ipl-logo

Banning Books Like Maus Is Part Of Sanitizing History By Gwen Katz

1026 Words5 Pages

Pajamafication is Prioritized over Education The article Banning Books Like 'Maus' Is Part of Sanitizing History, is written by two individuals: Gwen Katz and A.R. Vishny. Katz is a writer, novelist, artist, and game designer. She has published one book and many short stories, and her main genres to write about are historical fiction and horror. She has an incredible interest in historic tragedies that have inspired her works. Vishny is an author and attorney, who specializes in Jewish representation in modern day society. With Katz military inspirations and Vishny's will to represent Jewish culture, they collaborated on the case of Tennessee school boards banning the book Maus. A book about a Holocaust survivor who is interviewed over the …show more content…

It’s appalling that the issue of schools banning books from students is still an ever present issue to this present day. Fact of the matter is, comfort is being prioritized over education. The school boards and their staff are rejecting truth because it contains inappropriate topics such as nudity, violence, and derogatory vocabulary. Katz and Vishny write how the Tennessee education board states these exact topics to their reason for why they chose to ban Maus. The school board's reasoning is how it is determined that they choose to prioritize comfort for the students. Katz and Vishny claim their statement within the second to third paragraph of Banning Books Like 'Maus' Is Part of Sanitizing History. Dangerous, difficult, and sensitive topics are a challenge for many kids, and can cause distress and despair to said students. Even though this stress is necessary to grow and mature, the school board is banning books from developing the kids' immature and young minds. Katz and Vishny are claiming that this “pajamafication” is ruining the great futures of these students. Another factor to consider is how the parents want their children to be taught from the educational system. Parents are more likely to have alternative objectives to the type of education their children receive, and can have a variety of reasons as to why they strongly suggest removing a sensitive book from their or other

Show More
Related

  • Maus Should Be Banned Essay

    1671 Words  | 7 Pages

    While “Maus” is not a teaching tool and it’s goal was not made to be so, it is a personal element that compels an authentic story. Consequently, why would the novel be banned from school

    Read More

  • Examples Of Controversy In Fahrenheit 451

    696 Words  | 3 Pages

    They also wrote about other banned books stating, “In York County, Pa., teachers and students protested against and overturned a ban on a selection of books told from the perspective of gay, Black, and Latino children.” Steve Cohen, Tennessee’s first Jewish Congressman, said, “It’s depressing to see this happen anywhere in the country, and when it comes to censoring an easy way to reach children and teach them about the Holocaust, it’s particularly

    Read More

  • To Kill A Mockingbird Controversy Essay

    1538 Words  | 7 Pages

    Ashley Chubb Dr. Grippin AP Literature 15 May 2023 Controversy surrounding To Kill a Mockingbird In recent years, the topic of banned books has been put into the spotlight, gathering attention from controversial school curriculums. Many previously banned or disputable titles have been brought back into the debate, introducing an array of disagreements between students, teachers, administrators, and parents. Although book banning has existed since the fifteenth century, opposition to this practice truly came to public attention in the early 1960’s.

    Read More

  • Book Banning Essay

    944 Words  | 4 Pages

    The New York Times then states, “They argued that young people have the right to read unsanitized versions of history, that diverse books expose them to a variety of experiences and perspectives, that controversial literature helps them to think critically about the world, and that, in the age of the internet, book bans just aren’t that effective” (What Students Are Saying About Banning Books From School Libraries). Students should have the right to connect to the books they read. By removing books because they have a transgender character, or a charater that others do not agree with because it is not “typical,” it creates a feeling of displacement. One student named Meghan from Glenbard West High School explains, “If we don’t learn history, we can’t learn from it, and that is the most essential key to humanity…” and, “Our society depends on the idea of future generations learning and progressing, and with the banning of books all we are doing is going backwards, not forwards” (What Students Are Saying About Banning Books From School Libraries). By censoring historical events such as the Holocaust, future students are at a disadvantage when it comes to creating a stable future.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Book Censorship Reasech

    1634 Words  | 7 Pages

    AJ Harasti Mrs. Hassing English 12B 18 April 2023 Book Censorship Reaserch Essay Access to information is one of the most crucial aspects of a fair and equitable education. Exposure to different perspectives and people is key to how a person performs in diverse environments that differ from what individuals experience personally. Because of this, local and federal governments should enact laws that stop censorship in schools’ curricula as well as acknowledging the problems that correlate with banning books. Every student is entitled to a fair and well-rounded education that a student is free to choose.

    Read More

  • Why Should Maus Not Be Banned

    557 Words  | 3 Pages

    Dear Dr Constant, Maus has been widely praised and recognized for its literary and artistic merits, including winning the Pulitzer Prize. Maus is a graphic novel written and illustrated by Art Spiegelman. It tells the story of Spiegelman´s father, a holocaust survivor, and his experience during World War 2. The novel is notable for its use of animals as Jews depicted as mice and Nazis depicted as cats. Maus was first published in 1980 and has since become a classic of the graphic novel genre, winning numerous awards.

    Read More

  • Why Should Books Be Banned

    1750 Words  | 7 Pages

    Books can create portals to different life experiences and encourage reading. A few schools and libraries have challenged the educational value of some books, however, therefore leading them to eventually be prohibited in a particular place. Each reason may be different depending on the book and the location of the exclusions. Books are icons of literature and their value should outshine the occasionally offensive topic. Be that as it may, there are multiple reasons why books should be taught and included in a curriculum.

    Read More

  • Why Is Fahrenheit 451 Be Banned In Schools

    652 Words  | 3 Pages

    Books are an essential way to gain knowledge whether they are controversial or not. Thousands of books have been banned from public libraries and schools due to being deemed ‘inappropriate’ by parents, administrators, or religious leaders. Whether Americans should ban books in public libraries and schools is an often debated topic. This censorship of books is dangerous, as it restricts the American people's’ ability to access information, leaving Americans ignorant. Historically, banning books is not a new practice.

    Read More

  • You Assign My Book, Don T Censor It By Mark Matbane

    1725 Words  | 7 Pages

    In Mark Mathabane’s article, “If You Assign My Book, Don't Censor It”, Mathabane argues against schools assigning censored versions of his story “Kaffir Boy”. The author supports his argument by explaining how his life story doesn’t have the same emotional impact without the extremely controversial scene where young boys prostitute themselves. Matabane’s purpose is to inform potential parents or teachers of the significance and importance of the controversial scene, in order to keep students from reading censored versions of his story. Matabane presents his argument to appeal to educated Americans. Overall Mathabane effectively proves his argument that censoring a pivotal point of his story compromises its theme of freedom.

    Read More

  • The Argumentative Essay Of Banning Books

    609 Words  | 3 Pages

    At one point in time, over 7,220 books have been challenged to be banned. Though these books have been removed for the safety of children, not all books should be banned for many reasons. These include the fact that banning books is infringing on the First Amendment, keeping children from understanding the real world, and, even though there are many reasons for book banning, not banning books could help a student’s education and can even work against itself. Banning a book from a school or public library could go against a person’s First Amendment of the freedom of press.

    Read More

  • Reasons Why Books Should Not Be Banned?

    1617 Words  | 7 Pages

    First, this text states, “Children should not be exposed to sex, violence, drug use, or other inappropriate topics” (Procon.org). To explain, parents are banning books from schools because they do not want their children to be exposed to these inappropriate topics. Moreover, banning these inappropriate topic books would be a great deal for parents and their children. Furthermore, the same text states that “Keeping books with an inappropriate content out of libraries protects kids, but does not stop people from

    Read More

  • Essay On Banning Books In Schools

    1127 Words  | 5 Pages

    In recent years, many different books in schools and libraries have been discussed and reviewed to determine whether or not they should be available for student access. However, while some believe that students should be allowed to such content, many topics involved are seen as inappropriate for younger and older children, and discuss things such as identity, race, freedom of speech, and LGBTQ+, and have ultimately been removed because of arguments brought to school boards and the American Library Association. The rights we have as students are responsible for what we’re able to view and allow us to learn about topics we have an interest in. Many of these topics are being argued against because of the sexual content they portray which is responsible

    Read More

  • Essay On Banned Books

    709 Words  | 3 Pages

    “American citizens who care about the improvement of education are urged to join students, teachers, librarians, administrators, boards of education, and professional and scholarly organizations in support of the students’ right to read” (The Students Right to Read). Citizens should be allowed to stand up if they believe books should not be banned. It is important that writers should be able to have their books out to the public without getting banned. “Challengers often employ a definition that maintains that banning materials is the only true form of censorship,”(Knox 740). Censorship of books is common and a real problem.

    Read More

  • The Banning Of Books Within The Modern Educational World

    779 Words  | 4 Pages

    Their conclusions are based on intuition, not information. This inexact process leads to widespread and inappropriate censorship and explains why teachers usually vehemently oppose banning books.” This supports the fact that parents shouldn’t have a say in banning books considering that they aren’t qualified to examine them and occasionally are depriving the students of key educational

    Read More

  • Persuasive Essay On Censorship In Schools

    844 Words  | 4 Pages

    Parents making up most of the challenges for “Banned and Challenge Book Week” (Manning par 3) to be censored shows that they are uncomfortable with the decisions on keeping inappropriate books and lessons in the school system. School materials can cause division in the classroom, with parents and the curriculum. Controversial topics such as politics, religion, race, and sexual orientation can easily cause a ruckus within our schooling system. For instance, in a work setting, there are rules in place and guarded by the HR department so employee conversations would not get out of hand like censorship for schools. In school, books can lead to conversations that are inappropriate for school-age pupils.

    Read More

More about Banning Books Like Maus Is Part Of Sanitizing History By Gwen Katz

Open Document