ipl-logo

Case Study: Incapacity

1457 Words6 Pages

1. Summarize the case (1/2 page) The case that I am analyzing is the Incapacity Case Study, which outlines a situation with a teacher who is inappropriate with his students and ultimately faces the consequences. The teacher was found to be using foul language towards the students, and allowing for both inappropriate and illegal actions in her classes, such as smoking or drinking alcohol. Additionally, she was absent from school without notification more than once and missed important deadlines for submission of grades to be put on report cards. Following a meeting with the principle and a board investigation, mental illness was identified and the teacher was placed on paid sick leave. Following a concerning letter from the teacher, the investigation …show more content…

Identify the legal (citing specific education laws) AND ethical (citing specific OCT principles) issues. (1-2 pages) The legal and ethical issues in the Incapacity Case Study are based on the actions that took place while the teacher was in the presence of students and others in the school. The ethical issue violations include those of care, respect and integrity, while the education laws that are called into question are those of morals and absences The ethical standards of the OCT are vital values for teachers to be successful in a school. Care is outlined as involving compassion, acceptance and interest for one’s students, which the teacher did not follow through her yelling of curse words and her disregard for illegal actions taking place under her supervision. The OCT ethical standards on respect involve aspects of human dignity and emotional wellness. The teacher under investigation failed to show human dignity by shouting foul words and disrespectful insults at the students in her class. By swearing at her students, a lack of respect for emotional wellness is shown as well. The teacher is clearly unable to show respect for her own emotional wellness throughout the investigation, as evident in her handwritten letter accusing the principal of ruining her reputation, and her inability to fill the prescription for her medication out of fear. Under the umbrella of integrity, the reliability and moral action of the teacher can be called into question when evaluating …show more content…

My case focused on the mental health and illness of a high school teacher who was influencing adolescents by her inappropriate behaviour in the classroom. The article Mental Health in Schools: How Teachers Have the Power to Make a Difference discusses the role that teachers have in promoting mental health awareness and how a teacher can intervene to assist a student in need (Meldrum et al 3). The content of my case relates to this article by citing the importance of awareness, identification and intervention when someone is suffering from a mental illness, and how an individual can take a stand to assist in the recovery of a mental illness (Meldrum et al 4). Additionally, the case that I have analysed relates to the safety of the school community members. As discussed in the Parents’ Guide to the Ontario Code of Conduct, the standards of behaviour directly relate to the issue at hand in the Incapacity Case Study, as it is stated that “School community members must not: give alcohol to anyone under the legal drinking age” which took place before the removal of the teacher from the classroom (2). This document outlines the requirements of all school members, including staff, in order to promote a “positive school climate and a safe learning and teaching environment,” a topic that we have discussed greatly in PROF310 (Parents’ Guide to the Ontario Code of

Show More
Related

  • Mgt 311 Week 3 Discussion 1

    682 Words  | 3 Pages

    Superintendent Elliott made some errors in this situation. A couple of the errors were responding to the parent complaint without referring him to the proper level and failing to listen to the principal. The complaint that was made by the parent is something that should have been handled by the building principal. Instead of trying to take care of the situation himself the superintendent he should have led the parent to the correct building level channel first to come to allow them the chance to come to a solution. The building principal should have been able to build a stronger school community relation with this parent by being honest and handling his mistake.

    Read More

  • Being A Victim's Assistant Case Study Essay

    1123 Words  | 5 Pages

    She would avoid angering her fellow officers, the victim, or putting the victim in danger by arresting Liz, which could lead to retaliation against Kate. 2. Case Study 2 a. The ethical dilemma for Jane deciding between upholding her confidential relationship with her client and to take no action, or to report Linda and her son’s use of peyote to the proper authorities. b.

    Read More

  • How Did Principal Goings Frame The Problem Involving Mr. Watson?

    747 Words  | 3 Pages

    Mr. Watson’ actions cause a clear disservice to students being observed and in order to address the severity of attendance, emphasis needs to be put on teacher accountability, professionalism and instructional

    Read More

  • Savana Redding Case Study

    1265 Words  | 6 Pages

    The majority believes that the circumstances were reasonable for the alleged crime that was being committed in the school. The school has an obligation towards the protection for the other students and to maintain order within the school and that the rules of the school not to be broken. The search for the pills are considered just because the search was of places that the pills could have been hidden and if not for the fact the rules were broken and the information about Redding’s disbarment of pills were brought to the attention of the school officials the search would not have occurred. The main disagreements between the parties are the way in which the search was handled. It is an agreement that what the student decided to do were against

    Read More

  • Seacrest High School Violence Analysis

    516 Words  | 3 Pages

    The incident was investigated by the State Board of Human Relation and the US Department of Justice. The outcome of the incident required the school district to appoint a monitor who was tasked with overseeing the many measures that would be taken to ensure student

    Read More

  • Conners Assignment

    770 Words  | 4 Pages

    To illustrate, on the teacher form, item 33 says “has forced someone into sexual activity” and item 43 says “is cold-hearted and cruel”. With that in mind, my boyfriend and I did not react to any of the items. Although my boyfriend had no prior knowledge of the Conner’s, he explained that he anticipated there would be items of that nature on the form because it was being used to assess difficulties. Items may elicit emotional responses or be concerning to real parents and teachers, especially if the most problematic items apply to their child or student. Asking about sensitive topics may make children, parents, teachers uncomfortable.

    Read More

  • Summary Of If You Don T Feed The Teachers By Neil Connors

    331 Words  | 2 Pages

    Teachers must feel welcomed, valued and safe in their environment. To achieve that end, the

    Read More

  • Principal Miller Case Study

    565 Words  | 3 Pages

    Using this model would allow Mr. Miller to review the mission of the school, determine whether ability grouping is aligned with the mission, and select an alternative that reflects the mission. 3. What action, if any, should Principal Miller take to demonstrate that he is an educational leader who treats people fairly, equitably, and with dignity and respect? Following Standard 3, Principal Miller should involve families and other stakeholders in the decision-making process. Mr. Miller should select and utilize a group decision technique will allow the opinions of the groups of parents, as well as other individuals and groups, to be heard and present their point of

    Read More

  • No Teachers Should Not Carry Guns Summary

    1484 Words  | 6 Pages

    The author used circumstances with ethos to argue that the teachers should not be

    Read More

  • Tda 3.1 Explain The Strategic Purpose Of School Governors

    918 Words  | 4 Pages

    The strategic purpose of school governors is to support the school in many ways. This includes, making sure there is a clear vision, ethos and strategic direction within the school. They support the head teacher and hold them accountable for the educational performance of the school and its pupils. They will oversee the financial performance of the school and make sure its money is spent in the right areas. They will also carry out a number of other significant duties, which include the appointing and dismissing of staff, hearing appeals and grievances, forming policy on the school's curriculum, setting standards for pupils' behaviour and discipline and setting and monitoring the school's aims and policies.

    Read More

  • One With A Criminal Conviction Should Never Be A Teacher?

    860 Words  | 4 Pages

    Lastly, I would advise them to contact administration if any additional concerns arise. Educators, administrators, and support school personnel have the great honor of serving today’s youth. We must always protect the students, ensuring their safety as if they were our own, and we must listen to the concerns of all key stakeholders for we serve the

    Read More

  • Medical Model Of Disability

    1144 Words  | 5 Pages

    In this report I will discuss both the Social and Medical Models, define their pros and cons and give a short reflection on my own opinion of the two models in everyday use today. Both the medical and the social models of disability describe how they see disability and how they feel disabilities and those suffering should be treated. Both models have very different views on the causes of, how disabilities should be taken care of and by whom and both have their strengths and weaknesses when it comes to caring for those with disabilities. Medical Model

    Read More

  • Police Observation In Elementary Education

    395 Words  | 2 Pages

    My question is why do people say they 're innocent even if they know there 's evidence to prove they’re guilty. Another thing i found interesting is that students are allowed to stay the night at her house, I found that interesting because I have never heard of students staying the night at a teachers house and it being “normal” or “appropriate.” One last thing I found interesting was how she wasn 't fired but simply put on administrative leave. In my opinion if I was the district spokesman I would have simply fired her because if a teacher puts students lives in danger they should not be able to teach.

    Read More

  • Academic Dishonesty Summary

    1295 Words  | 6 Pages

    This article study place in Turkey its aims to evaluate academic dishonesty among university nursing students. 197 students included to this study. It has two instruments to collect data .the first one is a questionnaire and the second is academic dishonesty tendency scale developed. All data analyze using detailed statistics.

    Read More

  • Diversity Of Education

    1159 Words  | 5 Pages

    Subsequently, “in 2017, 79% of teachers in both primary and secondary schools reported seeing an increase in stress, anxiety and panic attacks in their pupils as well as a rise in depression, self-harm, and eating disorders”. The kind of environment that our schools are putting our pupils in is basically fit in or fail. Also, in the classroom, it is said to “try your best” but sometimes the best is not good enough for the school 's standards. Putting all this pressure and responsibilities on one person causes stress, anxiety, and panic attacks. We are taught that “this is how life goes”, but the system once again fails to acknowledge the fact that we are not all equal.

    Read More

More about Case Study: Incapacity

Open Document