To have cultural relativism or not to have cultural relativism this is the question? Cultural relativism is the idea that the beliefs and practices of a culture should be understood within the context of that particulars culture 's background, history and current events surrounding it. In order to fully understand someone else 's culture you have to take yourself out of the picture, by taking an insider 's view toward a different culture that your unfamiliar with, while doing an outsiders view on your own culture. From an etic perspective, I will address some of America 's rite of passages, that people go through, while addressing a rite of passage that Americans have in common with other countries. In addition, I will describe the …show more content…
According to Arnold Van Gennep " we move from one status to another within the lifecycle, the life events and status changes that are typically experienced by individuals are commonly proclaimed to other members of society by formal rituals known as life crisis rites of passages". The main question is understanding why rite of passages are so important to countries culture. Certain rites of passages helps us grow into the person we become in today 's world. The reason why we celebrate these rituals are because in the eyes of society status changes is very important. Some things that are considered a rite of passage are christenings, puberty rituals, marriages, and funerals. There are four public ceremonies: celebrations of puberty( which mark the beginning of adulthood). marriages( which legalizes new sexual, economic and child bearing obligations). funerals( which celebrate the lost of human status by the deceased and restructure the ongoing social order). All of these play a huge role in the American customs. Specifically child birth, marriages, puberty rituals, and funerals are just some of the rites of passages that people go through. Using an etic and emic mindset helps you to understand not only your rite of passages, but other cultures rite of passages …show more content…
Based on a study of 186 "traditional" cultures, Schlegel and Barry found that most had puberty rituals for adolescents. (Schlegel, Barry, 1991)Few people in the United States actually go through a puberty ritual, but America does have transitions.(Crapo, 2013) A few examples are receiving a drivers license during teenage years, graduating from high school, gaining the right to vote at the age of 18, becoming old enough to drink alcohol legally. Most rituals for boys to manhood is severe and painful. For example circumcision, scarification of the body, (decorating the body with a pattern made of scars. Marriage is another rite of passage that many people will do. In America people are getting married at an older age, than before. The median age of males that are getting married for the first time is 26 years, while females are over 23 years. ( Crapo, 2013) Most people in the United States actually marry someone who lives a few miles to them.(Crapo, 2013) Although the internet is one of the most popular things in today 's world, there 's only 3% of married people who met on the
In the article ‘Body Ritual Among the Nacirema’ written by Horace Miner he goes on to describe the culture and rituals of the Nacirema. A group of North Americans that are found “between the Canadian Cree, the Yaqui and Tarahumare of Mexico, and the Carib and Arawak of the Antilles.” Throughout the article he describes American rituals from an outsiders point
The statement “rites of passage” is commonly used to explain a major event in a person 's life. Everyone in their life will go through many rites of passage such as birth, marriage, prom, etc. Rites of passage are can often be found in literature such as Katniss Everdeen and Harry Potter. Another major one is Alyss from the Looking Glass Wars becoming more mature. In Looking Glass Wars Beddor uses rites of passage to convey Alyss becoming more mature in preparation to become a queen.
They say everyone goes through the rite of passage; however the way people went through it is unique. Rite of passage is the transition from one phase of life to another phase. This can be seen in the book The Goose Girl written by Shannon Hale. Where the readers follow the main character Ani's journey, through the stages of rite of passage. Ani's separation in the rite of passage is when she is forced to run off into the forest.
Scene 1 Both: (Black background) Hello ladies! Welcome to Culture Identity! Jade: Do you or anyone you know find it hard to balance your culture and the American culture?
In, Marriage in the Jewish Tradition, by Blu Greenberg, a Jewish marriage “is a change in personal status. Neither sacrament nor mere legal transaction, it enjoys the trappings of…the richness of ceremony and rite” (7). The rite of passage of a Jewish wedding symbolizes the transition “between the couple and their families, and especially the separation of the girl-youth from her family and her joining her husband’s family” (Sharaby 41). The couple experience a moment where they are neither married nor single before they reach their new identity. In Van Gennep’s timeline of rites of passage, a Jewish wedding follows the three main stages.
Cultural relativism is the understanding of other cultures in their own terms. To achieve the understanding of the rituals used in the cultures of another, one must be able to look at them from an emic (insider) perspective. One must also be able to look at his own culture from an etic (outsider) perspective. The ability to look at one’s culture from the etic point of view will make it easier to explain the rituals to someone from a different culture, for example, rites of passage. Rites of passage are used to mark a life stage and are celebrated by tradition or religion, meant to separate a specific group.
Today, in most countries people marry after a period of dating and engagement. Usually marriage happens when individuals are at an older and more mature than in the Elizabethan era. Present today are opportunities to know someone before marriage
The ethics of cultural relativism are different than traditional ethical theories mainly because cultural relativism dismisses morality. Cultural relativism is named so because the ethics of different cultures
These rituals also create a sense of moral community, in which people conform to, which furthers their purpose and meaning in
Well, that is a false statement. The average age for a man to get married is twenty nine years old and the average age for a woman to get married is at twenty six. At the age of 14 and up most teens have no idea how to take care of themselves. Women that marry under the age of 18 are most likely to go into poverty because they drop out of school and, therefore, lack the knowledge of how to meet the family needs. Did you know about fifteen million girls are married before the age of eighteen each year?
Each culture has several examples of rites of passage that occur as early as birth and as late in life as death. One good example of a rite of passage is a high school graduation, because it marks a young adult’s transition from a student to a graduate. When you analyze the graduation ceremony, each phase can be seen and explained quite clearly. The first of the three phases in a rite of passage is called the separation phase. It is defined as the part of the rite of passage when the person is removed as a member of his or her previous society.
It is an over-optimistic argument as cultural relativism has a more logical way of reasoning, for at least two reasons. First, it reminds us that objective truth does not have a plausible standard in every culture that is peculiar to the society. Furthermore, it shows that every value must be less universal as every society has its own moral code. For example, eating the flesh of our parents is dreadful to a normal person. However, for the Callatian (Blanco, 2013), it is a sign of respect as the person’s spirit will dwell within them.
(Luco, Week 3 Notes, p.9) Cultural Relativism is simply a combination of the following three theses: 1. The only criterion of moral truth or falsehood is the moral code of a cultural group. 2. A moral claim is true, relative to a culture’s moral code, if and only if the claim is generally accepted within that cultural
Ethnocentrism and its prevalence in U.S culture Ethnocentrism is judging another culture solely by the values and standards of one’s own culture. Individuals who are ethnocentric judge other groups in relation to their own ethnic group or culture. I think The United States likes to refer to themselves as the “big mixing pot” of cultures. I would agree, we do have a wide range of different cultures, but that does not mean that we do not “evaluate and judge other cultures based on how they compare to our own cultural norms.” I think us as Americans feel this way, because we are too scared to change what we have learned and known since birth.
Throughout this essay, cultural relativism will be questioned, but also supported in some ways. The idea of cultural relativism reminds me of a sociological term--ethnocentrism--that essentially means the opposite. Ethnocentrism is essentially a bias about your own culture against other cultures. One can only see their culture (usually as dominant to the others), rather than attempting to see the perspective of whatever culture is in question. An example of real-life cultural relativism is female circumsition or clitordectomy.