The Negative Effects Of The Orphan Train System

1046 Words5 Pages

The United States underwent significant industrial development in the mid-19th century, which fueled the growth of American industry and the expansion of the railroad system. With industrialization came the need for cheap labor to provide the manpower for the industrial expansion. Immigrants flowed into the country in record numbers in the early 20th century, with many living in overcrowded conditions, which resulted in young families falling apart. The New York Children's Aid Society (CAS) was established to care for the growing number of orphaned or abandoned children. Charles Loring Brace, the founder of the CAS, developed a system called "placing out," whereby children would be sent to families throughout the United States, Canada, and …show more content…

Many of these children went on to lead successful lives, with some even becoming prominent members of society. For these children, the Orphan Train system represented an opportunity for a better life and a brighter future. However, the Orphan Train system also had negative consequences. For many children, being placed out to families in different parts of the country meant losing touch with their cultural abor.and familial roots. Some children were forced to abandon their languages, religions, and customs in order to assimilate into their new families and communities. Others were subject to abuse and exploitation by their new caregivers, who often viewed them as little more than a source of cheap labor.
Some orphanages were built to care for the growing number of orphaned or abandoned children, but many children simply lived on the streets. Sensing the growing problem in New York City, Charles Loring Brace helped organize the New York Children's Aid Society (CAS) and the New York Foundling Hospital (Brace [2]). The founding of the CAS led Brace to develop a system called "placing out" whereby children would be sent to families throughout the United States, Canada, and Indian Territory. Between 1854 and 1930, some 200,000 orphans, homeless, and abandoned children were "placed out" from major East Coast …show more content…

Many children were sent to families who were not prepared to care for them or who were only interested in the child's labor. The Orphan Train also disrupted cultural ties by sending children to families who did not share their cultural heritage. This resulted in the loss of cultural identity for many children.
Furthermore, the Orphan Train highlighted the complexities of social welfare programs and their impact on marginalized communities. While the Orphan Train provided a solution for some children, it was not a solution for everyone. The system relied heavily on the willingness of people to take in children, which varied widely from region to region. Moreover, the placement of children was not always monitored closely, which meant that some children were placed in abusive situations.
The story of the Orphan Trains is an important part of the history of the "Progressive Era" in nineteenth- and twentieth-century America. The Orphan Trains were a response to a growing social problem, and they represented an attempt to find a solution to that problem. The Orphan Trains also represented a significant shift in the way that society thought about the welfare of children. Instead of being left to fend for themselves, children were now seen as deserving of care and

More about The Negative Effects Of The Orphan Train System

Open Document