Level 5 Leadership Analysis
Draft Leadership Critique
Jim Collins’ theory of Level 5 Leadership has fundamentally transformed my perspective on leadership. My amusement is that the theory is not a hypothesis or a coined out phrase but, rather derivative of empirically research. I would rather call it a discovery.
According to Collins' defined, Level 5 leaders are those at "the highest level in a hierarchy of executive capabilities." (2005: 138) Those category of leaders are individuals who possess a “combination of personal humility plus professional will” (Collins, J., 2005: 140).Also, they are “modest and willful, shy and fearless” (Collins, J., 2005: 140). The most surprising part about those Level 5 leaders is that they look very ordinary people that they can easily
…show more content…
Whether Level 5 leaders are transformational in their style is not directly mentioned. However, in his research Collins observed "Level 5 leaders routinely select superb successors." (2005: 144) is in agreement with the idea that “Transformational leadership....develop the followers to achieve their fullest potential” (Jogulu, 2010: 706) also “they not only inspire those around them, they empower those individuals to step up and lead.” (George et al., 2007:137). That is typical of Level 5 leaders who take upon themselves the responsibility to develop their …show more content…
Those attributes are what makes sense to me as a leader. I hate the spotlight, but I cannot claim that I own Level 5 seed. Opposite to Level 5 leadership mindset, Shamir portrayed “leaders who truly believe they have been endowed with special qualities not possessed by ordinary mortals and who act on the basis of such a belief. History has shown that such leaders can be very dangerous.” (2005: 400). Such poor leadership mindset are contrary to my convictions and as a leader, that's why I am infatuated with Level 5 leadership all the more.
In conclusion, Collins' piece on Level 5 leadership only tells us who these leaders are, how they conduct their business, the results they produce, and the impact they make. There are still so many unknowns, for instance, how they came to being? How to find them? What indicator do they pose? What environment exposes them? Organizations that are on the good side of luck may run into a Level 5 leader and enjoy a transfer from "good-to-great"(Collins, 2005: 138). But it is equally true that those organizations with bad luck. For those, Level 5 leadership will remain a mere academic
Theme Of Leadership In Beowulf
815 Words | 4 PagesWherever human beings are accumulated together in large numbers, they need leadership. Even a school needs a principle to mentor and escalate the school’s rank. Armies need generals to lead them to a courageous victory. Civilians need governments, captains of industry and intellectual leaders of thought as well. However, There are characteristics common to most great leaders that can be picked out.
Contrasting Leadership Models Of Leadership In Healthcare Practice
935 Words | 4 PagesWhile popular literature focuses on practical advice and tips for leaders, academic literature delves into the theories and concepts behind leadership (Dye, 2017). One common issue with popular leadership literature is there are often claims made without sufficient evidence to back them up (Dye, 2017). With popular leadership literature, it is vital to make there is valid evidence to support all leadership claims. Without this support, it's difficult to determine whether the ideas apply to effective leadership (Dye, 2017). One way I can become a better critical consumer in my field is to do my research and fact-check claims before incorporating any ideas into my leadership style.
William Deresiewicz's Speech Analysis
1056 Words | 5 PagesIn fact, Deresiewicz believes that many of the people that have gained leadership positions over the recent years do possess those qualities, yet they are not equipped to be good leaders. The reason given for this is that young people are being trained to excel at maneuvering their way up a bureaucratic environment, but they are not being trained to think for themselves about what that environment entails. Young people are growing up with too many distractions, which inhibits them from being alone with their thoughts and prevent them from experiencing the solitude that makes for good leadership. For this reason, Deresiewicz suggests that America is experiencing a “crisis of leadership.” I agree that for many years, young people were raised to believe that everyone who did what they were supposed to do were entitled to success.
5 Facts About Creighton
1109 Words | 5 PagesThe required text for the class is Hackman’s and Johnson’s Leadership: A Communication Perspective. • The course qualifies as a doing social sciences course. • There are a total of 13 quizzes that will be taken during the course, in addition to three
Analysis Of Bo's Lasting Lessons By Coach Schembechler
1581 Words | 7 PagesSome leaders are developed through lifetime lessons. They are brought up in strong family core values, that they pass on to others. They have great role models
Fahrenheit 451 Hero Quotes
872 Words | 4 PagesAnother thing about leadership is its an art. People can’t just become a leader, it’s inside of them just waiting for an opportunity to reveal itself. “Educators, health professionals, and parents all agree that as society grows more complex, young people are in greater need than ever for grounding in the basic values that determine character”(Hirschmann 12). This shows that the higher ups in
Chapter 10x Leadership Summary
1867 Words | 8 PagesThese leaders are in constant motion. They stimulate ideas and creativity, and encourage wise experimentation, and are critical about results and discipline. They do not rely on luck or circumstances to determine their success, but they analyse their situation, and react according to it. When they face bad luck, they learn from it and make any necessary changes, and when they face good luck they continue to follow their principles. Leaders work with the expectation that what they are working for, will become great and will remain great even after they leave their leadership position.
Organizational Leaders: Annotated Bibliography
669 Words | 3 PagesAnnotated Bibliography Chaleff, I. (2003). The Courageous Follower. San Francisco, CA: Berrett-Kohler Publishers, Inc.
Levels Of Leadership Book Review
690 Words | 3 Pagesand I thought that this went along great with the text for this course. The book is broken down between the five levels of leadership. The levels are Position, permission, production, people development, and pinnacle. These different levels talk about what they are, how you acheive them, and why you
Donald Trump's Leadership Style
1924 Words | 8 PagesIn spite of the fact that’ leadership analysis’ is the art of breaking down a leader into basic psychological components for study and use by academics and practitioners, a sound leadership analyses
Leadership: A Critical Review Of Leadership Theories
1000 Words | 4 PagesCritical Review of Leadership Theories There have been a variety of theorists who have tried to understand how good leaders acquire their skills and whether the components which make up a successful leader are hereditary or learned. Many Studies have been made using twins to identify that about forty percent of differences in personality are hereditary. (Vernon et al., 1998) From this we can see that it is not only a matter of whether a person in born with these skills but one must also build on them to become a successful leader.
The Food Terminal Case Study
1372 Words | 6 PagesModule 8: Leadership Model MGT 560: Leadership Development Colorado State University-Global Campus Professor: Tom Woodruff May 03, 2015 : Introduction The Case Study, The Food Terminal (A) has been considered to offer the Model adapted from Montgomery, Copley, and Associates (1996) as a solution for the issues arising out of the case study. A professional situation experienced by me has been considered too and the model employed while I was working as a Manager. Heart Mike mentioned that he was initially nervous while getting the responsibilities and was asked to meet the department managers, and that he could see the look of disappointment in their eyes. He had the heart to share that most of these managers
Self Reflection Paper On Leadership
1818 Words | 8 PagesThrough self-reflection and academic readings, I have discovered that I identify with three different leadership theories. During the first meeting in a Strength Based Leadership class, we were asked to write our leadership history. The class then began an ongoing exploration of various leadership theories. Upon reviewing my leadership history from the first class and synthesizing the information from the theories that were examined, I discovered that I most resonate with the Trait Leadership Theory, the Skills Leadership Theory, and the Path-Goal Leadership theory. These theories are leader focused, describing the process and techniques a leader uses to accomplish goals.
The Leadership Theory: The Great Man Theory
1274 Words | 6 PagesLeaders are made, not born. The Great Man Theory suggests that people inherit qualities and traits that make them better suited for leadership. “To suggest that leaders do not enter the world with extraordinary endowment is to imply that people enter the world with equal abilities, with equal talents.” (Thomas Carlyle 1840) While it is true that there are certain characteristics that leaders are born with that predispose them to become leaders, the influence of these characteristics are often overexaggerated.
Difference Between Trait And Behavioural Theories
1000 Words | 4 PagesAccording to the book, "individuals who exhibit traits as a leader able to recognize someone who is a leader of leaders does not mean they managed to get each group to achieve its goals. " theories of leadership behaviour suggests that certain people are able to distinguish the behaviour of a leader by himself and not from
More about Level 5 Leadership Analysis
Theme Of Leadership In Beowulf
815 Words | 4 PagesContrasting Leadership Models Of Leadership In Healthcare Practice
935 Words | 4 PagesWilliam Deresiewicz's Speech Analysis
1056 Words | 5 Pages5 Facts About Creighton
1109 Words | 5 PagesAnalysis Of Bo's Lasting Lessons By Coach Schembechler
1581 Words | 7 PagesFahrenheit 451 Hero Quotes
872 Words | 4 PagesChapter 10x Leadership Summary
1867 Words | 8 PagesOrganizational Leaders: Annotated Bibliography
669 Words | 3 PagesLevels Of Leadership Book Review
690 Words | 3 PagesDonald Trump's Leadership Style
1924 Words | 8 PagesLeadership: A Critical Review Of Leadership Theories
1000 Words | 4 PagesThe Food Terminal Case Study
1372 Words | 6 PagesSelf Reflection Paper On Leadership
1818 Words | 8 PagesThe Leadership Theory: The Great Man Theory
1274 Words | 6 PagesDifference Between Trait And Behavioural Theories
1000 Words | 4 Pages