ipl-logo

Wilfred Owen And Robert Frost

1020 Words5 Pages

Wilfred Owen and Robert Frost successfully convey the brutal, cruel and inhumane theme of violence in their eye-opening poems, 'Disabled ' and 'Out, Out '. Set during the hard times of war, these poems portray different war-related themes and carry their own distinctive similarities and differences, contrasting with one another.

On one hand we have 'Disabled, ' written by Wilfred Owen with his intense experience as a soldier in the First World War. His past experience inspires his piece of poetry heavily. Whereas, on the other hand, we have 'Out, Out 's poet; Robert Frost, a British-settled American who returned from England at the start of World War One. He was regarded as the unofficial "poet laureate" of the United States. (Note that both the poems are written and set during the World War One.)

War is a state of prolonged violent large-scale conflict involving two or more groups of people. It is the most extreme form of collective violence, in the present and the past. Both the poems portray the theme of violence in a different manner In 'Disabled, ' the victim of violence is an underaged young man who purposely joined the army and had his limbs shot off in a war. It is an example of direct violence from war. Whereas 'Out, Out ' displays a boy who gets his hand chopped off from a buzz saw while doing a man 's job (again pointing to underaged boys doing an older man 's work), and eventually dying. This is an example of an indirect violence from the effects of war

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of Thomas Paine And Olaudah Equiano

    273 Words  | 2 Pages

    Thomas Paine and Olaudah Equiano dispute the belief that Britain is more civilized than the countries it has colonized. Paine, as an upper class white man, is able to protest the power structure of Britain by proclaiming that the British government led by the aristocracy law of primogeniture is unethical and unnatural in his essay The Rights of Man that questions the nobility and the competence of the aristocracy who rule the empire of Britain. He argues that governments built on military conquests and aristocracy are based on despotism and cannot establish a fair and effective government for the people. Equiano, on the other hand, must disguise his voice as a freed African slave who has shown through his writing that he is equivalently or exceedingly capable of communicating and behaving as any white man in the upper and middle classes of Britain.

    Read More

  • Ted Hughes 'Bayonet Charge' And Wilfred Owen's Exposure

    1571 Words  | 7 Pages

    Both Ted Hughes and Wilfred Owen present war in their poems “Bayonet Charge” and “Exposure”, respectively, as terrifying experiences, repeatedly mentioning the honest pointlessness of the entire ordeal to enhance the futility of the soldiers' deaths. Hughes’ “Bayonet Charge” focuses on one person's emotional struggle with their actions, displaying the disorientating and dehumanising qualities of war. Owen’s “Exposure”, on the other hand, depicts the impacts of war on the protagonists' nation, displaying the monotonous and unending futility of the situation by depicting the fate of soldiers who perished from hypothermia, exposed to the horrific conditions of open trench warfare before dawn. The use of third-person singular pronouns in “Bayonet

    Read More

  • Examples Of Emasculation In Regeneration

    798 Words  | 4 Pages

    This contempt of emasculations is also made clear in Owen 's "Disabled". This poem discusses the faith of a teen soldier who has lost his limbs in the trenches and is confined to his wheelchair, utterly helpless. Relationships

    Read More

  • Bruce Dawe's Poems 'Homecoming And Weapons Training'

    1397 Words  | 6 Pages

    We live in a world where we have to hide to make love, while violence is practiced in broad daylight. John Lennon. Based on his own reading and reflection, Bruce Dawe constructs his attitudes towards war in his poems, Homecoming and Weapons Training, believing it to be lacking sense historically and ultimately futile. By specifically addressing an Australian cultural context, the poet exposes a universal appeal in that the insensitivity and anonymity are common attitudes towards soldiers during war. Dawe clearly expresses his ‘anti-war sentiment’ through his use of language and imagery as he examines the dehumanising aspects of war and its brutal reality.

    Read More

  • Explore The Effects Of Conflict In 'Remains'

    795 Words  | 4 Pages

    Compare how the effects of conflict are presented in ‘Remains’ and one other poem you have studied? ‘Remains’ by Wilfred Owen is a war poem that presents an unnamed conflict where the soldier shoots the looter, but is unsure whether the man was armed or not. If the latter case, the shooting would have been unnecessary and would be thought as an act of murder. This acts as an emotional conflict arising to the soldier due to the situation. Similarly, in ‘Poppies’, the mother suffers from an emotional conflict arising from her yearning for her son as the mother seems to be speaking to the memories of her son.

    Read More

  • Comparison Of Do Not Weep Maiden By Gwendolyn Brooks

    220 Words  | 1 Pages

    In both texts, the Universal Theme is that war takes away the things we love and hold dear to ourselves. We can see an example of this in Gwendolyn Brooks’ poem, the sonnet-ballad

    Read More

  • To Lucasta On Going To War Poem Analysis

    1005 Words  | 5 Pages

    Compare and contrast essay The two sets of poems share the same topic which is living through war, but they have different tones, diction, settings and symbols. Poetry set one views war as a way of gaining honor while set two claims that it’s a waste of lives and all these opposing ideas are due to the different timeline. Tone and diction are one of the most important elements in poetry, because tone is the general character or attitude of a place in a piece of writing, while diction is the choice and use of words and phrases in speech or writing. They can be simply differentiated in general terms as the way or style of speech of a person and the different pitches expressed due to the different emotions being experienced by him/her during speaking which I will go further in detail by the end of this essay.

    Read More

  • Comparing Disabled And Wilfred Frost's Out, Out And Disabled

    1007 Words  | 5 Pages

    The two poems “Out, Out” and “Disabled” share similar points of view but have completely different structures. The poem “Disabled” was written in 1917 by a young man called Wilfred Owen. It expresses the bitter thoughts of a teenaged veteran who lost his legs in World War I. It describes the horrible effects of the brutal war and the hardships of disability. On the other hand, the poem “Out, Out” was written in 1916 by Robert Frost.

    Read More

  • Two Dead Boys Poem Analysis

    254 Words  | 2 Pages

    These two poems were found from the internet. The first poem is ‘Two Dead Boys’ by Tyler Rager. The second is called ‘Don’t Change on my Account’ by Shel Silverstien. The first poem is full of contradiction and irony.

    Read More

  • Differences And Diction In Borden And Owen's Poetry

    964 Words  | 4 Pages

    Comparative Essay How can different perceptions about one topic be expressed in poetry? The main theme that the two sets of poems convey is war, but it’s expressed in different point of views through the use of diction that builds tone. The tones of these poems play a big role in conveying the differences between the different eras that these poems are written in, and shows how societies have changed from the Victorian era till the time of World War I. The diction and tone in Borden and Owen’s poems is so much different than the diction and tone in Lovelace and Tennyson’s poems due to different perspectives and point of views. In all four poems the main idea is war, but each set conveys a perspective of war, a positive perspective

    Read More

  • A Poetic Analysis Of 'Disabled' By Wilfred Owen

    1450 Words  | 6 Pages

    "Disabled" by Wilfred Owen is a poetic analysis of war that exposes the struggles of adjusting to civilian life. A deeper analysis of "Disabled" reveals the irony of war; a soldier's fight for his country's freedom which results in the sacrifice of his mental and physical freedom. The soldiers and their families suffer from the scars and traumatic events of the war daily, while those that benefit can remain in oblivion of their suffering. Owen’s "Disabled" gives the readers an intimate poem detailing the tragic loss of humanity that a soldier suffers. Because of the war, the soldier has been reduced in mind and body.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Disabled And The Bright Lights Of Sarajevo

    982 Words  | 4 Pages

    In the poems “Disabled” by Wilfred Owen and “The Bright Lights of Sarajevo” by Tony Harrison, both poems present the truths of war. However, both differ in terms of setting and contrast that help depicts the similarities between their theme. Disabled takes place within World War I as Owen vividly describes the subject’s amputation, but the poem is centered around the subject’s adjustment to civilian life after war. In The Bright Lights of Sarajevo although Harrison discusses the consequences of partaking in war in the town, he illustrates the way in which life goes on regardless the horrific impact. Through use of setting and contrast, both poets contribute to presenting the theme of the realities of war.

    Read More

  • The Senttry Wilfred Owen Analysis

    894 Words  | 4 Pages

    Wilfred Owen was one of the main English poets of World War 1, whose work was gigantically affected by Siegfried Sassoon and the occasions that he witnesses whilst battling as a fighter. 'The Sentry ' and 'Dulce et Decorum Est ' are both stunning and reasonable war lyrics that were utilized to uncover the detestations of war from the officers on the hatreds of trenches and gas fighting, they tested and unmistakable difference a distinct difference to general society impression of war, passed on by disseminator writers, for example, Rupert Brooke. 'Dulce et respectability Est ' and the sentry both uncover the genuine environment and conditions that the troopers were existing and battling in. Specifically The Sentry contains numerous utilization of "Slush" and "Slime" connection to the sentiments of filthy, messy hardships. 'The Sentry ' by Wilfred Owen was composed in 1917 and is Owen 's record of seeing a man on sentry obligation harmed by a shell that has blasted close him.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Last Laugh By Wilfred Owen

    1730 Words  | 7 Pages

    Within the context of recent history, Wilfred Owen is often considered the greatest writer of modern British war poetry. Composing the vast majority of his poems in a one-year time span, Owen found inspiration from his personal experiences fighting in World War I and fellow poets joining in the fight around him. Born in 1893, Owen grew up the oldest of four children, enjoying a particularly close relationship with his mother while his father remained distant. Owen graduated from Shrewsbury Technical School at age eighteen. Afterwards, Owen took numerous odd jobs throughout Europe, seemingly at a loss for his purpose in life.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Maya Angelou's 'Still I Rise'

    1362 Words  | 6 Pages

    ‘Still I Rise’ by the American, Maya Angelou presents the character of a black woman who is oppressed in the 1970s but refuses to accept this. ‘Disabled’ by Wilfred Owen, however, is concerned with a character who is ‘broken’ after the disabilities he suffers in the First World War at the beginning of the twentieth century. The poem ‘Still I Rise’ is about a woman who discloses that she will overcome anything due to her self-confidence. The line ‘But still, like dust, I’ll rise’ is a metaphor that expresses that she will not be downtrodden by others.

    Read More

More about Wilfred Owen And Robert Frost

Open Document