ipl-logo

Webb Vs Edwards Case Study

978 Words4 Pages

Legal studies assessment
1. The name of the case is Webb v Edwards [2018] NSWDC 67
- The parties involved in this case are:
- Tony Webb (Plaintiff)
- Lyndon John Edwards (Defendant)

On Tuesday the 15th of May 2007 Tony Webb was driving on the Mitchell Highway at around 7:05 am to his work at Dubbo from his home at Narromine, NSW. As he began to approach a left bend in the highway he encountered an oncoming large prime mover which was transporting an oversized agricultural scarifier, Driven by Lyndon John Edwards. Tony Webb attempted to avoid the collision by veering to his left, but a side-swipe collision occurred, mechanical implements were needed to cut Tony Webb out of the wreckage of the car. As a result of the accident Tony Webb sustained …show more content…

Medical professionals have described tony webs post-accident situation as a very complicated case.
- The district court of New south wales is the original jurisdiction for this case.
- The assessed amount to be paid was $2,076,707.88 but after applying the agreed 20% apportionment because of the plaintiff's contributory negligence the amount to be paid by Lyndon John Edwards, the defendant was $1,661,366.20.
- The ratio decendi was based on the legal precedent of a previous case.

2. Common law countries use the adversarial system, the Adversary system is a system of trial in which two parties battle for an impartial third party who tries to reach a fair and equal judgment. The following features of the adversarial system keep the trial fair and unbiased. The two parties have full control of the proceedings and are responsible for the preparation of their case and the presentation, this allows the parties to feel satisfied …show more content…

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander customary law does not specifically receive recognition in the Australian constitution and references that allow racial discrimination by the commonwealth are still present in the constitution. Societies views are changing and the importance of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander customary law and culture is now becoming more important as it is believed that the legal system must reflect the people it serves. Customary law is still seen as the soft version of the justice system by many people so the idea of integrating it into Australian law isn’t supported by many individuals. Circle sentencing is one way that aboriginal customary law is beginning to be integrated into the legal system as it is allowing aboriginals to achieve justice in a more traditional way while still abiding by the Australian constitution.

5. International laws govern how countries and states should interact with each other international law has an impact on domestic laws through human rights treaties, importing and exporting of goods and global communications and connections. The Mabo case reflects this because the domestic law at the time didn’t match the international

Show More
Related

R V Dean Case Study

1700 Words | 7 Pages

The Australian Crime Commission: the sentencing of offenders in the New South Wales criminal justice system Cases: - R v Dean [2013] NSWSC 1027 - R v David John STEVENS [2014] NSWDC 197 Section One Case 1: R v Dean [2013] Elements of the offence: Actus Reus: Roger Dean pleaded guilty to eleven counts of murder by way of reckless indifference to human life, and eight counts of recklessly causing grievous bodily harm ( s 18 and s 35 (2) Crimes Act 1990) . The offence occurred in the early hours of November 18th , 2011. The actus reus of the offender, Roger Dean has been proved by the prosecution upon the investigation of the case. CCTV footage from the Quaker’s Hill Nursing Home shows Roger Dean repeatedly walking in and out of multiple

Read More

The Case Of Lindy Chamberlain

2102 Words | 9 Pages

The source examines the impact of victims being wrongfully convicted and imprisoned, and the international approach to the issue. Australia has signed the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR) signed by the Australian government in 1972, which states once a person has been wrongfully convicted and they have received a punishment, by law they are entitled to compensation unless its proved there is an unknown fact which has arisen. However, this was never adopted into Australian law, as a result any individual wrongfully convicted and imprisoned isn’t entitled to any compensation under Australian law. Australia’s commitments to signing this is that all states and territories must meet their obligations under article 14 (6) which are incorporation of the domestic article into domestic legislation to ensure a legal right to compensation. Though a state or territory government does have the ability to make an ex gratia payment to a wrongfully convicted individual through a request or their own doing.

Read More

Case Of R V Kokopenace

891 Words | 4 Pages

According to the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms, “Any person charged with an offence has the right to be presumed innocent until proven guilty according to law in a fair and public hearing by an independent and impartial tribunal” (Legislative Services Branch, 2017, para. 11). In the significant Canadian case R. v. Kokopenace, an Aboriginal man was tried by an unfair jury as the community where the trial took place was 25 percent First Nations, however, the jury only included 4 percent of First Nations people (Pinder, 2015). This report will summarize the major facts of the case, court’s decisions, and dissenting opinions of the judges. Clifford Kokopenace was an Aboriginal man who lived on the Grassy Narrows First Nations reserve

Read More

Explain Why The Provincial Government Can Combine Two Adjacent Provinces

692 Words | 3 Pages

The parties decide what evidence to present, what witnesses to call, and how to question them. The judge is to be a neutral during the process and uphold the principles of fairness and equality, although he does make determinations of fact and law. The adversarial system is usually found in places with a common law system. In an inquisitorial hearing, the judge has a more prominent and active role in regards to evidence and questioning the witnesses. The inquisitorial system is typically found in places with a civil law system.

Read More

Consider The Supreme Court Of Canada's 2012 Decision In R V Ipeelee

899 Words | 4 Pages

This criminal code encourages sentencing judges to have recourse to a restorative approach to sentencing. Also, the enactment of s. 718.2 (e) is a definite direction by Parliament to pay particular attention to the circumstances of aboriginal offenders during the sentencing process because those circumstances are unique and different from those of non-Aboriginal offenders. Further, when sentencing Aboriginal offenders, courts must take judicial notice of such matters as the history of colonization, displacement, and residential schools. And they should look at how that history continues to translate into lower educational accomplishment, lower income, higher unemployment, higher rates of substance abuse, suicide, and, of course, higher levels of imprisonment of Aboriginal peoples. (Canadian Law, an Introduction 6th Edition: Neil Boyd 2015; page,

Read More

Impact Of The Mabo Decision

949 Words | 4 Pages

One of the most significant events in Aboriginal peoples struggle for rights in Australia was the Mabo decision in 1992. This event took away the myth of terra nullius from Australian law and would recognise rights that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples have to the land and waters according to tradition. Thus, creating way for the legal recognition of native land titles (Loos & Mabo, 2013). This essay will explain the impact of the Mabo decision, what events led to this event and what impact this has on Australian people today.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Circle Justice Vs Us Criminal Justice System

256 Words | 2 Pages

Circle Justice vs. US Criminal Justice System Do you want to know the differences between the Circle Justice System and the US Criminal Justice System? Circle Justice is a punishment but it’s also a way of healing. The Circle has lots of great pros but also has cons.

Read More

Prison Rates In Australia Essay

512 Words | 3 Pages

International prison population statistics have found that the female prison population is increasing at a faster rate than the male prison population. Research has confirmed that, in the majority of countries, the male imprisonment rate is predominantly larger than that of the female imprisonment rate, however this does not apply to indigenous women within Australia. Overwhelming research shows that the imprisonment rate for indigenous women within Australia has increased at a significantly faster rate compared to indigenous males, most clearly highlighted through the general trends in prison rates within the last decade. This essay will discuss how the presence of indigeneity plays a key role in explaining the disparity between male and female imprisonment rates, further explaining why indigenous women are incarcerated at significantly highly rates. Moreover, there are numerous sociological and criminological theories, which provide an explanation for the disparity of male and female imprisonment rates.

Read More

Gnych & Anor V Polish Club Case Study

879 Words | 4 Pages

Throughout the court case Mr Reynolds was asked quite a lot of questions and he replied to most of it with ease providing resources and proof to back his argument. Test applied: Firstly MR. REYNOLDS described to the judges all the laws that Polish Club limited breached.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Circle Of Justice Vs Criminal Justice

394 Words | 2 Pages

Circle of Justice vs. The Criminal Justice System Everyone is innocent until proven guilty in the court of law. The Circle Justice system is the native American way of justice. The Criminal Justice system is the American way of justice. Both of the systems are alike, but they sometimes have different outcomes.

Read More

Advantages And Disadvantages Of The Common Law System

1268 Words | 6 Pages

The law is meant to provide justice to people. So the main advantages of the common law system is that it is consistent, adaptive, equal and independent. Consistency is achieved through the precedent as the base for the decisions, not the personal attitudes of the judges. The parties, involved in the process, are expecting that their case would be decided as the similar one, it creates certainty in getting equal justice and stability. Precedents are usually developed in the higher courts by the senior

Read More

Essay On Monism Vs Dualism

1225 Words | 5 Pages

There are reasons for this, first is that, internal implementation of international law is always conditioned by a rule of the state’s municipal law. Clearly stating that international law’ internal interpretation is always governed by the municipal constitution. Second is that in national courts, even a monist country, their courts may fail sometimes to execute treaties which are binding under international law. United State law is an example of non-self-executing treaty. While dualist country’s courts, unincorporated treaties are given limited effect on the internal process.

Read More

Disadvantages Of Judicial Precedents

702 Words | 3 Pages

Different judges will have different interpretation of cases; hence, they may bind a single case with various precedents making it more difficult to pass a judgment. In this type of situation even competent judges may find it complicated to decide on the ‘ratio decidendi’. Nevertheless, there are a lot of case laws and deciding which case law best appropriates to a case is not always an easy task, as it is time consuming and very stressful to find the most suitable precedent. Therefore, not only the doctrine of judicial precedent has the disadvantage of being complex, while the judges are discussing which case law to apply to a specific case, justice is at the same time being delayed.

Read More

Power Politics: The Concept Of International Law

1867 Words | 8 Pages

Ever since the establishment of state sovereignty through Westphalia treaty we have seen various international laws emerging in the international world of politics. Originally, International Laws are shaped by group of kingdoms or states through treaties which commonly contains temporary ceasefires and to not so less extent trade conducts. In this day and age though, international laws are instigated from several International Institutions (i.e.: United Nations) which addresses issues ranging from territorial borders to human rights violations. Numerous international laws in the modern world right now are considered ‘binding’ connoting that it is obliged to adhere to it; similar to how it is required for us as citizens to adhere to our national

Read More

Examples Of Arguments Against Ravisia

967 Words | 4 Pages

Speech of Respondent: • The first issue before the Court is, if Ravisia state violated international law during the presence of military forces in Alicanto. The answer to this question is “NO” for following reasons: Your Excellency, before we give concrete examples of why Ravisia’s troop presence on territory of Alicanto is legally, I would like to draw your attention to the fact, when Alicanto police have admitted their inability to eliminate the illegal actions of their own country. During this time, the area of Alicanto and Benuu has become repeatedly an area of controversy, where were a number of violent acts, terror and mass violation of human rights and fundamental freedoms, the death of civilians, there were signs of ethnic cleansing. Your Excellency, Alicanto not only failed to ensure implementation resolution number 5440, passed by UN security council, but the situation was getting worse day by day. Alicanto failed to ensure fulfillment of the obligations regarding the protection of human rights.

Read More

More about Webb Vs Edwards Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document