ipl-logo

Skinner Vs Psychoanalysis

1006 Words5 Pages

There are several similarities and differences between behaviorism (skinner) and psychoanalysis (Freud).

Both behaviorism and psychoanalysis do not believe in the concept of free will in humans and they are both deterministic. Behavioral approach assets that the environment and the consequences of behavior control people while psychoanalysis believe that people are controlled by their unconscious drives. Through his observations, Freud believed that childhood experiences could lead to emotional problems in adulthood. Skinner in his experiment proved that behavior that produces pleasurable consequences is likely to be repeated whilst that which produces negative consequences is stamped out.

Behaviorism and psychoanalysis both believed that …show more content…

Behaviorists believe that anything to do with cognition is outside the study of psychology and they define psychology as the study of observable behavior whereas Freud placed much emphasis on mental life. Freud divided the mind into three parts the conscious, the preconscious and the unconscious. He believed that the unconscious mind contained desires, inaccessible memories and impulses that are responsible for human behavior.

Skinner embraced psychology as a science by using experiments and observations to prove his theories. The Skinner box was one of Skinner’s most famous experiments and it fulfilled the goals of psychology, which are to describe, explain, predict and control behavior. In contrast, Freud’s theory of human behavior is not scientific. The theory was formulated basing on Freud’s observations of his patients overtime. It cannot be replicated making it impossible to prove the existence of such constructs as the id, ego or superego.

Freud also believed that human behavior has biological bases influenced by the id. Although he failed to prove that human behavior has biological bases, he believed that it would be proven in time. This was in stark contrast to behaviorists who believed that behavior was the product of the environment and its consequences …show more content…

Modern psychology now bases its theories in feasibility and replicability. The fact that most of the constructs in Freud’s theory such as the id, ego and superego cannot be tested and proven has made the theory invalid today. On the other hand, behaviorism is still very valid as its based on scientific laboratory experiments. Behaviorism has been replicated in many studies with the same results being achieved. The theory is still valid in modern therapeutic applications through behavior modification and behavioral therapy e.g flooding and shaping. It is also currently used in the treatment of depression and anxiety

Show More
Related

  • Examples Of One History Graded Influence

    716 Words  | 3 Pages

    Psychoanalytic Theory is an impressive theory of human development that embraces that irrational unconscious drives and motives, often initiated in childhood, that lie beneath human behavior. Behaviorism is a psychological theory that tries to explain why people act the way they do. It emphases on what can be witnessed. And social learning theory expands the ideas found presented by behaviorism.

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud In A Separate Peace

    2370 Words  | 10 Pages

    Originally from Austria, Sigmund Freud was a trained neurologist who was particularly interested in the human psyche. Over many years, Freud developed a theory to explain human behavior, what we refer to now as “Freudian Psychology.” First, he divided the mind into three levels, and used the analogy of an iceberg to help others understand it. On the surface, Freud identified the Conscious. It is here that most of our decision making and ideas are processed.

    Read More

  • Opening Skinner's Box Analysis

    1267 Words  | 6 Pages

    Through The Psychologist Eye In Lauren Slater’s book, “Opening Skinner’s Box,” we discover in the first three chapters the mysteries behind a few psychological experiments and the discoveries that three profound psychologists have made. Each chapter is about a different psychologist, the first is B.F. Skinner; a behaviorist who designed a process of learning in which behavior is controlled, he called this operant conditioning. Lauren Slater wanted people to know about his experiment, she read his books, talked to friends and family members to unearth the features behind this man. She found that he was a loving father, who could train animals to do unordinary things, like play the piano for an example, through the processes of operant conditioning,

    Read More

  • Ap Psychology Chapter 1 Study Guide

    1189 Words  | 5 Pages

    Skinner’s focus on positive and negative reinforcement of learned behaviors had a lasting influence in psychology that has waned somewhat since the growth of research in cognitive psychology. That emphasis has continued, particularly because of the importance of testing in determining opportunities for children, but other areas of exploration in African-American psychology research include learning style, sense of community and belonging, and spiritualism. Social psychologists conduct research on a wide variety of topics that include differences in how we explain our own behavior versus how we explain the behaviors of others, prejudice, and attraction, and how we resolve interpersonal conflicts. Wundt viewed psychology as a scientific study of conscious experience, and he believed that the goal of psychology was to identify components of consciousness and how those components combined to result in our conscious experience. Westen also argues that critics fail to consider the success of the broad ideas that Freud introduced or developed, such as the importance of childhood experiences in adult motivations, the role of unconscious versus conscious motivations in driving our behavior, the fact that motivations can cause conflicts that affect

    Read More

  • Classical Conditioning And Observational Learning Analysis

    2548 Words  | 11 Pages

    Introduction Learning enables you as an individual, to gain more knowledge about something which you have never learned about. Learning also has to do with past experiences which are influenced by behavioural changes (Weiten, 2016). There are different types of ways to learn; through, classical conditioning, operant conditioning and observational learning which will be discussed and analysed in the essay.   Behaviourism Behaviourism is considered one of the main subjects in psychology and the two main people who founded behaviourism were, Burrhus Frederic Skinner, also known as B.F Skinner and Ivan Pavlov who were famous for the work they did on classical and operant conditioning (Moderato & Presti, 2006). According to Moderato and Presti

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Behaviourism And Psychodynamic Theory

    498 Words  | 2 Pages

    Freud focused on the unconscious part of the mind and how it affects a person’s thinking and physical wellbeing. Psychoanalysis believed that our behaviour and emotions are controlled by our unconscious mind and although psychodynamic theory has influenced psychology in a positive way it has been criticized on scientific grounds as while behaviourist approach believed that psychological evidence should be derived from scientific study, psychoanalysis operated on a different base which believed that mental experiences were as important and valid as an evidence as the scientific study. Psychoanalysis were opposed to experimental research because they believed that a person’s mind cannot be studied under controlled conditions therefore psychodynamic approach is not considered scientific. Despite many differences behaviourism and psychodynamic approach also have some similarities for example both approaches believe that current behaviour is determined by past experiences, psychodynamic approach believes that what happened to you when you were a child has been locked away somewhere in the unconscious part of the mind that shapes an organisms

    Read More

  • B. F. Skinner Influence

    920 Words  | 4 Pages

    B.F. Skinner, America’s Most Influential Behavioral Scientist To begin with, it is important to mention that this paper focuses on B.F. Skinner and his famous theory on behavior analysis. B.F. (Burrhus Frederic) Skinner was born on March 20th, 1904 in Pennsylvania, in a small town called Susquehanna (Bjork, 1993). Evidently, his parents were Grace and William Skinner. His father was a lawyer.

    Read More

  • Examples Of Psychobiography

    2186 Words  | 9 Pages

    Greenberg (1986) believes Freud’s case studies do not place enough stress on revealing the outcome of the treatment and that Freud’s aim was more to illustrate his theoretical points (p.240). In cases, Greenberg asserts that many of the presented cases would not even be considered acceptable examples of psychoanalysis and, in short, that virtually all of the cases studies had basic shortcomings (p.240). Furthermore, many other powerful criticisms about Freud inaccurate and subsequently flawed evidence have been published. These critics contend that Freud’s evidence is flawed due to the lack of an experiment, the lack of a control group, and the lack of observations that went unrecorded (Colby, 1960, p.54).

    Read More

  • Core Philosophy Of The Psychoanalytic Theory

    986 Words  | 4 Pages

    Recognizing the division of personality in the,”ID”Ego”, and Super ego and that the unconscious is an important part of who we are and noting that anxiety plays a big function in how one reacts to the world at large and highlighting Freud’s theory on defense mechanism to help one cope with such anxieties. Core Philosophy of the Therapeutic Approach The most important underlying ideas relating to the psychoanalytic theory was mainly influenced by Sigmund Freud, one of the most famous names in Psychology, his Psychoanalytic Theory formed the bases of many current psychoanalytic theories. He was the first to discuss the unconscious mind and its role in human behaviour. Freud believed that there were three levels consciousness the first he labeled s the unconscious mind which exist outside of an individual’s awareness at all times.

    Read More

  • Watson's Theory Of Behaviorism

    705 Words  | 3 Pages

    In its most general sense, Behaviorism, also known as behavioral psychology, is a theory of learning developing as a result of the ideas and beliefs shared by a group of people who has influenced educators’ view of learning. The term behavioral psychology refers to a psychological approach which principally concerned with stimulus-response activities and emphasizes the role of environmental factors in a learning process, to the exclusion of own free will. There is a tenet of behavioral psychology that “only observable, measurable, an outward behavior is worth investigating” (Bush, 2006, p. 14). Historically speaking, behaviorism was originated in the 1880s and develops gradually in the twentieth-first century and beyond. Skinner and

    Read More

  • Conditioning And Behavioral Psychology

    765 Words  | 4 Pages

    Behavioral Psychology, also known as behaviorism, is psychology which studies observe behavior, understanding the role that conditioning is influencing a person’s thoughts and their actions. It is the connection with our minds and our behavior. A person’s behavior depends on how others treat them, too. There are many ways to improve all positive behavior. Children who receive positive reinforcement to their good work and behavior are often motivated to keep doing good.

    Read More

  • Sigmund Freud's Theories Of Personality Development

    789 Words  | 4 Pages

    The first aspect is the psyche which is structured into three, the id, ego and superego, all develops at different stages in our lives. The id is an important unconscious structure that contains basic instinctual drives when we are born. Freud believed that the id is based on our pleasure principle. For example, a baby needs or wants something such as milk, the baby

    Read More

  • Models In Human Science

    1161 Words  | 5 Pages

    You also cannot generalize the results Freud got from the experiences he made with individuals to a large number of people. This is one reason of why the use of models in human sciences can be extremely difficult and untrustworthy and therefore can hinder the gaining of knowledge. In response to the counter claim, even though the results from Freud’s experiments cannot be fully generalized, the model can still be useful. Still nowadays it’s used in patient analysis.

    Read More

  • Psychoanalytic Theory In Counseling

    1045 Words  | 5 Pages

    INTRODUCTION. A set of assumptions or rules on which the practice of an activity is based on is called a theory. It is also a fundamental or a basis used to account for a situation. There are several theories used in counseling practice.

    Read More

  • Psychopathology In Psychology

    1207 Words  | 5 Pages

    Starting from the first laboratory by Wilhelm Wundt to theories by Freud and Watson and more specific fields of psychology which are based on the ideas in these theories and other historical theories. The contribution of historical figures play a vital role in the development of modern psychology. Even though, their theories does not happen to be the way they used to be, the fundamental idea of it is the root of psychology. Modern psychology is more diverse yet the psychologists still explore theories such as behaviorism, psychoanalysis, humanism and cognitive

    Read More

More about Skinner Vs Psychoanalysis

Open Document