ipl-logo

Donna Smargiassi Case Study

476 Words2 Pages

Judge Laura Turlip 400 Church St. 2nd Floor, Archbald, Pa. 18403 (570) 876-0570 was advised of the identity of Investigator Sean P. Brennan and of the confidential nature and purpose of the interview, Turlip, provided the following information:

Turlip worked as in private practice from 2000 until 2005 when she ran for judge. She took office in January 2006 and was reelected in 2012 and her term run until 2018.

Turlip recalled the Donna Smargiassi case. She knew Donna and her sister and parents from the area just like she knows Lili Vioncek-Clark and her family. Clark and Turlip have been friends for approximately 5 years. Turlip’s significate other went to high school with Clark. He has been …show more content…

Turlip told her where to go and then Clark started to tell her what happened but Turlip told her she didn’t want to know the details because she wasn’t allowed and it would get her in trouble. Turlip told her to see the ADA when she went to the courtroom. Clark never mentioned it again.

When the case came before Turlip, she disclosed to both ADA Brian Gallagher and defense attorney Terri Pawelski that she knew both parties involved in the case. Turlip also knew Pawelski’s sister pretty well and the rest of her family. Turlip knew Smargiassi had some mental issues and when she appeared before her Turlip told her she was sorry to see her under those circumstances. Turlip didn’t feel that she should recuse herself otherwise she would have to do that over 60 to 70% of the time because she knows a lot of people from her area. Turlip indicated that she can be impartial when it comes to the law.

Turlip said there are 3 attorneys that are totally disrespectful and to her and Pawelski is one of them. She is very unprofessional and it seemed like she had a chip on her shoulder for one reason or another. Turlip knows Pawelski practices in Philadelphia and she felt a little sorry for her because she had to drive up to Lackawanna County because that’s what Pawelski told her, but Turlip said she didn’t have to act the way she did in her courtroom. Turlip almost made a complaint herself to the D Board about

Show More
Related

  • Case Study Of Dollree Mapp's Home In Cleveland

    233 Words  | 1 Pages

    Mapp said the suitcase was not hers and she had lent it to a boarder. She was arrested, prosecuted, found guilty, and sentenced

    Read More

  • Registered Sex Offender Case Study

    1744 Words  | 7 Pages

    Dominic T. Hicks, DOB 05/01/77 is a known Registered Sex Offender that lives in Unit 6 and was a possible match to the suspect description given by the victim. On 06/24/15, I conducted registered sex offender address verification checks and contacted Hicks at 109 Lake St. S. #6 which is his registered address. At about 0900 hours, Cpl. Crocker and Detective Lansing contacted Wehrman at the hospital.

    Read More

  • Arizona Superior Court Case Summary

    756 Words  | 4 Pages

    On October 14, 2015, I went to the Arizona Superior Court at Downtown Phoenix. I went to the room 503 in the Central Court Building, which is a family court. The judge that was in the room is Paul J McMurdie. He begin hearing at 1:30 P.M. and there are a 5 hearing during the day that I visited. One of the case that he hearing is FC2010-006759, Hall vs. Gollins.

    Read More

  • What Is The Christine Jessop Case

    1340 Words  | 6 Pages

    Justice Fred Kaufman found in his 1997 report on the commission of inquiry into that wrongful conviction. In the Jessop’s original statement they had arrived home at 4:10 p.m. on October. 3, 1984, and Christine was not home. The focus of the police shifted to Morin, who was the Jessop’s neighbour and lived with his parents. The police discovered that Morin left work at 3:32 p.m. that day and could not have made it home before 4:14 p.m.

    Read More

  • In Defense Of Detective Dana Hughes, Metropolitan Police Department

    1372 Words  | 6 Pages

    I saw some bruises on her, but she said she was fine”. Battered woman syndrome plays a large part in the defense and although one could avoid her releasing her bias to the jury, she seems like her presence would be more hazardous than good for the defence. The only things that she could say that would be

    Read More

  • 12th Justice System Case Study

    416 Words  | 2 Pages

    I am all so concern regarding Judge Jessica Colon-Sayre bias regarding the case base on a statement she allegedly made. Apparently in her chastising of my daughter (Jaclyn), Judge Jessica Colon-Sayre supposedly made a statement regarding her personal experience and used it as a point of references in the case, (“She

    Read More

  • The Case Of Mr. Griffin V. Salt Lake County Jail

    951 Words  | 4 Pages

    It was on February 15, 1986 in Salt Lake, Utah, where the mother of Cammie K. reported the sexual abuse of her nine-year-old daughter by a man known as Mr. Griffin. Detective Strong and two other County deputies were assigned for the investigation on the case. During their investigation, detective Strong and other deputies went to interview Cammie K. at her home, where she told officers in different occasions that the Mr. Griffin sexually abused her. After that interview, the officers then went over to interview Mr. Griffin. At his home, Mr. Griffin confessed to being the abuser, but after the coercion interview by Detective Strong.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Lewinsky's Speech

    1149 Words  | 5 Pages

    She tells the story of Tyler Clementi, an 18-year-old college student who was secretly filmed kissing another man. Overcome with shame, he committed suicide. While Clementi’s tragic story is a stunning narrative on its own, Lewinsky powerfully connects it with her own life. Her breath catches and she pauses. Emotional – choking up – she tells of how Clementi’s story resonated with her mother:

    Read More

  • The Herman Case

    1083 Words  | 5 Pages

    The social worker did not handle the case correctly or completely. Herman obviously had some social issues, and showed signs of psychological problems. No action was taken on account of those possible problems. No supervision or consultation was exercised in this case, even though the social worker did not know precisely what should have been done. Though the senior center director seemed to care more about her job than about Herman, she was simply following protocol that comes with her occupation.

    Read More

  • Essay On 14th Amendment

    662 Words  | 3 Pages

    Several hours later more officers arrived and with a piece of paper they said was a warrant, after she did not come to the door the officers broke down several doors, entered the home and were confronted by Ms. Mapp. She was handcuffed after she took their “warrant” and put it in her dress. Court transcripts states, “The search spread to the rest of the second floor including the child's bedroom, the living room, the kitchen and a dinette. The basement of the building and a trunk found therein were also searched. The obscene materials for possession of which she was ultimately convicted were discovered in the course of that widespread search” ("USSC case Mapp v. Ohio").

    Read More

  • Judge Richard Cappelli Case Study

    191 Words  | 1 Pages

    Judge Richard Cappelli 201 W. Front St. Media, Pa. 19063 (610) 891-4042 was advised of the identity of Investigator Sean P. Brennan and of the confidential nature and purpose of the interview, Cappelli, provided the following information: Judge Cappelli was a MDJ from November 1992 until he was elected to the Common Pleas Court in May 2014. Cappelli knows Judge Vann from when he was a MDJ and they would cover for one another over the course of time. Cappelli doesn’t know Vann outside of work, he never socialized with her. Cappelli vaguely recalls the circumstances involved when Vann called him and asked him to do an arraignment for her because she had some sort of conflict.

    Read More

  • The Mcmartin Trial

    1122 Words  | 5 Pages

    The discretion of the case was significant in the regard of the defense, which countered some contradicted evidences. The evidences from the trial and the hearing preliminaries have revealed that the children were coached. The testimony showed lack of credibility on the issues and showing the significance of the discretion on the defense. McMartin told his attorney that he did not do it and his attorney used his discretion and believed him.

    Read More

  • A Piece Of Cake Analysis

    549 Words  | 3 Pages

    I read A Piece of Cake: A Memoir. It was written by Cupcake Brown. This book was very inspiring and emotional. The story begins with a memory as to why her mother named her Cupcake. Cupcake 's mother died when she was 11.After that she got taken away from the family she knew.

    Read More

  • Tomcik Case Study

    785 Words  | 4 Pages

    The caregivers lacked commitment, compassion, conscientiousness, fairness and honesty, and if they had taken their jobs seriously probably Tomcik wouldn’t have suffered as much. Trial began on July 22, 1991 and the decision was made on October 7, 1991. Tomcik’s total damage came out to be $85,000 according to the text. The defendants were proven wrong and they were charged. The court did the right thing, but I think a stricter action should have been taken against the defendants.

    Read More

  • Brandy Mcclain Case

    1796 Words  | 8 Pages

    This complaint is based upon the allegation of sexual harassment, disruptive, hostile work environment & racial discrimination filed by Brandy Stockton against Dr. Gregory McClain, stemming from their working relationship at the University of Missouri Hospital. Stockton received repeated harassing / threatening phone calls, some of which started the day Dr. McClain resigned subsequent to a peer review. The caller threatened to chop her up and deliver the pieces to her family. A criminal case has been presented to the Cole County Prosecutor against McClain by the M.U. Police Department. They identified an individual in Texas as the probable source of harassing / threatening calls.

    Read More

More about Donna Smargiassi Case Study

Open Document