Think of a world where there is no freedom, and yet, its a utopia. The main character of The Giver by, Lois Lowry named Jonas, lives in this aforementioned world. By the end of the book, Jonas would describe his world as a dystopia. Jonas lives in what he calls the community, where the government chooses the jobs, supplies the food, stalks and watches over its citizens, imposes strict and unforgiving laws, regulates everything, prevents differences among people, and both condemns and allows lies. Most citizens of the community would call it a utopia. At the beginning of the novel, Jonas is one such naive citizen. However, Jonas changes throughout The Giver and as a result, tries to change the community.
At the beginning of the book, Jonas is
…show more content…
However, he was wise at the end. Jonas’s naivety was evident when Jonas was thinking about volunteer hours and how they were always important to him because the other hours of the day were regulated heavily. This shows that Jonas is naive because he does not know that having very little free choice is not normal, and that most people from the time before him had the freedom to choose how they spent their time, “The freedom to choose where we spend those hours had always seemed a wonderful luxury to Jonas” (Page: 26). Another example came later in the book as Jonas was talking to The Giver about color and quickly rebukes the community that they should not have eliminated color. The example shows how Jonas was naive because he did not know all of the evils that the world had created by means of color. He did not know the effects of color on the world throughout history. Eventually, jonas’s naivety gave way to wisdom after he had learned about the previous world. Wisdom was shown later in the novel after Jonas learned about both the freedoms and restrictions of the old world. At one point, after Jonas has not taken the pills for four weeks and has nearly been The Receiver for one year, Jonas realises that the feelings that the community experiences are just shells of what feelings really are. As he reflects on this, he learns that the sharing of emotions ceremony at the end of the day, would be useless in
The idea of a utopia, a state or place where everything is perfect, is one that has been fantasized and described by many authors in several different ways. Just as beauty is in the eye of the beholder, a perfect society can appear very different to different people. Two books that both attempt to illustrate the idea of a perfect society but with stark contrasts are Anthem by Ayn Rand and The Giver by Lois Lowry. Both encourage the idea of prioritizing one’s community, and duty to said community, over oneself in order to maintain a perfect and peaceful society. However, utopian societies are usually shown to not be as perfect as they seem when analyzed in literature.
Society has a negative, neutral, or positive effect depending on which one you live in. For instance, The Giver’s society is neutral due to the sameness so they are much different from our society. Its is surprising how different they are. The way they choose jobs, celebrate birthdays and mourn death are different from us. They do not even celebrate birthdays after twelve.
The last extreme change is that we have emotions, feelings and we can see color, Jonas’s society is so much about equality that they don 't want anyone to be different or they fear that the people will have the power to chose what they want to do. Today 's society and Jonas’s have some similarities. Such as, in both children are given comfort objects to help them through rough times. Well just like in The Giver all children go to school in our country too.
He feels betrayed by his father and his community for lying to him. In this quote, he realizes that if his community lied to him about something super important like a release, they might be lying about other things too. I completely understand why Jonas feels hatred and resentment towards his father and his community because he just saw his father kill a newborn baby and lie to his face about how release works. I would feel the same way if someone did that to
The Giver, by Lois Lowry, depicts a dystopia that strips people of all their freedoms and humanity. On the surface, the Giver’s society is a perfect utopia, free from the problems that plague humanity today, but after looking more closely at the people’s lives, the dystopic nature of this society is evident. The Giver’s community and our society have many similarities and differences, although our societies are comparable in that they have similar goals, such as helping people and having perfect equality, the means to achieve these goals are very different and as a result, the freedoms, laws, and day-to-day lives of the people are vastly different. The freedoms in the Giver’s society and our society are very dissimilar.
Just think. Nobody has any knowledge of the past. You do not know what color is, you have no emotion, and everybody is the same. The world that you live in is colorless, emotionless, drab, even lifeless. This is the type of world that Jonas and The Giver live in.
Lea Vilna-Santos Mrs. English, 7th September 1st, 2015 The Giver, by: Lois Lowry Log Entry 5: Chapters 9-10: Question 7: In chapters 9-10, Jonas realizes from reading the last rule in his list that allows him to lie, that what if what people say isn’t the truth, despite what everyone in his community learns about the importance of telling the truth. He was even chastised when he exaggerated as a Four. He said that he was starving, but he was only hungry. His teachers made sure he understood that even though it was an unintentional lie, it was still a lie because as long as he lives in their community he will never be starving so they didn’t want him to ever say anything like that again.
Jonas first sees the color red when he is throwing an apple with Asher his best friend, and he pays attention a lot in school. A quote that shows that Jonas has the power to see beyond when “‘You're beginning to see the color red’[The Giver said]”(Lowry 89).The quote shows that Jonas is starting to see the color red. A quote that shows that Jonas is very observative when “‘We are all aware that Jonas has been a top student throughout his school days.[The Chief Elder said](Lowry 59).This shows that Jonas is a very observative young man. The problems in the this story are that Jonas is apprehensive about his ceremony of 12,and he also sees a baby get released.
Jonas also found out what it means to starve. This was very hard for him, he now realized that all places are not like his community where everyone is all the same and had everything provided for them. If Jonas had had lots of innocence, he would not have been starving, he would of stayed in his community. This is shown in the following quote, “Jonas remembered, suddenly and grimly , the time in his childhood when he had been chastised for a misusing a word. The word had been “starving.”
In the novel “The Giver” chapter 9 when Jonas is reading his requirements for his assignment he sees that he may lie and he cannot help himself but wonder “ What if other adults had, upon becoming Twelves received the same sentence,what if they all had been instructed ‘you may lie’. This shows that societal rules can change mindsets because, in the beginning of the novel “ The Giver” we have a look on how people's lives are constantly controlled even their dreams called “stirrings”, so i the beginning Jonas is already aware of the rules that are set and has no doubt about the way they run things. Then as soon as he gets his assignments and has a look at the rules and questions the system and himself and slowly finds out the truth when not even noticing yet. To add on in the film “Up” a little boy named Russell goes to the older man’s front door (Carl Fredricksen) and asks him if he needed any help or work to do so he can get a badge, Carl continues to say no and brush him away but Russell continuously knocks on his door until Carl finally gives in.
ould the community in The Giver be considered a utopia or dystopia. Most people would say it is dystopia because they have no choices, no color, and they have no feelings. So would The Giver be considered a utopia or dystopia. First, the reason why the community is a dystopia is they can make no choices.
He is under sameness and the influence of the community. Jonas is chosen to receive feelings, colors, and emotions from memories. As time goes by Jonas sees the community not as a utopia but a horrible place. Jonas wants to change
The giver by Lois Lowry- Analytical essay ________________________________________________________ What if we lived in a world of peace and equality? What if we lived in a world with no differences? A world with no social classes and inequality. That sounds pretty amazing doesn’t it?
The Giver Literature essay I have read the dystopian novel “The Giver” (1993) which is written by the beloved American author Lois Lowry. “The Giver” is about a twelve-year-old boy with the name Jonas. Jonas lives a similar life as all the others in the community, until the Ceremony of Twelve when he got assigned the task as the Receiver of Memory. As The Receiver of Memory it is Jonas’ task to keep all the memories of the past so not everyone needs to keep this burden. Although Jonas received beautiful memories with a lot of colors and happiness he also felt grief, pain and anger.
Jonas learned a lot of memories. Another way the setting affected Jonas was that he knew things that the community never knew. He knew what pain, love, and happiness were. Everyone else didn't such as when Asher and others were playing the war game. Jonas had just got the memory of war and was speechless about it.