In the novel The Things They Carried by Tim O’Brian, the death of Kiowa helps develop the motifs of guilt and shame consequently affecting the meaning of the book to surviving the war. Kiowa proved a genuine friend to O’Brian and the rest of the platoon not simply through his words, but his dignity and actions. When he died, it was brutal and dehumanizing, ultimately causing much guilt and blame throughout the entirety of the book. O’Brian even claimed “when a man died, there had to be blame." This blame and guilt affected the novel and shifted the tone entirely. Kiowa was mentioned in the book as someone who had not in particular been affected by the war. He was diligent and hardworking, but O’Biran also portrayed him as a humble character. …show more content…
Even after two decades O’Brian still suffers and explains, “I’d gone under with Kiowa, and now after two decades I’d finally worked my way out (O’Brien 125). He means what when Kiowa died he “went under” with him. It felt comparable as if he died and drowned along with Kiowa and was merely revived when he went back to the field, then the burden was finally lifted. He then didn’t feel the guilt of it being his fault. Just as O’Brian suffered, many others did. While it wasn’t physical at first, it affected them drastically mentally. Rat Kiley was a prime example on how Kiowa affected the book. Kiley’s mentality changed and he no longer could be the savior to others and shot himself in the foot. This brought him to Japan directing the meaning of the book towards surviving the war mentally. It was as if everyone had blamed themselves for Kiowa's death although it wasn’t anyone’s fault entirely. O’Brian explained it as, "But I was present, you see, and my presence was guilt enough” (O’Brien 120). It wasn’t that any individual was solely responsible for the death, but the presence and having the power and opportunity of being …show more content…
They each blamed each other and themselves for certain events, such as Kiowa’s death; all of which affected themselves as a person inside the war, and following the war. Within the book, Jimmy Cross explains his view and attitude towards the unexpected death: “There was nothing he could do now, but still it was a mistake and a hideous waste. He felt sick about it” (O’Brian 164). Cross’s feeling of guilt for Kiowa's death he feels was because of his lack of intuition and courage was the reason for his death. Not exclusively does Cross blame himself, but others also end up blaming Cross. They are all haunted and looking for someone to blame rather than themselves. L.T still felt responsible because of how he was in charge of the young men. This highly affected the characters in the novel during and after the war. Each person held that guilt and carried it throughout their lives. Ironically, along with that guilt came relief and happiness. While they all lamed themselves, they all were happy that it wasn’t them. While none of them mentioned it or spoke the words, they all felt it. O’Brian described it as, “Though it’s odd, you’re never more alive than when you're almost dead” (O’Brien ___). This brought characters mixed feelings which ended up harming them mentally. Rat Kiley struggled with this guild. He tried his best to exist as
Tim O’Brien never lies. While we realise at the end of the book that Kiowa, Mitchell Sanders and Rat Kiley are all fictional characters, O’Brien is actually trying to tell us that there is a lot more truth hidden in these imagined characters than we think. This suggests that the experiences he went through were so traumatic, the only way to describe it was through the projection of fictional characters. O’Brien explores the relationship between war experiences and storytelling by blurring the lines between truth and fiction. While storytelling can change and shape a reader’s opinions and perspective, it might also be the closest in helping O’Brien cope with the complexity of war experiences, where the concepts like moral and immorality are being distorted.
He feels guilty because the men in his company are under his command and he was supposed to keep them safe, but he failed because he wasn’t paying attention. He kept daydreaming about Martha, who Lieutenant Cross had a crush on, when he should’ve been paying attention to the battle happening at the time. And as a result, he blames his obsession on Martha and himself for the death of Ted. To atone for the death of Ted, Lieutenant Cross decided to burn “Martha’s letters” (Tim O'Brien 22), pictures, and threw away a pebble that Martha had given him. He threw away all reminders of Martha to make sure that the memory of Martha would never distract him again so that his men won’t have to die like Ted
When they feel lost and deal with the traumas that come with fighting in the war, he quickly engages himself with their troubles and conducts a free therapy session by lending an ear, and checking in on them regularly while fighting in the war at the same time. For example, when Tim killed the young Vietnamese soldier during the war, he started to contemplate about the life that the fallen soldier could have had if it wasn’t for Tim taking his life. While the other soldiers carried on with their lives, Kiowa was the only one who stayed back and said to Tim, “It wasn’t you man. It wasn’t you.” (O’ Brien 145).
He reflected on his actions and understood that he had let his men down. He knew that nothing he could ever do would bring Ted Lavender back, but he believed that he had to become a better officer for the sake of his men. He decided to enforce strict field discipline, flank security, and clean weapons in an attempt to keep his men safer, (O’Brien, 104). Although he knew that his new policies would not be well-received, he decided to do them regardless because it was his obligation “not to be loved but to lead, (O’Brien, 104).” Jimmy Cross became a different kind of leader due to his failure to keep Ted Lavender
[Insert Body Paragraphs Here]- Because Jimmy Cross is the lieutenat and the leader of the group he feels responsible for the death of his soldiers. While the soldiers were looking for a spot to spend the night, LT Cross decided to stop in a sewage field which led to Kiowa’s death. When Cross was standing over Kiowa he had felt that is was his fault, “Jimmy Cross stood very still, afraid to move, yet knowing he had to, and then he murmured to himself, "My fault," and he nodded and waded out across the field toward the boy” (169). Since Jimmy Cross balmes himself for the death of not only one of his soldiers but also his friend, he feels as if he needs to take full responsibility for Kiowa's death. Despite Cross's fear, he knows that he must move on and take action for the other soldiers.
Death is an inevitable part of the life cycle. To bring those who are gone back to life, people must recreate their memories with the deceased through storytelling. In the novel The Things They Carried, Tim O’Brien shows that when someone experiences a loss, by telling stories of the lost one it will keep them alive through the mind and help one cope with them being gone. In the first chapter, The Things They Carried, O’Brien demonstrates the theme of telling stories to cope with death by how the platoon members talk about Ted Lavender’s death, “Like cement, Kiowa whispered in the dark.
This was when the war started to feel real for everyone, including Lt. Cross: “Lieutenant Cross found himself trembling. He tried not to cry….. He felt shame. He hated himself” (O’Brien 16). Lieutenant Cross was never properly trained, resulting in an inadequate leader.
A similar guiltiness is displayed by Norman Bowker, after he feels that his lack of courage resulted in the grotesque death of Kiowa. The feeling of not doing enough to save a friend haunts many war veterans. For Bowker, his inability to save Kiowa and other experiences of Vietnam left him directionless in his life after the war, ultimately leading to his suicide a few years down the road. Unlike Tim, who uses his ability to create stories that capture the complicated emotions of war to cope in his life back in America, Norman feels alone since he is unable to share his inner feelings from Vietnam that still haunt
He had even made the reader feel sympathy and guilt for the dead man. The most prominent feeling of guilt for all the men had been after Kiowa’s death. Kiowa was a good man, and a good friend to everyone in his platoon, and he did not deserve to die the he did. One young soldier was so shaken by guilt, it had caused him to freeze and act completely different from then on. These feelings of guilt had weighed a lot, and also had took a toll on each solider.
Grief is mainly what people deal with after the death of a loved one. Some people tend to stay in the grief stage for a really long time and it can affect their daily life in negative ways because maybe they don’t have the energy to do activities or other stuff with ones that are still alive since they prefer to be alone. In the “Things They Carried”, O’Brien shows grief because he has to deal with the loss and death of the man he killed. Furthermore, death loss can be one of the worst burdens people have to deal with in their everyday lives.
An example of how Kiowa was an emotional compass for the group, is when Tim O’Brien killed a man and was having a hard time with cooping. “Think it over,’ Kiowa said. Then later he said, ‘Tim it’s a war. The guy wasn’t Heidi–he had a weapon, right? It’s a tough thing, for sure, but you got to cut out that staring” (O’Brien 120).
Kiowa knows it is wrong to bring war into a place of peace. With this peace of mind, it shows how good of a person Kiowa is. It showed why people like him as a person. In a like manner, O’Brien discusses morality in the chapter “The Man I Killed.”
1.Guilt is one of the worst things accompanied by death. Guilt plays a huge role throughout the novel. In war, men are constantly dying and these men all become best friends with one another. For example, Norman Bowker felt a tremendous amount of quilt towards the death of Kiowa.
The loss of innocence and gain of war trauma affects almost every soldier in the war either during or after the war. Which is seen through the killing of Kiowa and the death throughout the chapters. O'Brien had tried to show Kiowa a picture at night with and turned a flashlight on and
He accepted the blame of Ted Lavender’s death because he was more focused on Martha than he was about his troops. Wesley states that while Jimmy Cross accepts the blame he thinks this will make it all better by accepting heroic responsibility. This relieved the stress upon Cross and made him feel as if he was even more of a leader and not a coward. When Ted Lavender died they treated it as if it was nothing but a daily routine.