ipl-logo

In Wells Fargo Scandal, The Buck Stopped Well Short Summary

498 Words2 Pages

TL;DR –The Wells Fargo Vice President who oversaw the retail division which was responsible for mass fraud should have been fired rather than allowed to retire.

The article “In Wells Fargo Scandal, the Buck Stopped Well Short” by Susan Ochs examines the behavior of Wells Fargo in regards to the Carrie Tolstedt. Carrie Tolstedt was the Wells Fargo Community Banking senior vice president during the time where thousands of fraudulent accounts were created by employees who directly or indirectly reported to her.

Starting last November, Wells Fargo was under investigation of fraud based on customer complaints concerning account being opened in their name without their knowledge. Ms. Tolstedt was in charge of over 94,000 employees in the Community Banking division during the five years of fraudulent activity. Ms. Tolstedt decided to retire in July, 2016 when the investigation was moving toward finality. Wells Fargo allowed Ms. Tolstedt to retire and take with her around $125 million in stock options while around 5300 of her former employees are getting fired for their part of the fraudulent activities. The author feels Wells Fargo did an injustice to society and Ms. Tolstedt’s former employees by allowing her to retire and take all of her stock options with her, since she should have been …show more content…

Tolstedt’s knowledge unless there was a drastic lack of leadership, which in either case should prevent her from taking her riches and running. The author believes the new rules which were created after the banking crisis would allow Wells Fargo to take back the stock options and possible some of her wages, due to her inadequate supervision and subsequent fraudulent activities of her employees. Would it be ethically responsible for Wells Fargo to pull back the monies, due to the fraudulent activities, from the author’s point of view it definitely would be ethical and

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of The Powerful Benefit By Brittnay Cooper

    194 Words  | 1 Pages

    In the article, " The Powerless Get Punished for Cheating, and the Powerful Benefit", written by Brittnay Cooper, argues that executives are not sent to jail for mortgage fraud that destroy poor neighborhoods. She argues, "Subprime lending fraud by banks like Wells Fargo and other lenders demolished African-American neighborhoods and exacerbated a crisis of black women and families being evicted from their homes yet no major executive has been punished. " The only ones suffering From the cheating are the lower-class because those causing the problems are faced with no penalties and feel as though they can continue these immoral actions. Cooper as argues," republicans are using trumped up evidence from conservative activist to press the case

    Read More

  • How The Wells Fargo Phony Account Scandal Sunk

    727 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the article Wells Fargo’s Reaction to Scandal Fails to Satisfy Angry Lawmakers it mentions how lower-level employees were mainly affected by this unethical behavior and that more than 5,300 employees had been fired due to the unethical practice. Some employees were fired that did not participate in the unethical practice during the scandal were affected as well as a result of not being able to attain the sale goals. Stated in the article, How The Wells Fargo Phony Account Scandal Sunk John Stumpf, “Two former employees filed a $2.6 billion class action suit, alleging branch workers were unfairly fired when they could not meet Wells' aggressive sales quotas.” Customers also suffered because they trusted this bank and its employees to do their job right and they were taken advantage of.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of Sarbanes Oxley Act Of 2002

    1249 Words  | 5 Pages

    As stated by Karen Seymour, Chief of the Criminal Division in Manhattan’s U.S. Attorney’s office in an interview: “I thought it was going to be a really good tool, But it never really developed.” Karen had expectations of seeing CEOs and CFOs being held responsible for fraud. However, over ten years later and only a few defendants have been charged, of that amount even fewer convicted. One of the most notable SOX cases against HealthSouth CEO Richard Scrushy, ended up in an acquittal.

    Read More

  • Joan Britney Case

    760 Words  | 4 Pages

    The second issue that should be addressed is the issue involving Paul Bertuzzi because he had insight to the fraud that was happening within the company, but decided not to say anything about it. This is the next issue to tackle as fraud is a criminal offence. As Paul had knowledge about the scheme that was being planned but wasn’t evolved it does not take first priority. His decision

    Read More

  • Jp Morgan Chase Bank Fraud Essay

    709 Words  | 3 Pages

    JPMorgan Chase Bank has faced several lawsuits in recent years. They have been hit with cases concerning fraudulent misrepresentation, bribery, and many things in between. By studying the accusations the company has faced, one receives a better understanding of who is really handling their money. An act of fraudulent misrepresentation cost JPMorgan the fine of a lifetime.

    Read More

  • Wells Fargo: The Scandal Of Wells Fargo

    187 Words  | 1 Pages

    As all this came to fruition, the bank was penalized with $185 million dollars in fines and other penalties by county and federal organizations (Blake, 2016). On top of getting slapped with millions of dollars worth of fines, Wells Fargo fired 5,300 employees that may have been involved in the scandal (Blake, 2016). Some of Wells Fargo’s top executives where asked to step down in court proceedings as well as in other meetings with federal agencies. There have also been several lawsuits filed against Wells Fargo by customers and former employees of the company that feel that they were wronged and bombarded with threats. Thankfully, this scandal did not affect most of Wells Fargo’s clients.

    Read More

  • The Big Short Movie Analysis

    1221 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Big Short, it seems as if almost nobody has any ethics at all. Firstly, the banks hugely increased the market for synthetic CDO’s. This is borderline illegal and should be illegal but isn’t. These were a huge contribution to why the housing market collapsed.

    Read More

  • Case Study Wells Fargo

    476 Words  | 2 Pages

    After numerous reports to the ethics line, it is almost certain that Wells Fargo officials had some knowledge of the scandal. Additionally, the inaccurate U5 forms “...confirm that Wells Fargo had ample information about the scope of fraudulent sales practices” (Cowley). Senator Elizabeth Warren “…publicly condemned [CEO John Stumpf] for his ‘gutless leadership’” in preventing and handling corruption within his company (Egan, Wattles, and

    Read More

  • Essay On Fiduciary Duty

    1765 Words  | 8 Pages

    Fiduciary duty: A fiduciary duty is a legal obligation to act in the best interest of a client or broader corporate entity. It sets the expectation that directors and officers place the interests of the firm over their personal interests. Business judgment rule: The business judgment rule lays out two requirements for directors and officers: that they uphold the duty of care and the duty of loyalty.

    Read More

  • Wells Fargo's Ethical Ethics Of Wells Fargo Financial Corporation

    1347 Words  | 6 Pages

    When it comes to the Ethical Decision Model, it does not just pertain to the employees who opened these accounts but also leadership who either failed to realize what was going on or decided to sweep it under the rug by just covertly firing some employees. Wells Fargo did take the first step in recognizing the problem but failed to define it, which explains why these unethical behaviors continued for so many years. When the corporation was initially aware of what was going on, they should have acted immediately and strategized a solution that would dilute the possibility of it occurring again. Instead of defining the problem, which would have foster, a proper solution but company decided to just terminate

    Read More

  • Fraud In Enron's Failure

    821 Words  | 4 Pages

    Starting in 1990s, a wave of corporate frauds in the United States occurred with Enron’s failure perhaps being the emblematic example. Jeffords (1992) examined 910 cases of frauds submitted to the “Internal Auditor” during the nine-year period from 1981 to 1989 to assess the specific risk factors cited in the Treadway Commission Report. He concluded that “approximately 63 percent of the 910 fraud cases are classified under the internal control risks.” Calderon and Green (1994) did an analysis of 114 actual cases of business fraud published in the “Internal Auditor” during 1986 to 1990. They concluded that limited separation of duties, false documentation, and inadequate (or non-existent) control were the main reasons for 60% of the fraud

    Read More

  • Wells Fargo Scandal Summary

    1237 Words  | 5 Pages

    The then CEO John Stumpf was forced to resign following insurmountable political and public pressure. Federal prosecutors also issued subpoenas and congressional hearings were held, for which then CEO John Stumpf attended. Additionally, on February 21, 2017, Wells Fargo terminated four high level executives involved in the scandalous news. The SEC’s investigation consists of warrants against bank executives for possible violations of GAAP principles and the Sarbanes-Oxley Act for inaccurate accounting practices. The SEC will probe possible violations of employee whistleblowing protection under the Sarbanes-Oxley and Frank-Dodson Act.

    Read More

  • Wells Fargo Ethical Theories

    468 Words  | 2 Pages

    Under this approach, an action is considered morally bad because of some characteristic of the action itself, not just because the product of the action is bad. Wells Fargo unethical practices demonstrates unethical behavior, under deontological ethical theories as its employees duty to operate in an honest and fair fashion , in providing services to the public. Wells Fargo codes of conduct does not permit sales practices of these sort, therefore the employees who participated in these practices made unethical decisions. Unfortunately there was a wrong-doing on a massive scale. The acts of unethical behavior were conducted by both the employees and management.

    Read More

  • Lehman Brothers: Financial Fraud In 2008

    2178 Words  | 9 Pages

    Executive Summary Lehman Brothers were an investment bank involved in transactions worth billions of dollars and one of the most powerful investment banks in the world. Lehman Brothers collapsed in 2008 following bad investment in the sub-prime mortgage market and used bad accounting practices called Repo 105 transactions to try and cover up the bad assets. This report sets out the use of the fraud triangle when describing the actions which led to the collapse. The pressure applied on the bank, the opportunity due to the lack of regulation to carry out the actions and the ability of the bank to rationalise their decision making.

    Read More

  • Worldcom Case Study

    902 Words  | 4 Pages

    1. What factors in the WorldCom case support the conclusion that CEO Bernie Ebbers Knew about the financial statement fraud? What factors support his defense that he did not know about the fraud? Bernie Ebbers Knew about the financial statement fraud because he was the one who encourage others to go into financial fraud because of the stock prices were going down, which was affecting his marginal loan. For that reason, he was trying to sell his stock, but the board of Directors lent him $341 million, along with 2% interest rate.

    Read More

More about In Wells Fargo Scandal, The Buck Stopped Well Short Summary

Open Document