Summary: Despite the fact that the two articles have the same theme of “rhetorical situation,” these two authors have completely different point of views on the relationship between rhetorical and situation. In “The Rhetorical Situation,” Lloyd Bitzer starts the article by asking a “confusing” question–what is a rhetorical situation? In order to explain his question, he puts it in another way by referring rhetorical situation to “the nature of those contexts in which speakers or writers create rhetorical discourse” (1). He believes that the presence of rhetorical discourse usually indicates the presence of a rhetorical situation, but the existence of situations is not caused by discourse. And he writes this article to …show more content…
And more importantly for him, the situation is the fundamental element of rhetorical activity. Bitzer defines Rhetorical situation as, “A complex of persons, events, objects, and relations presenting an actual or potential exigence which can be completely or partially removed if discourse, introduced into the situation, can so constrain human decision or action as to bring about the significant modification of the exigence.” In describing “Rhetorical Situation” Bitzer also mentions 3 constituents of it: First of all, the exigence—an “imperfection” or a “defect,” which is also the need of having something to be done. There is a variety of exigencies. An exigence will be classified as rhetorical only when it allows positive modification and the positive modification is based on discourse. The second constituent is the audience. The audience in this case plays the role of …show more content…
Unlike Bitzer, who considers the situation as the primary factor which produces a rhetorical discourse; Vatz, implies that rhetorical discourse creates the situation. (He believes that “the meaning is not discovered in situations, but created by rhetors.”) And he regards the rhetor as the most important one who make choices and constructs rhetorical meanings. In explaining the importance of rhetor, He writes that there are two main steps in “communicating situations”: the first is the selections on events for communicating; the second is the translation or our own understanding of the selected
Click here to unlock this and over one million essaysShow More
Grant-Davie describes thoroughly the term rhetorical situation and how the development of the definition and its constituents has contributed to the discovery of the motives and responses behind any discourse. The analysis of rhetorical situations could determine the outer or inner influences of the rhetors, the audience, and their particular constraints. Grant Davie supports his claims by using the earlier definitions of scholars and teachers as his foundation. He also addresses his own analysis drawn by life experienced discourses which it also helps the reader understand the causes of rhetorical situations. This is important because it teaches any writer or reader to analyze a situation and think about the options and paths it could lead
Rhetorical Analysis Essay In her Article “How to Stop Stewing,” a general assistant reporter Diana Opong makes the argument that even a small gesture can have a significant effect on others. It’s easy to become caught up in our own lives and overlook the impact of our actions on those around us. To gain clarity when things feel personal, it’s important to slow down and consider our own actions, as well as the motivations behind them. Through her use of anecdotes and imagery, Opong teaches us to consider our own actions and reactions in a more balanced and objective way.
Many people have a certain opinion when it comes to their standing on tattoos, whether they see them as beautiful pieces of art, or body mutilation, everyone subscribes to a different belief. Many people who see teenagers, believe that these teens are “troubled”, or impulsive and impressionable, which at that point in the brain’s development that may be true, but they never consider that maybe that teen is ready, or is willing to commit to the tattoo simply because it is something that has importance to them. Andres Martin, a child psychiatrist, wrote an article in a 2000 edition of the magazine “Reclaiming Our Children and Youth” about teenagers and tattoos, where he directly addresses the reasons that would support the ideas behind teens getting tattoos. Andres
What is the rhetorical mode? What is it about the essay that demonstrates that it is that mode? In the reading “Just Walk On By” I can totally relate what he's going through as I a black man, I've experienced something very similar, but I feel that the essay’s rhetorical mode is exemplification because he uses specific details, examples, and facts to add interest and to get his thesis/Pov across.
When arguing for racial equality, James Farmer Jr. quotes St.Augustine, “An unjust law is no law at all.” He claims that just laws are meant to protect all citizens; whereas, unjust laws that discriminate Negroes are not laws to be followed, thus raising awareness of racial discrimination by using emotional and logical appeals. In The Great Debaters, Henry Lowe appeals to the audience’s emotions during a debate about Negro integration into state universities. To challenge his opponent’s claim that the South isn 't ready to integrate Negroes into universities, he affirms that if change wasn’t forcefully brought upon the South, Negroes would “still be in chains,” which is an allusion to slavery. With this point, he is able to raise awareness of
CAS100C Lesson 1 Assignment Lu Jia 1. a. According to Dr. Zarefsky, a rhetorical situation refers to a situation in which people’s understanding can be changed through messages. It has four basic components: the audience, the speaker, the occasion and the speech. A hypothetical example of a rhetorical situation is when a student (let’s call her Alice T) is running for Student Union president and is making a speech to emphasize her strengths and try to influence her fellow classmates to vote for her.
Grant-Davie opens his writing with numerous definitions of a rhetorical situation. He then says that these definitions do not grasp the complexity of rhetorical situations. To fully understand a rhetorical situation, he suggests an analysis of the exigence, recognizing that rhetors and audience are both a part of a rhetorical situation, and that there may be multiple rhetors or audience. Grant-Davie then stated the four constituents in rhetorical situations that are exigence, rhetors, audiences, and constraints.
The type of rhetorical text that I decided to analyze is a song. The title of the song is called Skyscraper, and it is written and sung by Demi Lovato. The main theme of this song is strength and rising above your own demons, and those who bring you down. It is about not allowing anything or anyone destroy the person that you are, and overcoming what may damage you. This song was actually written during a time when Demi herself was struggling with an eating disorder and self harm.
Rhetorical strategies are a variety of parts that make up an essay. The strategies include everything from explaining a process, to structure of writing. Whether the author 's purpose is to entertain, inform, or persuade, ultimately these strategies will strengthen not only the author’s purpose, but also the writing itsef. Typically when authors use these strategies, they are very precise to how they use them, and when deeply analysing a piece of writing, this is very clear. In Bell Hooks’ “Understanding Patriarchy”, she used rhetorical strategies to convey her purpose.
In his landmark essay, "The Rhetorical Situation," rhetorical scholar Lloyd Bitzer laid out some of the basic components of the rhetorical situation. Bitzer views rhetoric as a action and not just hot air and fancy words. He defines rhetoric as “A mode of altering reality, not by the direct application of energy to objects, but by the creation of discourse which changes reality through the mediation of thought and action.” He sees rhetoric as a way to learn how to get things done. Rhetoric can be applied to practical things.
Evolution. Evolution was a notion theorized by Charles Darwin to understand how one species can become another animal in a matter of a few generations, or how animals develop tiny changes within their body to adapt to their environment. As humans continue to advance into the realm of technology, we find ourselves in a path of our own evolution. Evolving in every minute aspect there is. For example, we have developed medicinal treatments to treat diseases or conditions that were once thought as incurable.
The cereal box assignment taught me about how companies want to sell their products at any costs. For example, if you are a person who likes to eat only healthy foods, companies will make their products more expensive and colorful, so people don’t care that it’s that expensive at all, all they care about that it’s healthy. Don’t get me wrong, I think eating healthy is right, but it’s what companies are doing to get people to buy their products is what I believe to be wrong. When doing the bicycle sales assignment for clowns, I used the Rhetorical situation; I was careful on choosing my text, my context and my audience and the communicator what I have learned from doing this assignment is that with patience and the Rhetorical situation