April 3, 2023
“The Giver” Compare and Contrast
Utopian and dystopian societies are a common topic in novels. Utopias depict an idealized society, while dystopias are utopias gone wrong. “The Giver” is a novel written by Lois Lowry about a utopia that is not actually perfect. It depicts a society that has eliminated war, hunger, conflict and hatred. However in the proccess eliminated happiness and love. This book is very meaningful as it is a warning to society about what happens without feelings and history. Due to “The Giver” growing in popularity it was made into a film. This is an overall good adaptation of the book, but is not an exact replica. Both “The Giver” novel and the film adaptation have …show more content…
As “Precision of Language” convey’s human sameness and control, the same goes for the absence of colour. In “The Giver” book, the community has eliminated colour in order to create a cohesive world. As The Giver educated Jonas, “We relinquished colour when we relinquished sunshine, and did away with difference. We gained control of many things. But we had to let others go.” (95) This quote explains how the decision to remove colour may help eliminate differences, but it takes away what makes people and life special. It is also a sort of turning point to Jonas, as it builds on his opinion about why his community isn’t perfect. In relation to the book, in “The Giver” movie colour is also a factor that has been removed from the community. This is clear to the viewer, as in the movie until Jonas gains the ability to see colour, the viewer gets to watch the movie in black and white. Including this part of the book in the movie was important, because it demonstrated to the viewer how Jonas saw the world. It may make the movie feel more impactful as it shows how sameness can eliminate happiness, love and …show more content…
In “The Giver” novel, there is a difference jobs that the main characters have. At the ceremony Asher received “The assignment of Assistant Director of Recreation.” While Jonas’ other friend Fiona, “Was given the important assignment of Caretaker of the Old.” (56) As readers it is understandable why these characters were given these assignments. As explained by the Head Elder, Asher was given his role because of his love of play. While Fiona received her assignment due to her long volunteer hours at House Of The Old. Conversely, in the movie Fiona and Asher have completely different roles in the community. During the ceremony, Asher’s assignment is pilot and Fiona’s is Nurturer. While this may seem like an insignificant difference, it is actually relevant as they use these jobs in the movie as an additional plot point that never existed in the books. Asher’s job as pilot becomes significant when Jonas escapes the community. Instead of random planes chasing after him like in the books, Asher actually chases after him. Similarly with Fiona, when Jonas is escaping he breaks Gabe out of the Nurturing Center with Fiona’s help. This difference may also be confusing to some viewers, as the movie does not give any sort of reasoning as to why these characters have received these jobs. In contrast to the book which gives us a clear understanding as to why they received these assignments. In addition to the
Click here to unlock this and over one million essaysShow More
Lowry makes it seem like a huge dam has been broken in between Jonas and the Giver using her style and word choice. This both created a major trust between the mentor and hero, as well as showed use of style by Lowry. This moment is developed by the style, and it develops the hero’s journey, which makes the style a major part of the hero’s journey in The Giver. In Among the Hidden the author says, “Jen waited. The silence between them seemed to be growing, like a balloon.
For example, in the world of the giver, they can't see color. This is shown on page 119 when Jonas says, "It's not fair that we can't see color. " This quote proves that in the world of the giver, they can't see color. The sameness is another example of the differences between the giver and modern society. Sameness is talked about in the book when the giver says that "there are people who choose sameness.
The book is about a life and a community without love, diversity, and memories. It is about sameness, where life is bland and there is no true emotion. It tells the sadness of this concept and how Jonas has to live with it, and how he plans to change it. But in the movie, it is merely Jonas’s short and backgroundless adventure to bring the memories back, the actionized version
Also, the community runs off of a rigid, daily schedule. These are just a few of the rules in the community. At first, this seems normal, and one could argue the government is focused on the safety of its members; However, as the novel progresses the community gradually reaches a state of turmoil. Literary Critic Carter F. Hanson asserts, “Lois Lowry’s novel “The Giver” (1993) inhabits the discursive space of dystopia, and like most dystopias, “The Giver” begins in an imagined world intended to be worse than the reader’s own, although it is initially inviting”.
What would the world be without color? In The Giver they lived their lives without color and it was only black and white. The characters in The Giver were Jonas and The Giver living in The Giver community in the future where everything is very controlling. What would have made The Giver community more positive are diversity, honesty, and empathy. Diversity would have been important to make The Giver community more positive.
Jonas is finding out that not everyone in the community can see color or know about the past at all: “‘But I want them!’ Jonasretortedy. ‘It isn't fair that nothing has color.’ ‘Not fair?’ The Giver looked at Jonas' curiosity ‘Explain what you mean’ ‘Well Jonas had to stop and think it through.
This theme is shown in the book when Jonas and the Giver plan to escape because they realized that the government is corrupt. This quote also tells us Even if something seems normal or perfect, it doesn't mean it is because Jonas realizes that only he and the giver can see color and that is his first indication that the government is corrupt because he knows if it was a normal place then everyone would be able to see color and be aloud to choose no to share their dreams. Another example that proves the theme is when Jonas was given a memory of his father killing a baby because it had a twin and they don't want two people in the society that look the same. (Lowry) “
Would you want to live in a society where everyones the same, perfect, and no color, or a society where people who have differences and are allowed to make mistakes? The reading of a society being different is why the book, The Giver, is being challenged. Many people believe that the book The Giver should be banned due to infanticide content; however, the book provides a perspective of someone who is different than the so called “normal” or “perfect”, it also gives teh reader a better outlook on how society is today. After reading the book, The Giver, the reader will have a better appreciation for all the unique differences in life. In the book, The Giver, Jonas states “ If everything’s the same, then there aren’t any choices!”.
The Giver Compare/Contrast Essay When some people hear the words ‘perfect society’ what do they think of? Take a look at our society, then take a look at Jonas’s society, between our two societies there are some comparisons and a vast amount of differences. For instance, the rules are different, as well as their family units and their individuality. While our society is more on the modern side, Jonas’s society is plainer. When it comes to the rules in our society, we don’t normally think of rules that are very extreme.
In Lois Lowry’s award-winning novel, The Giver, Jonas’s society is considered to be utopian because the society has an overall sense of sameness, organization, and minimal problems. To begin, the society is utopian because of sameness. In Lois Lowry 's, The Giver, Jonas is selected to be the Receiver of Memories and he comes to learn that when his community decided to go to sameness they were getting rid of color, emotion, and choice. At first the Giver tells him it 's to "protect" them from making the wrong choices. As stated in the text “Our people made that choice the choice to go to sameness”.(Lois Lowry pg 95)
In The Giver, Lois Lowry shows her readers what it is like to live in a society with no diversity, no color, and no freedom. In this society, there is a twelve-year old boy, named Jonas, who finds the truth about life outside of his community. He does not have the option of choice, and he is stuck in a futuristic world of “sameness”. Jonas’ world is dull, and he wants to change it because it does not have the amazing features and opportunities that he learns about. In this story, Lois Lowry is warning her readers that too much conformity can lead to no freedom and no true happiness.
In the book,everyone has the same attribute’s but one twelve year old boy named Jonas. Throughout the novel,Jonas has suffer and has been misunderstood. Jonas opened his eyes to the reality of the community. This causes tears,anger,lonely’s,confused,unaware and misunderstanding. “He killed it my father killed it”,Jonas said to himself” (Lowry 188).
He believes that people should be able to the the real world with different colors and organisms. In the community everything is the same even the colors. That is why people don’t notice Fiona’s red hair but Jonas does because he received the memories from the Giver. “The Giver” shows a life of not having the freedom of choice. The story also shows the life of sameness and being directed to do everything that the people are told to do.
Imagine living in a world with no freedom, choice, individuality, and color. Would you want to live in a world like this? Most of you would have said no, but a boy named Jonas has no choice, but to adhere to his community’s rules. In the book and the movie, “The Giver”, by Louis Lowery, Jonas finds it difficult to accept his community’s way of life. However, after he becomes the receiver of memory, he challenges the community after discovering what the world used to be like before sameness.
Stop, think about this for a moment. You are in a community that cannot see color, has no feelings, no choices to be made on your own, and no diversity between each other. How would you feel? Jonas, a twelve year old boy and the Giver have to live in this community knowing all this. As they live in this futuristic dystopian community they share memories of the past and what is elsewhere.