ipl-logo

What Is The Difference Between Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby

568 Words3 Pages

When looking for similarities and differences between the movie The Great Gatsby and the story “Winter Dreams,” both written by F. Scott Fitzgerald, you will see that both cover the theme of unrealistic love and the topic of craving to be from old money families. The Great Gatsby is told from the point of view of neighbor Nick Carraway. We learn that Jay Gatsby would go beyond measures to get what he wants. Whether to be more wealthy or show his undying love for one of the antagonists in this story, Daisy Buchanan. Dexter Green, in the story “Winter Dreams,” has very similar characteristics to Jay Gatsby. Dexter is another example of someone who wishes they were born with old money. Dexter even went as far as quitting his job and dedicating himself to joining the upper class so that he could match the status of Judy Jones. …show more content…

Despite both characters living a luxurious lifestyle, they still feel unworthy and dissatisfied with their lives. One example of unworthiness is shown in The Great Gatsby and how it is never sufficient for Jay when Daisy says she loves him (The Great Gatsby). Although Daisy says she loves Jay, it is not enough for him because she never claims to not love Tom. Daisy never seems to be able to give Jay the love he craves throughout the movie. Dissatisfaction is also shown through the character Dexter near the end of the story when he starts regretting the things he prioritized in life. Despite all of his success, he still has regrets about feeling that he wasted his childhood chasing after Judy and spending so much time achieving a wealthy status. “For he had gone away and he could never go back anymore,” (Fitzgerald 550) this shows how he wishes he could go back in time and spend less time on these things, but sadly he can’t. No matter what Jay and Dexter did or did not have, they always endeavored for

Show More
Related

Similarities Between Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby

1002 Words | 5 Pages

Despite Dexter Green’s overwhelming resemblance of Gatsby, there are also numerous, subtle similarities to Nick. “A sort of dullness settled down upon Dexter. For the first time in his life he felt like getting very drunk.” (Winter Dreams 9). In addition to both of the characters originating from middle-class families in Minnesota, they also rarely, or never get drunk.

Read More

Similarities Between Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby

1169 Words | 5 Pages

In “Winter Dreams”, there is also a similar social class ranking. Dexter Green spends all his time building up his social class status to live up to his “golden future” that he imagines. Judy, similar to Daisy in The Great Gatsby speaks her mind about her feelings toward social class to Dexter. Fitzgerald writes, “But I’ve just had a terrible afternoon. There was a man I cared

Read More

Compare And Contrast Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby

140 Words | 1 Pages

Jay Gatsby from The Great Gatsby and Dexter Green from Winter Dreams both encounter the dangers of being driven by their desire to achieve the American Dream and the pursuit of their unrealistic infatuations. However, while Dexter’s ambitions for success are driven by his own desire to work hard and attain financial freedom, Gatsby’s ambition for success is derived entirely from his infatuation with Daisy Buchanan, a beautiful and charming girl he met and fell in love with in his late 20s. Dexter’s values and willingness to take initiative for his own life before the life of others is what differentiates him from Gatsby’s delusional characteristics which ultimately lead to his death. Comparing the characters of both Jay Gatsby and Dexter Green

Read More

Differences And Similarities Between Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby

432 Words | 2 Pages

Dexter, in “Winter Dreams,” comes from a middle-class family and works as a caddy at a golf course to earn money. Gatsby, in “The Great Gatsby,” is also from a similar background, growing up poor in North Dakota. Despite their uncertain beginnings, both characters are able to climb the social ladder and achieve their dreams of wealth and success. However, there are also several differences between Dexter and Gatsby.

Read More

Compare And Contrast Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby

1221 Words | 5 Pages

The passage, Winter Dreams, by F. Scott Fitzgerald, has the same theme. A poor man loves a wealthier woman and revolves his life around trying to get her. To be able to relate to these characters and truly get a feel and understand each characters actions in these novels, readers must use intellectual empathy to put themselves in their shoes to see how they would feel and react in the same situation. Gatsby sees Daisy as not only a woman whom he loves, but also a symbol of his American dream of being seen as “old money”. Dexter does not see Judy for how she truly is; he sees her how he wants her to be.

Read More

Examples Of Greed In The Great Gatsby

454 Words | 2 Pages

In The Great Gatsby Daisy, Tom and Gatsby are materialistic and lie to one another with lies. “Your wife doesn’t love you’ said Gatsby. She’s never loved you. She loves me”. “Her voice is full of money”.

Read More

Daisy As A Tragic Hero

1109 Words | 5 Pages

She chooses the extravagant lifestyle that Tom is capable of providing instead of patiently waiting for her true love. The self-centered desires she displays demonstrates the lack of authetic love she promised Gatsby. Instead, she marries Tom “without so much as a shiver”, demonstrating her hedonistic mindset (76). Since Tom treats Daisy with minimal care, she thoughtlessly dives into an adulterous affair with Jay Gatsby. With no severe intentions towards marriage, she always “ought to have something in her life” to fulfill her heart (79).

Read More

Similarities Between Mr De Winter And The Great Gatsby

392 Words | 2 Pages

“His face without expression,I could not tell whether he laughed inwardly or not”(Rebecca 37). Gatsby, a man that has suddenly become and rich has moved to West egg, and Mr. De Winter, a man who has tragically lost his first wife,both share similarities between each other. In the novels, Rebecca by Daphne Du Maurier , and ,The Great Gatsby by F. Scott Fitzgerald , they both share strong comparisons and contrasts like how Mr. Winter’s and Gatsby 's ways of presenting themselves are both similar.

Read More

Winter Dreams Character Analysis Essay

622 Words | 3 Pages

Winter Dreams By F. Scott Fitzgerald is a short-story telling of a 14 year-old caddy named Dexter Green. In this narrative Dexter meet Judy Jones while working at his golf course. As the story continues on, Dexter becomes severely infatuated by Judy. The desire to be hers overcomes him so greatly, he works his way to wealth to be in the same social class as her, hoping to catch her attention and marry her someday. However Judy may be beautifully the outside as she ages, but her insides say differently.

Read More

The Great Gatsby Selfish Analysis

539 Words | 3 Pages

Although Gatsby does not seem to be a selfish man on the surface, his intentions and success may. He builds a ginormous mansion and throws extravagant parties all to get Daisy and her love back. Gatsby does all this for his good since all it consists of is having Daisy all to himself. The corruption and obsession of wealth is displayed through the characters Daisy, Tom and Gatsby as they live their lives in

Read More

Similarities Between Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby

1126 Words | 5 Pages

“Winter Dreams” and The Great Gatsby The short story of “Winter Dreams” and The Great Gatsby book are both written by F.Scott Fitzgerald. The American Dream is pursued in a similar way in the Great Gatsby and “Winter Dreams” thought the very materialistic characters Jay Gatsby and Dexter Green, falling in love with Judy and Daisy. The characters use the ideals of the American Dream (hard work, achievement, being self-reliant) to win the women they love.

Read More

Examples Of Unhappiness In The Great Gatsby

1873 Words | 8 Pages

The characters in the novel pretend that they have their lives all figured out, but through their successes their downfalls and emptiness can be seen, to prove that money cannot buy happiness. Jay Gatsby is the newest and upcoming star in New York during the 1920’s. Through his business and inheritance he is one of the richest men of his time. One may think that his abundance of wealth would lead him to be eternally happy, but he is the opposite. Gatsby longs for his love of Daisy, which is his personal American Dream.

Read More

Comparison Between Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby

1374 Words | 6 Pages

Characters in novels can have obsessions with people, the same as in the world readers live in today. In the book, The Great Gatsby, the main, male character, Gatsby, is obsessed with a woman named Daisy Buchanan. In the passage Winter Dreams, Dexter, the main male character, is obsessed with a woman, Judy Jones. F. Scott Fitzgerald wrote both of these novels/ passages introducing the same theme. The Great Gatsby is a story about a man who has revolved part of his life around trying to achieve his American dream by conforming to a woman and society 's standards.

Read More

Literary Analysis Of Winter Dreams

1560 Words | 7 Pages

By the end of the story he cannot have the girl, and his dreams are ruined. The author illustrates Dexter Green as a wishful boy longing for what the future holds. Fitzgerald incorporates many symbols as one being solely Judy Jones. The author uses style in the story by separating the story into 6 sections. Fitzgerald in “Winter Dreams” depicts the fantasy of the American dream and how no matter how hard one works he may never achieve his dream.

Read More

Symbolism In F. Scott Fitzgerald's Winter Dreams

1183 Words | 5 Pages

Judy becomes a symbol of the upper class that Dexter has always longed to join, and he allows her to use him over and over while she indulges in affairs with other men. Dexter completely romanticizes her and connects her in his mind to the higher status he craves. Throughout the short story, Fitzgerald effectively communicates Dexter's disillusionment with his quest for the American dream by incorporating symbolism, imagery, and dramatic irony. Fitzgerald emphasizes the emptiness of Dexter’s materialistic aspirations and his eventual realization of their falseness through the symbols of darkness and the color gold. Darkness serves as a symbol of the loneliness and emptiness that creeps up on Dexter in his journey of climbing the social ladder.

Read More

More about What Is The Difference Between Winter Dreams And The Great Gatsby

Related Topics

Open Document