Discuss why classical organizational theories are often referred to as the machine theories 25marks.
The classical writers thought of the organization in terms of its purpose and formal structure. They placed emphasis on the planning of work, the technical requirements of the organization, principles of management, and the assumption of rational and logical behavior. The main idea of the classical perspectives of an organization is that organizations are similar to machines. Hence, if you have a well built and well managed machine, then you will have a very productive and effective organization. The assumption is that each employee is part of a large machine, which is the organization. If one part fails then the entire machine fails.
There
…show more content…
He reflects that all processes could be examined into distinct tasks and that by scientific method it was possible to discover the one best way to perform each task. Each job was broken down into component parts, each part timed, and the parts rearranged into the most efficient method of working. After years of numerous experiments to determine best work methods, Taylor suggested the following four principles of scientific management. These principles are usually summarized as follows that is the development of a true science for each person’s work, the scientific selection, training and development of the workers, cooperation with the workers to ensure work is carried out in the prescribed way and lastly the division of work and responsibility between management and the …show more content…
According to Taylor, workers are not allowed to give suggestion but simply do what they are assigned to do. This is directly related to how machines work for instance a machine is commanded anything without agreement whether to perform the task or not.
The second classical theory that is often referred to as the machine theory is the bureaucracy theory by Max Weber. He believed that organizational management should focus on task proficiency and impersonal relationships. According to Weber, bureaucracy should be synonymous with order, consistency, reason, and reliability. In order to aspire to these traits, organizations need to have specific rules and emphasize impersonality. He noted that bureaucratic organization much have the following characteristics:
The Texas Bureaucracy does not have a CEO; the powers are spread among all the different bureau heads. (Slides 2 -20) Indicate how the agencies of the bureaucracy can be organized.
In Goodsell’s “A Case for Bureaucracy” Goodsell makes several valid points about the argument for and against Bureaucracy. Before reading I too would have assumed bureaucracy is a waste of time and that most bureaucrats are just lazy, rude and tend to hate their job. But now I've realized that Bureaucracy does succeed. People, Americans, tend to expect bureaucrats to be able to do anything. Even when the tasks seems impossible they expect the problem to be solved immediately which ultimately sets the bureaucrats up for failure from the beginning.
Frederick W. Taylor’s book, “The Principles of Scientific Management,” is a book where he described how the company could be more efficient by managing time, breaking tasks down into small parts, and using standardized tools. They wanted either a council-manager system or a commission plan which means a city’s government would be divided into several departments under the control of an expert commissioner. They also said that if a board of commissioner or a city manager that has the knowledge in city
Organizational culture is the foundation for organizations to strive and maintain success. Its structure of standards, include planning of human resources, management, health and safety, and the like. Organizations depend on these tactics to gain revenue, marketing strategies, and satisfaction of employees, and build relationships. Management should also be involved to create positive work environments, demonstrate great attitudes, and effective communication to its employees. The organizational culture at Walgreens is based on a variety of components within the organization.
1. Does this case support or contradict Weber’s arguments about the monolithic power position of bureaucracy in society? Both cases, How Kristen Died and The Columbia Accident supported everything Weber described. Weber wanted to maximize efficiency as well as eliminate favoritism. Weber’s overall reason for creating bureaucracy was so that a new administrative system could be created that would treat all humans equally.
They are in a generation where they accept the logic of organizational power in short being a conformist. Even though a bureaucratic system is obvious in our government today we are still not made aware of it specially its complications and its consequences. Up to this date we still experience complications in a bureaucratic government also in a bureaucracy mandated business. A bureaucratic government isn’t all negative it has its pro’s specially being a well-organized government as well as a well-organized business organization. but in this paper were going to talk moreover on the negative or the cons of a bureaucratic government.
Leadership Thought Prior to 1900 The earliest study of leadership thought would be the “Great Man Theory. This theory conceptualized leaders as a single “Great Man” who knew everything and influenced others to follow him. In leadership discourse, the Great Man theory—an assertion that certain individuals, certain men, are gifts from God placed on earth to provide the lightening needed to uplift human existence—is associated mainly with Thomas Carlyle (Spector, 2015, p.250). The focal-point of this theory is that leaders’ skills are inherent and set that them apart from those around them and that these traits enable them to assume roles of power and authority.
The German sociologist Max Weber [3] described many ideal-typical forms of public administration, government, and business. Weber agreed that bureaucracy constitutes the most efficient and rational way in which human activity can be organized, and that thus is indispensable to the modern
This style of leadership can be advantageous in highly regulated lines of business, and it can be an efficient management style in companies that don 't require much creativity or innovation from employees. Bureaucratic leadership is one of the most prevalent forms of management today. Weber 's Ideal Bureaucracy is characterized by the following: ~Hierarchical Organization ~Delineated Lines Of Authority With Fixed Areas Of Activity ~Action
Max Weber embellished the scientific management theory with his bureaucratic management theory largely focused on dividing organizations into hierarchies, establishing strong lines of authority and control. Weber suggests that organizations develop standard
The use of communication and unity are the key characteristics for a well- run organization. This reenterates the statement made by O’Toole and _____ involvement from managers enforces subordinates to move forward in a more suitable manner. Consequently organizational structure is necessary for a well implemented
During the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, Max Weber suggested a set of principles for an "ideal" bureaucracy for large-scale organizations of all types. Through firmly ordered hierarchy of supervision-management and subordination, written records of management, expert training, and official activity taking priority over other activities, the bureaucracy management was envisioned as a large machine for attaining organization’s goals in the most efficient manner possible. Weber developed 8 principles regarding his Bureaucracy Management Theory. Principles of Bureaucratic Management Theory 1.
Scientific management (also known as TAYLORISM) is an approach that was created in order to increase the productivity of workers and to ensure that there was no hostility between the workers and the management. It included a set of principles that were drawn up as a conclusive result of systematic study of the work in industries. The father of the ‘human relations’ approach is Elton Mayo (1880-1949). He is famous for his well-known “Hawthorne Studies”.
Employees feel appreciated when being rewarded for hard work. Drawbacks 1) Untested assumptions - Many of the assumptions made by classical writers were based not on scientific tests but on value judgments that expressed what they believed to be proper life-styles, moral codes, and attitudes toward success. 2) Human machinery-Classical theories leave the impression that the organization is a
Fayol developed the ’14 Principles of Management’ including; Initiative, giving employees the freedom and space to be creative and unique. Espri de Corps; where a business will promote uniqueness and unity within a workforce and Scalar Chain; where employees will always be made aware of their place and role within the business, ( Manktelow 2015). Whereas Taylor called his theory ‘Scientific Management’ and overly stressed the need for efficiency and restricted himself to the activity of production within a firm. It could even be said that Taylor had a micro-approach due to his restrictions within a factory and Fayol had a macro approach as his principles are adaptable to all fields of management. However, Taylor did conduct several experiments earlier on in his studies testing the task sytem within a firm focusing on all aspects of production such as the time needed, materials, labour and what was the quickest, most-effective way of producing the good in question, ( Taylor 1911)