ipl-logo

Analysis Of The Article 'Smacking Is Distinct From Child Abuse'

559 Words3 Pages

Smacking is Distinct from Child Abuse
(Personal Response)
The article ‘Smacking is Distinct from Child Abuse’ published in the Herald Sun on October 16th 2009, written by Cheryl Critchley discusses Critchley views and opinions on whether or not smacking is child abuse.
A claim made by Critchley in her first two sentences is that if parents do smack their children they are accused of child abuse and not being able to control their kids. If parents don’t smack their kids then it’s the opposite, they are thought to be ‘soft touches’ who let their kids run wild. I feel that what Critchley has claimed is true but a swift tap on the bum or smack (within reason) shouldn’t be considered child abuse because child abuse and discipline are two different things. Discipline is training a person to obey rules and have the correct behaviour by using punishment to correct their misconduct, light physical punishment is considered as …show more content…

Critchley believes that smacking a child is counterproductive to their development and it teaches the child that violence is the solution to any problem. Whilst Critchley believes this she still vouches that not all parents who use smacking as a form of discipline are child abusers. I agree with Critchley’s views on smacking children and will strive to keep them my whole life. But what’s more is that I believe the majority of people who smack their kids are not child abusers they just want to teach their child that it is seriously not ok to do what they were doing to provoke the parent to smack them. On the other hand though, there are the minority of parents that just use smacking to abuse their children so there is a time where we have to draw the line as to whether smacking is being used to abuse the child or if it’s being used to enforce good

Show More
Related

Summary Of No Spanking No Time-Out, No Problems By Khazan

1016 Words | 5 Pages

In the article “No Spanking, No Time-out, No Problems”, Olga Khazan uses many rhetorical strategies to support and persuade her audience. That traditional punishment methods of parents will not change a child’s/children’s unruly behavior overall, but positive reinforcement will increase the chances of better behavior not only now, but in the future as well. “Positive reinforcement is the presentation of a pleasurable consequence following a behavior” (Craighead). This twist to traditional discipline teaches children to work towards a resolution instead of teaching them to lean toward violence. “For example, the way that parents discipline their children is how children discipline their peers” (Khazan).

Read More

Summary Of No Spanking No Time-Out, No Problem By Khazan

994 Words | 4 Pages

The issue Khazan discusses in “No Spanking, No Time-Out, No Problems”, parents need to change their own behavior, before wanting to change their child’s behavior. Khazan confronts the issue of punishment along with behavior using a persuasive writing style to share her thoughts on punishment: “Punishment might make you feel better, but it won’t change the kid’s behavior” (Khazan 25). Khazan presents a child psychologist, Alan Kazdin’s to speak on parenting interventions. Along with parenting intervention, Khazan utilizes her interview with Kazdin, presenting a more of an understanding towards the issue of punishment. Utilizing Kazdin’s parenting interventions, he uses examples to prove that; punishment should not be used to fix negative behavior.

Read More

Summary Of Gently Does It By Cheryl Critchley

601 Words | 3 Pages

The opinion piece ‘Gently Does It’ written by Cheryl Critchley, asserts the dire effect ‘smacking’ young children has on their development and potentially aggressive future. ‘Smacking’ often elicits a vehement debate, with parents saying it is their right and decision whether “to smack or not smack”, with others suggesting it proposes an unclear and burred line regarding domestic abuse. Critchley’s article was posted on the 10th of August 2013 in the Sunday Herald. This choice of platform is concurrent with an older target audience, particularly parents who or may not be partaking in the ‘harmful’ act of ‘chastisement.’ A maternal tone is adopted by Critchley throughout the entirety of her piece, whilst showing growing concern for the probable

Read More

Summary Of Is Spanking, No Problem

1042 Words | 5 Pages

Is Spanking A Problem Solver? Today's day and age parents try to steer clear of spanking their children and try a more modern approach on parenting trying to give a positive discipline. But does that solve everything? In this article “No Spanking, No Time-Out, No Problem” Alan Kazdin uses several elements throughout this article.

Read More

Adrian Peterson's Case Paper

544 Words | 3 Pages

In Adrian Peterson’s case, I decided that his action did reflect abuse. I began to research more about the details about this case and found that Peterson disciplined his four-year-old child using a tree branch. The hitting with the tree branch did result in multiple bruises and lacerations surrounding the boy’s body. Peterson publicly admitted that he did discipline his son because he pushed his brother while playing video games (Bonesteel, 2016). Abuse is defined as the “knowing, intentional, negligent” harmful punishment given to a child and physical abuse refers to hurting the minor with “objects that leave marks” (Cauffman, 2018).

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Lowering Drinking Age

1798 Words | 8 Pages

If 18 year olds are old enough to vote or fight and die for their country, then they should be able to drink alcohol. [McCardell] believes that alcohol is a fixture in the lives of young people and suggests, instead of trying to outlaw it, America should consider policies the will “empower” eighteen-to-twenty-year olds to make mature decisions about it. In the early 1970s, most states raised the drinking age at 21 since that was the voting age at that time. From 1969 to 1976, some 30 states lowered their purchase ages, generally to 18. This happened because the voting age was lowered from 21 to 18 in 1971 with the 26th amendment that was passed with the congress of the united states to amid increasing support for a constitutional amendment.

Read More

The Inexcusable Reality Of The Whipping By Carl Hayden

859 Words | 4 Pages

Luckily, there are now laws in place to protect children that are subject to child abuse, yet this doesn’t stop some parents from demonstrating abusive tendencies. Despite child abuse being impermissable in todays society, it still transpires. Child

Read More

Child Abuse And Neglect In The State Of Indiana

478 Words | 2 Pages

There are several types of child abuse, People don’t realize it’s not just hitting your kid that is considered child abuse. There is Physical, Sexual, Verbal, Emotional,Psychological and Neglect. All of those have different signs, and different types of effects. The more common form of abuse is, physical abuse. Physical abuse is, “any intentional act causing

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Spanking Children

828 Words | 4 Pages

Signs of a child being physically abused include bruises, cuts, burns, fractures, internal injuries or brain damage. When none of these characteristics are present, it cannot be considered child abuse. A typical spanking should not cause any of those types of injuries. In fact, spanking is considered acceptable in our society and sometimes very necessary to discipline a child. A spanking is an open-handed hit on the behind, which should never cause severe bruising, bleeding, or scars.

Read More

Argumentative Essay About Spanking Your Children

600 Words | 3 Pages

This study was conducted on April 25, 2016 by experts at The University of Texas at Austin and the University of Michigan. Elizabeth Gershoff and co-author Andrew Grogan-Kaylor. Their study focuses on what most Americans would see as spanking and not a potentially abusive behavior. During their study they found that spanking your children can cause them to defy their parents more frequently and can also cause a lifelong mental health issue. It showed as the frequency of spanking increases, the likelihood of anti-social behavior, mental health issues, and aggression also increases.

Read More

Psychological Theories Of Child Abuse And Crime

2401 Words | 10 Pages

"Child Abuse and Neglect" says that Physical abuse can include "striking a child with the hand, fist, or foot or with an object, burning, shaking, pushing, or throwing a child; pinching or biting the child, pulling a child by the hair or cutting off a child’s air." However, physical abuse is considered to be a use of punishment in wrecked as well as normal families such as the use of physical force with the intent of inflicting bodily pain, but not injury, for the purpose of correction or control or discipline. Yet, there is a thin line between physical punishment and abuse which many parents seem to lack notice of. "Child Abuse and Neglect" explains that the level of force used by an angry or frustrated parent can easily get out of hand and lead to injury. Emotional or verbal abuse is one of the worst forms of mistreatment due to its invisibility.

Read More

Spanking Persuasive Speech

954 Words | 4 Pages

What is the long term outcome? Is there a better way to assist the situation? Many parents feel that it is unnecessary to spank a child because it is not okay to hit, on the other hand, other parents view it as a way of getting the child’s attention and telling them “No.” There are just as

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Child Abuse

1733 Words | 7 Pages

“There are many factors that contribute to this repulsive behavior. Physical, sexual, and psychological cruelty are effects of child abuse. Physical abuse is a painful, devastating event that occurs on a daily basis. According to the government, physical abuse is “when someone uses a part of their body or an object to control a person’s actions.” “ There are many forms of physical force, such as, hitting, strangling, slapping, beating, and kicking.

Read More

Argumentative Essay On Child Abuse

1142 Words | 5 Pages

In different instances, this would come up in conversations and the reactions were for the majority “that’s awful” or “poor thing” or “I can’t understand how anyone could do such a thing” and I never fully understood why. My mother was raised with an abusive father and a compromising mother (who too was dealing with the abuse), so I have seen how a negative experience can have a positive impact/result (message) on a person/child. I have now grown a curiosity to understand the different limits of child abuse and believe what my parents did benefitted me and any other children who received this discipline. With that in mind, I am going to define, and explore different aspects of child abuse with some modern examples.     Some people believe that physical punishments can be degrading and negatively affect the mental health of the child compared to those who think it teaches discipline and how to respect others without any significant damage to the child 's psyche.

Read More

Informative Speech On Child Abuse

818 Words | 4 Pages

What is child abuse: A) According to Jonathan Franzen, the author of Encyclopedia Britannica, child abuse is defined as "the willful infliction of pain and suffering on children through physical, sexual, or emotional

Read More

More about Analysis Of The Article 'Smacking Is Distinct From Child Abuse'

Related Topics

Open Document