Excavating Memories in “Max Ferber” In his book, “The Emigrants”, W.G Sebald talks about four different characters and their stories. In his last one, he talks about Max Ferber, a Jewish painter who moved to Manchester as a refugee from Nazi Germany when he was a kid. In the narrator’s visits throughout the years, Ferber tells the story about his past and stay in Manchester. The chapter explores the past that haunts and affects his daily life. Throughout his life, Ferber has experienced trauma and dealt with it by repressing his memories through art. Several symbols describe his way of dealing with them. Sebald uses Ferber’s painting process and Manchester’s cityscape to develop the theme of repressed memories. Sebald …show more content…
This method of scraping and repainting serves as a metaphor for dealing with memories. He scratches and scrapes the paint as if he was erasing his memories and filtering them. Whereas by painting and reworking, he tries to edit these thick layers of memories that are stacked on the canvas. However, some memories escape “annihilation” (P162) right to his mind. He continues the destruction until everything he wants to get rid of will be wiped off. This process of scratching made the floor thickly covered with paint droppings and dust. Ferber had a weakness for the dust and “loved more than anything else in the world”(P161). It symbolized the physical residue of memories that was building up on the floor as it was constantly fought in the painting process. He never touched them, he left them undisturbed believing that they will dissolve into “nothingness”(P161) over time. In addition, the author emphasizes more than once Ferber collecting the dust: “his prime concern was to increase the dust.”(P161) He describes Ferber’s obsession with his past. Furthermore, there is a contrast in Ferber’s dealing with memories. He is holding onto them by …show more content…
He first describes Manchester as a city that has endured ups and downs by pointing out: “Manchester’s shipping traffic peaked around 1930 and then went into an irreversible decline, till it became to a complete standstill in the late Fifties.” (P 166). As well as that, Ferber’s studio was located in the middle of an industrial area full of “deserted buildings” (P160). Everyone has fled off, the same way Ferber fled Germany. The location of the studio symbolizes a link between Ferber and his past. After its decline, Manchester was a city of “motionless and deathly silence”(P166). All of its histories have been buried. “One solid mass of utter blackness, bereft of any further distinguishing features” (P168) was all that was left. There is a similarity between Manchester and Ferber. They were haunted by the history that was repressed but present. In the novella, Manchester acts as a description of Ferber’s painting. Similarly, as his paintings, Manchester has witnessed a huge transformational change. It transitioned from a natural structure to an industrial city that endured an economic disaster later on. Manchester underwent the destruction of a “natural amphitheatre” (P168) the same way Ferber scrapes his painting. Moreover, Manchester was reconstructed into the industrial “Jerusalem”(P165) just like Ferber’s painting undergoes
Birch describes a “darkened” (5) Melbourne, that despite not being “a bombsite”(1), is still “a city of cold light and benign shadows” (4-5), displaying the negative history associated with the city. In his poem, Birch examines that although Melbourne was not “among the rubble” (3) post World War II, it shared a similar pattern of destruction in the form of the devastation brought upon the Indigenous population at the time of the British Colonization. This concept links Burton Pike text The Image of the City in Modern Literature, in which Pike claims every city in the world has its own “individual history” (3), however cities “all seem to exemplify similar patterns” (3). This identifies that the formation of a city follows a general historical structure, and can be seen through Birch’s comparison of Europe’s involvement in WWII with the Colonization of Australia.
Over the course of a century, Manchester evolved from a town of nothing extraordinary into the country’s vital trading centre. Comparing the maps of Manchester in 1750 to that of 1850, it is evident that not only has the city increased in approximately five times of size but also has built canals and railroads that pierce through the city at all angles (Document 1), including the famous Liverpool and Manchester Railway. Such expansion in urban development and increase in mobility allowed for industries to thrive; as a result, the economy prospered. Being granted a royal charter in 1852, Manchester came to be known as the “Workshop of the World”. In terms of “commerce and manufacture”, it had surpassed “any other town in the British Dominions or indeed the world.”
There are five "spots of paint" that have been created: a man mowing a lawn, a woman picking flowers, a small boy with his hands in the air, a thrown ball, and a girl waiting to catch the ball. (pg. 2). This image was preserved while the rest was “a thin charcoaled layer.” (pg.2) This moment of how this family doing a normal activity was captured, but everything was burnt away except the spots of the figures. It depicts how one moment people could be normal but gone the next, while the smart house continues doing daily tasks with no one in it.
They had problems linking ancient cities with those in the modern world. However, there was another beautiful city activist while embracing Sargent’s views took them a few steps further, Charles
Once lay a city, but now only a lonely house “in a city of rubble and ashes” (p.222). The technologically advanced house continues its business, cooking breakfast, waking the family up, telling them about the weather, but the house’s words reach no ears. The city lies empty of human life. The house continues its chores even when the “gods,” referring to the humans in the house, “had gone away” (p.223). All that was left to show that humans once existed were the five sections of paint left on the black west sidewall.
This is saying that he does not care if it looks good because he just hates that she is painting on it. This shows how him and lou hate what ever she does to the wall. But
Manchester, England was the epicenter of the Industrial Revolution. Although it was successful in the production of treasured items, Manchester was becoming heavily contaminated. The image, “The Silent
For the fact was that industrial urban America was busy transforming material life, substituting machine-made products for those once produced by hand” (Ewen, 64). Others hated this new America where all the fresh air was gone and they spent all their time indoors. One Italian women said “‘Where are the green fields and open spaces in America?... All about me was the harshness of brick and stone and the stinking smell of crowded poverty’” (Ewen, 61).
Not only did their complaints raise wages and decrease working hours, they also eventually advanced medical care, increased literacy rates in the city, and made the city more sanitary. This resulted in healthier, happier people who lived longer and prospered. Not only did people become healthier, the children that they had were also healthier at birth, making it so parents didn’t need to have as many children in fear that some would die at a young age. Overall, Manchester vastly improved as a city throughout the 18th and 19th century; reforms were made, people became happier, and education spread throughout the city, but not before workers protested and died young because of their working and living conditions. The story of Manchester truly proves that in order to improved, you must first experience the lowest point; without the low point, you can never truly understand or experience
This theme was revealed through an epiphany and shows just how feeble a young mind is. This realization shows to be an important part in the story and why an adult mind takes time to sculpt
Manchester is described as an ugly city that has no beauty and is so filthy and foul it can turn a good man into a savage[doc 2&5].One person questions if the progress was worth the physical suffering [doc 7]. Document 11 shows a painting from The Graphic of the horrible pollution in Manchester where the peasants live. Even though there were negative reactions there was also positive reactions. Many of the nobles agreed that the working conditions improved over the years[doc 10]. Some however, agreed that it should not matter how working conditions are because the peasants have always lived terrible lives[doc 3].Others who do not agree with the others agreed that Manchester was truly beautiful because of the tremendous growth of industry[doc 9].
Apparently, the residents of Manchester did not care for how education would aid them and chose reckless lifestyles to attempt to live as happily as possible despite the long hours, poor wages, crowded conditions, and rampant disease. Document 6 helps to corroborate much of this, claiming that most workers lacked basic amenities of clothing, furnishings, and good nutrition. Lacking these amenities and basic nutrition, it is unsurprising that many individuals turned towards the bars that sprung up in the crowded city to not only take their mind off of the horrid situation but also to avoid the practically poisonous water and nourishment that they would receive elsewhere. These conditions resulted directly from the economic growth of Manchester as it encouraged industry to expand at a rapid, unregulated pace that led to high pollution and poor city-planning. Manchester experienced serious issues resulting from its economic growth in terms of its industries’ poor quality, city’s poor infrastructure, and citizen’s poor living
It was filthy; chockful of human waste, smoke, and sickness. Robert Southey, an English Romantic poet, wrote after witnessing Manchester’s decline, that industrialization led Manchester to become a place where one only hears, “the everlasting din of machinery, and where; when the bell rings, it is to call the wretches to their work instead of their prayers” (Document #1). It is true that as people moved away from their home churches and to the cities, church attendance declined. The duty of work became constant and life was miserable for many of the working class. Southey, as a romantic, is expectedly biased against industrialization because of the romantic nostalgia and sentimentalism towards the past.
As the car was in motion on the way to where I would be staying I rolled the window down. Something other than the tall green grasses and canopy trees caught my attention. I finally started to see some scattered buildings, hotels, and restaurants. The city started to seem more urbanized, that wasn 't the only infrastructure that I saw, more was yet to come. As we went deeper into the rural areas the buildings disappeared and the sidewalks started to become more deteriorated.
There is the idea of a city, and the city itself, too great to be held in the mind. And it is in this gap (between the conceptual and the real) that aggression begins” is central to Saunders’ essay, due to the fact that this quote illustrates Saunders’ message that people tend to have misconceptions generated from their own limited experience and misconceptions can easily lead to conflicts and aggression if handled