ipl-logo

Difference Between Jefferson And Hamilton

458 Words2 Pages

Strict v Loose Interpretation of The Constitution Thomas Jefferson believed in a strict interpretation of the Constitution while Alexander Hamilton believed in a loose interpretation of the Constitution. Jefferson believed that they should follow the Constitution word for word and not change a single thing. When it came to the national bank, he believed in a strict interpretation, as well. But he believed in a loose interpretation of the Louisiana Purchase. Alexander Hamilton believed in a loose construction of the Constitution, and also the national bank. He thought that the government could do whatever they wanted if the Constitution did not directly forbid it. Jefferson and Hamilton both had a really loose interpretation of the Louisiana …show more content…

But that is what Hamilton thought that is what was necessary. Jefferson and Hamilton never got along with anything. With both of them being from different parties they were always getting into political arguments over what the government should do with national banks and with how the constitution should be interpreted.
With the national banks Hamilton wanted a national bank and Jefferson did not want one. Jefferson argued against the bank. There was nothing given to the national government in the Constitution, and he kept thinking that all powers not specifically given to the central government were given to the states. So Jefferson believed that only the states had the power to fund banks. Jefferson believed that the Constitution should be interpreted literally. Which is where the strict constitutional interpretation idea comes from. Hamilton believed that what the Constitution did not forbid it. It did not say that the national bank was completely against the Constitution. Jefferson was convinced that the tenth amendment stated that they had no right do so. The faction federalists, who would soon become the political party, Federalists, believed in loose construction/ the "elastic clause."
Hamilton's argument convinced Washington, who signed the bank into Law

Show More
Related

  • Alexander Hamilton And Thomas Jefferson: First National Bank Of The United States

    333 Words  | 2 Pages

    Both Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson had different opinions on how the First National Bank of The United States should be set up and if it goes by what is stated in the Constitution, which led to an argument between federalist and antifederalist in 1791. Federalist, Alexander Hamilton, was a strong believer in the development of a strong central government and broad a interpretation of the Constitution. On the other hand anti-federalist, Thomas Jefferson, was convinced that the government should have to undergo a strict interpretation of the Constitution and that the government shouldn't interfere, more than needed to, in the lives of the American people. Hamilton recommended that the government should in fact make the Bank of the

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Jefferson And Hamilton's Economic Plan

    327 Words  | 2 Pages

    A lot of nation’s investors found this alluring. It would also tie them to the new national government, since they would want that them to survive so they could get paid on their investment. Jefferson and Madison opposed Hamilton’s debt funding plan. They believed that

    Read More

  • The Controversy Between Hamilton And Jefferson Regarding The Bank Of The United States

    369 Words  | 2 Pages

    During the debate between Hamilton and Jefferson regarding the Bank of the United States, both used the elastic clause (Article 1, Section 8, clause 18) and the tenth amendment in the preamble as justification to their positions. When Alexander Hamilton presented his Report on a National Bank to Congress, he had specific proposals in his plan for his bank, which is what caused a great rift between Hamilton and Jefferson. The main proposals Hamilton had that was refuted by Jefferson were based along the lines of the worth of the bank's stock, the shares sold at a pricing of $400 per share, how the bank would be run by its elected board, and its ability to establish offices in other cities. The reasoning as to why Jefferson was so opposed to

    Read More

  • The Great National Bank Debate Between Thomas Jefferson And Alexander Hamilton

    1512 Words  | 7 Pages

    The Great National Bank Debate was an argument between Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton about if a national bank should be established for the U.S. This would be decided by George Washington. Alexander Hamilton thought the national bank would be great for U.S. trade and it would give a central place for financial actions. This bank would be the biggest financial corporation, bigger than any other nation (Hill) But, Thomas Jefferson thought the opposite and believed that a national bank would only cause problems for the future of the U.S. Washington should approve Thomas Jefferson's proposal of no national bank because it would give the U.S too strong of a central government, would benefit and grow the upper class and financially corrupt

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast The Beliefs Of The Colonies In The Late 1700s

    622 Words  | 3 Pages

    There were many different beliefs throughout the colonies in the late 1700s. Jefferson did not believe in a strong Federal government, he believed in a government run by all educated men. Jefferson wanted a strict construction of the Constitution. When Hamilton introduced the idea of a Federal Bank, Jefferson disagreed with him, saying that the constitution did not give the government the power to create a Federal Bank.

    Read More

  • What Is Alexander Hamilton Necessary?

    961 Words  | 4 Pages

    The need for a national bank was very much so necessary. Hamilton also convinced president Washington to sign the bank bill by his lengthy report that stated: “This criterion is the end, to which the measure relates as a mean. If the end be clearly comprehended withan any specified powers, collecting taxes and regulating the currency, and if the measure have an obvious relation to that end, and is not forbidden by any particular provision of the constitution, it may safely be deemed to come with the compass of national authority.”

    Read More

  • How Did Hamilton Influence Political Parties

    297 Words  | 2 Pages

    Hamilton interpreted the Constitution more loosely and thought a bank was necessary, however Jefferson was against this since the Constitution didn’t give Congress the power to create a Bank. The main three differences between Hamilton and Jefferson were on what should drive the country, government power and the interpretation

    Read More

  • Contrasting Views Of Thomas Jefferson And Alexander Hamilton

    1048 Words  | 5 Pages

    From 1794-1824, Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton had contrasting views on how the government and country should operate. Hamilton focused on fixing short-term financial issues through his Financial Plan by uniting the states under a national bank and creating protective tariffs to establish American manufacturing. Jefferson opposed many of Hamilton's ideas because he feared they would give too much power to the federal government. He encouraged farming and resisted Hamilton's belief in a strong manufacturing system. Both visions fought one another to gain favor, but one was more prominent overall.

    Read More

  • Relationship Between Federalists And Alexander Hamilton

    208 Words  | 1 Pages

    Alexander Hamilton and the Federalist had different ideas did Thomas Jefferson and the Republicans. (Schultz, K. M. 203). The Federalists believed they could learn a lot from Great Britain and that the United States should be designed like England 's government. they wanted centralized bank and Federal Constitution.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Hamilton's Blessing

    1403 Words  | 6 Pages

    The creation of the first bank in the United States prompted a political debate which started in 1791, and went on in the following years. Hamilton’s plan foresaw a bank provided with special powers and privileges, which gave birth to a wide opposition. Although Hamilton 's idea continues to exist in today’s economic environment, at that time his proposal was met with widespread resistance from individuals such as James Madison and Thomas Jefferson, who considered the creation of a federal bank as unconstitutional. Following to a broad interpretation of the Constitution, Hamilton argued that in order to have an effective bank, Congress should be provided with all the powers required. Jefferson disagreed with Hamilton, and claimed that the establishment of such a bank was not consistent with the powers that the Constitution granted to Congress.

    Read More

  • Jefferson Vs Hamilton Research Paper

    283 Words  | 2 Pages

    Hamilton interpreted it loosely while Jefferson was strict. This led to an argument about whether the creation of a national bank was constitutional; Hamilton stated it was while Jefferson claimed it wasn’t. Another issue that they clashed

    Read More

  • Comparing Thomas Jefferson And Alexander Hamilton

    649 Words  | 3 Pages

    Each one had their own view of how to do this, but it was a main goal of both politicians. Alexander Hamilton was a founding father and leader of the Federalist party. Hamilton wanted America to be just like Great Britain. He believed that in the best interest for the country, the government should be run by elite people with lots of money. Hamilton was The United States Secretary of Treasury, during this time, and proposed many of his reform ideas to Congress.

    Read More

  • Alexander Hamilton's Transportation Revolution

    1568 Words  | 7 Pages

    Hamilton wanted to create public credit with a treasury system, a national bank, a mint, and increase manufacturing which would help unify the country. On the other hand, there was Jefferson, who opposed a strong central government. He argued that the “wealthy would gain at the expense of ordinary Americans and that Hamilton’s political economy would corrupt the morality of citizens and undermine the social conditions essential to republican government”(Powerpoint). The country would opt for an approach closer to Hamilton’s views. One of the first acts was the National Banking Act.

    Read More

  • Similarities Between Jefferson And Hamilton

    1449 Words  | 6 Pages

    Hamilton vs. Jefferson Visions to Reality     Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton both had very defined visions of the scope and power of the new federal government, how they saw the future of the economic development, and what the United States society should become. In my opinion Alexander Hamilton had more of an impact on the United States during the 1820’s and on contemporary government when compared to Thomas Jefferson. His policies did not strictly work during that time and many of his ideas are still seen in today’s society. Jefferson’s views and ideas on/of the national bank, higher tariffs, debt assumption, The Federalist Party, and his support of the ratification of the Constitution are all reasons in why his policies and visions came closer to becoming a reality.     Thomas Jefferson and Alexander Hamilton, molded the gatherings that provoked to the twofold party system under which the U.S. works today.

    Read More

  • Comparing Alexander Hamilton And Thomas Jefferson

    497 Words  | 2 Pages

    There was many differences between Alexander Hamilton and Thomas Jefferson,they both had different ideas of how to run the country. Hamilton was a Federalist; he wanted the nation government to be strong , while Jefferson was a Democratic- Republic, he wanted the states to hold more power.(Competing Visions of Government: The Federalists vs. the Republicans) They both have different views in political issues and ideals for the country. Alexander Hamilton wanted a strong central government because he experienced the results of a weak central authority.(The Differences Between Hamilton & Jefferson's Views on Political Party Beliefs)On the other hand Thomas Jefferson wanted a weak central government because he thought that the threat of cruel

    Read More

More about Difference Between Jefferson And Hamilton

Open Document