In his book, entitled Complications: A Surgeon’s Notes on an Imperfect Science, author Atul Gawande explains what gastric bypass surgery is and also states that it is one of the strangest surgeries he has ever performed. In stating this, Gawande brings up the question of a human’s control over appetite. This paper will consider Atul Gawande’s discussion of adult obesity, including the question of will power. Also, I will explain Gawande’s position that adults have no self control when it comes to their appetites. In the chapter “The Man Who Couldn’t Stop Eating,” Gawande mentions society’s opinion that adults have the willpower to overcome their appetite. He notes that, “we have a choice over such simple matters as whether to sit still or stand up, to talk or not talk, to have a slice of pie or not” (169). Basically, Gawande is presenting the common belief in willpower. He points out that because people have a choice in most situations, they assume …show more content…
Gawande demonstrates his point through several different stories involving patients who had gastric-bypass surgery. For example, when telling the story of a woman named Carla, Gawande states, “She had slowly found herself to have a profound and unfamiliar sense of willpower over food.” Gawande argues that as a result of this change, “she no longer wanted to eat like she did before. She thought that the surgery was why she no longer ate as much as she used to. Yet she felt as if she were choosing not to do it” (174). Basically, Gawande implies here that previous to the surgery, Carla did not have this sense of willpower over food. He explains that the decreased appetite which typically accompanies successful gastric bypass surgery can give patients the false sense of increase
This often leads to eating disorders as well due to the consistency of not eating from the lack of food. My favorite of the essay describes how I feel about this topic “ they should
According to surgeon and Master of Public Health Atul Gawande, the morbidly obese should consider Roux-en-Y gastric-bypass surgery (Gawande 187). In “The Man Who Couldn’t Stop Eating,” Gawande describes Vincent Caselli’s gastric-bypass operation as well as his complete recovery. He explains what a Roux-en-Y gastric-bypass is, and retells several personal accounts from his experience as a surgeon. Throughout the article, Gawande gives many facts about the surgery, stating that many problems can arise during the recovery phase. Overall, many people lose at least two-thirds of their weight in a year; however, in rare cases, people can regain their weight or even exceed their original weight (194, 196).
Saletan gives more than enough information on how, when, and what is happening worldwide about obesity. Although he does not give a solution, he still made an eye opening experience while reading this essay. Obesity is now happening worldwide. Yes I said it, worldwide according to Saletan. “Egyptian, Mexican, and South African women are as fat as American”, he claims in the second paragraph.
In the article, “Slow Ideas”, Atul Gawande utilizes personal and historical anecdotes to further strengthen his claims. He often transitions between stories by asking the audience a critical question and then providing his stance on this issue. This strategy allows for a paper that flows well, and also maintains a high level of interest from the audience. This is because the questions often cause the reader to stop and think about their own take on the situation. After posing a question, Gawande then transitions into explaining the problem through the use of a narrative example.
However, using structural functionalism of obesity and prevention through medical care is essential to a balance of a functioning society. Studying structural functionalism theory of the epidemic of childhood and adult obesity through on the risks and the impacts of overeating without exercising. However, to prevent obesity, there needs to be the balance between medical costs and educating the community of the risks and the consequences of indulging without proper physical
In “What You Eat Is Your Business,” Radley Balko tackles the issue of who is responsible for fighting obesity. Balko argues that the controversy of obesity should make the individual consumers culpable for their own health and not the government (467). As health insurers refrain from increasing premiums for obese and overweight patients, there is a decrease in motivation to keep a healthy lifestyle (Balko 467). As a result, Balko claims these manipulations make the public accountable for everyone else 's health rather than their own (467). Balko continues to discuss the ways to fix the issue such as insurance companies penalizing consumers who make unhealthy food choices and rewarding good ones (468).
such a moderate amount of it that the boys...would know what it was to go with their hunger unsatisfied for he believed that those who underwent this training would be better able to continue working on an extremely empty stomach. (Document B) What this piece of evidence indicates is that, by starving the youth, it would better train them to be less hungry. Statistically, the body cannot “pretend” to be hungry. In order to have energy and to fulfill the task needed, a person needs to eat food to survive.
In both David Zinczenko’s “Don’t Blame The Eater” and “ Radley Balko’s “What You Eat is Your Business”, the argument of obesity in America is present and clear from opposing viewpoints. Both articles were written in the early 2000’s, when the popular political topic of the time was obesity and how it would be dealt by our nation in the future. While Zinczenko argues that unhealthy junk food is an unavoidable cultural factor, Balko presents the thought that the government should have no say in it’s citizens diet or eating habits. Zinczenko’s article was written with the rhetorical stratedgy of pathos in mind.
Atul Gawande in his article “Whose body is it, anyway?” introduced couple of cases, which discussed a controversial topic, doctors dealing with patients and making important medical decisions. These are difficult decisions in which people might have life or death choices. Who should make the important decisions, patients or doctors? Patients don’t usually know what is better for their health and while making their decisions, they might ignore or don’t know the possible side effects and consequences of these decisions.
I believe that pursuing happiness as a goal has detrimental effects. As a society, we tend to believe that we need to be full of joy at all times, but that isn't realistic - life happens. By attempting to be cheery all the time, you will never be genuinely content. You will always be searching for more and won't be satisfied with what you have, creating a permanent cycle of gloom rather than bliss.
Obesity has gained a lot of attention in the recent years especially in the 21st century. Right now in America, there is an ongoing epidemic. The cause is not by viruses or bacteria, but by human nature. There is no one way to solve this serious problem. With growing body sizes and serious medical problems associated with obesity, it is a problem that needs to be addressed and changed.
A risk factor for many other diseases, obesity can affect health and longevity. Weight loss is achievable, and it provides plenty of health benefits. Studies have shown that many people who attempt weight loss regain the weight they lost. The major challenge in managing patients is, therefore, to improve their ability to sustain whatever weight loss can be accomplished. Diet, exercise, and behavioral management are the main sources of treatment, But medication and surgery can be considered in certain individuals.
She also discusses how obesity can be related to health issues as well as psychological issues. A similar argument was made in the article, “Add Cake, Subtract Self-Esteem” by Caroline Knapp, where she talks about her personal experience on how her stress caused by college and relationships caused her to suffer from anorexia. She stated how starving yourself daily is a painful experience. Prose and Knapp both believe that eating food is not something to frown upon. I agree with this because as humans eating food is essential for living a healthy lifestyle.
In this excerpt from the essay “Appetite,” written by Laurie Lee, Lee explains why appetite is one of our major pleasures and what we should be doing to protect it. The author starts off talking about the qualities of fasting, and how he believes we should give up our pleasures regularly in order to preserve their intensity. To strengthen his argument, Lee tells a story of the men separating from the women and children leaving them to starve until the men returned with food. After the men return home, they continue on to feed their family and celebrate with them. The author ends the essay by actually telling us why it is important to preserve our appetite.
(Dray, Sarah.) Most suppose that by going on diets, losing weight, and going back to their original eating habits is acceptable. These actions are simply making matters worse for them. “People who diet gain more weight than those who skip the diet route altogether (Dr. Axe.) ”