plan called the New Jersey Plan. It as well had the same three branches but, the plan provided legislators to have only one house. Each state would only one vote in the legislator, regardless of the population.
Constitutional Convention Pros And Cons
543 Words | 3 PagesThe New Jersey Plan was a multi person Executive Branch chosen by Congress. They had one Supreme Court which was establish by the Executive Branch. Which it wasn’t much different by the Articles of
More about Virginia Plan Vs New Jersey Plan
Compare And Contrast The Virginia Plan Vs New Jersey Plan
309 Words | 2 PagesCompare And Contrast The Virginia Plan Vs New Jersey Plan
203 Words | 1 PagesCompare And Contrast The Virginia Plan Vs New Jersey Plan
370 Words | 2 PagesHow Did The Virginia Plan A New Constitution
315 Words | 2 PagesDifference Between Virginia And New Jersey Plan
1276 Words | 6 PagesCompare And Contrast The Virginia And The Constitutional Convention
333 Words | 2 PagesThe Virginia (Large States) Plan And The New Jersey
595 Words | 3 PagesPros And Cons Of The Constitutional Convention
744 Words | 3 PagesThe Virginia Plan Was A Constitutional Convention In 1787
998 Words | 4 PagesOne Of The Plans Presented At The Constitutional Convention
1077 Words | 5 PagesWhat Are The Articles Of Confederation Related To The Formation Of Government
657 Words | 3 PagesCompare And Contrast The Articles Of Confederation
455 Words | 2 PagesConstitutional Convention Dbq
844 Words | 4 PagesThe Three Compromises Made In The Constitutional Convention
1593 Words | 7 PagesConstitutional Convention Pros And Cons
543 Words | 3 Pages