Having a pit bull as a pet is like having any other pet, most pit bulls are warm, cuddly and very enthusiastic. They tend to provide security, comfort, and studies have shown that pit bulls have an extreme and extensive psychological and therapeutic effects on humans of every age. Yet in over 1,000 US cities and more than a dozen of counties within 36 states it is illegal to own this specific breed and they have a “breed-specific legislation”. Pit bulls were not born vicious or aggressive; they are raised to behave this way by irresponsible people. Although others state that studies have proven that pit bulls carry this aggression in their DNA. Scientist and CDC don’t agree. Are they as aggressive as the media states they are? Just like children, …show more content…
The New York Times wrote an article called “A Breed That Came up the Hard Way” were it stated that because of their unparalleled love and devotion for children they were commonly known as “The Nanny Dog” throughout the late 19th and early centuries. (Fletcher,W 1971). Meanwhile advocates for this breed claim this specific breed is the most abused, tortured and abandoned breed in the U.S. They’re often difficult to adopt out due to their stigma caused by the media. The ASPCA revealed that there is no evidence that shows how breed-specific laws make communities safer for people or companion animals, these laws are costly and extremely difficult to enforce. In Prince George’s County, Maryland it shows that it has spent more than $250,000 to enforce its ban on pit bulls and yet concluded “Public safety has not improved as a result in a study conducted in 2003. In 1990, Florida legislators banned any municipality from passing legislation that targets a particular breed. Miami Dade County was able to survive the ordinance passed in 1989 and predates the state law restricting this breed. (Fletcher,W
Click here to unlock this and over one million essaysShow More
Lynn uses the rulings of appellate courts to disprove the myth among pit bull advocates, that pit bulls are unidentifiable. The author begins the article by addressing the case of Ohio v. Anderson, and that it was decided that a dog owner of ordinary intelligence can determine if they own a dog commonly known as a pit bull. Moreover she addresses that pit bull advocates state that pit bulls are unidentifiable and that there is no such thing as a pit bull, and why this argument is not only invalid but misleading and harmful to society. Lynn states that adoption agencies have tried to create different names to signify variating subgenres of the breed in hopes to get pit bulls adopted.
The counterargument of this is that pitbulls are not aggressive just from dog fighting it is also the way the owners raise the dog breed, you could personally raise another dog breed besides a pitbull and they could lash out as well and be into dog fighting also, why should we blame the pitbulls. A pro stated from pro con says that pitbulls have the automatic nature to be aggressive and bite people. This is not true at all; there are very nice pitbulls out there who are not aggressive or bite at all. The counterargument to this statement is that, Pitbulls are not aggressive or dangerous they are just like and other dog breed if they are raised incorrectly or get raised into dog fighting they will be aggressive, but if you raise them properly and don't dog fight they are the most gentle breed of dogs out there. Some questions you may be asking could be, Should places have this pitbull restriction?
The proposition of pit bull bans continues to create passionate debates. Repeatedly, this issue of bans has been brought to the public’s attention through news outlets continuing to question the relevancy of such bans. Should we have breed-specific bans? Are pit bulls truly as bad as many portray them to be?
The supposed dangerous breed, the Pit bull, has been in the news, media, and been the center of dog attacks in america since the beginning of 20th century (Hiding the Truth, 2016). Labeled as killers, these dogs have a history that is unknown by many. The killer breed isn’t even a breed at all (Hiding the Truth, 2016). Pit bulls are a group of dogs with the same signature body that most Pit Bulls have. The American Kennel Club does not recognize Pit bulls a breed but rather as a grouping of dogs with similar features to that of an American Pit bull Terrier (Hiding the Truth, 2016).
“That reaction is familiar to many owners of pit bulls, whose aggressive reputation and association with dogfighting have made them one of the least adopted and most euthanized breeds in the U.S., according to shelter operators,” (Source D). Pits should be treated and looked at just like any other dog should, just because their history and background isn’t good doesn’t mean the dogs aren’t. People should do their own research on pitbulls and look into them before they go believing something off the internet that may not be
Literature Review Stereotypes Contrary to population beliefs in society, Pit Bulls not as aggressive than they are thought to be. According to testing by The National Canine Temperament Testing Association, Golden Retrievers, Poodles, Border Collies, English Setters, and a number of many other breeds are considered more likely to become aggressive than the breeds known as Pit Bulls. While the average score these dogs tested 82.4 percent, Pit Bulls scored a 86.5 percent (Frosek). In the same testings, Golden Retrievers came in with the score of 84.9 percent (Einhorn, 2011).
Across the nation animal shelters are flooded with unwanted or homeless dogs, 74% of them being pitbulls. It is strongly believed, by some, that animals are not born mean they are made mean. Many people like to jump to the conclusion that Pitbulls and similar dogs, are naturally mean, but in reality they make the best family pets if treated
Most people do not know pitbull is not a breed, but a generic term utilized to describe dogs with similar traits and the name “pitbull” originated from England. Some of these dogs include American pitbull Terriers, American Staffordshire, and English Bulldogs and they all tend to have unfair stereotypes such as they are vicious and only bread for fighting. These stereotypes cause pitbulls to be one of the most misunderstood types dogs in America. Centuries ago in England, dogs such as American Staffordshire and English
A 21 year old pregnant women was spun around and someone tried to attack her, a Pit Bull named Cash defended the women by biting the man, he got scared and he had run off. Cash was a friendly dog and has never bit anyone before, but he instinctively knew that the man was dangerous. Some people hear stories of Pit Bulls saving their owners life or them saving another animal, although they are reported in the media they are not heavily covered. They only like to cover the stories where Pit Bulls have attacked a person or where they have lashed out, therefore they are betrayed as an angry breed and “brainless killing machines”. Even though Pit bulls have the highest number of attacks on people than any other dog breed, that doesn 't mean that the
More than likely the people that get this type of dog would just train a different breed of dog such as german shepherds to do the same thing therefore, “banning pit bulls would make no progress”. http://www.opposingviews.com/i/should-pit-bulls-be-banned. “If it was determined that pit bulls were 5 times more likely to attack than any other dogs, that could mean that 5 out of 1 million pit bulls will attack in their lifetime instead of 1 out of 1 million. The point is the evidence that shows pit bulls are more likely to attack than other dogs is misinterpreted to mean that they are likely to attack”. http://www.opposingviews.com/i/should-pit-bulls-be-banned.
The American Temperament Test Society have concluded that, “American Pit Bull Terriers, the most popular breed used in dog fights, have a very high temperament passing rate of 82.6 percent. Even dogs commonly thought to be kind and gentle (and they are, with the right care) like Bearded Collies and Chihuahuas scored lower than American Pit Bull Terriers.” This supports that the breed is not inherently temperamental. “In the early 1900’s, this type of dog was the most popular family pet in America.” "Should Pit Bulls Be Banned - Hiding the Truth. " The dog gained the nickname “nanny dogs” because they were thought to be so loyal and caring of the children of the households.
There are many myths that people can’t support against this, however statistics do not lie. Pit bulls have caused 2235 counts of bodily harm and have 911 child victims (lifestyle9.org/top-10-most-dangerous-dog-breeds-that-you-should-stay-away-from/). Animal shelters run a temperament test which tests how aggressive a pit bull or any kind of dog is. only 20% of pit bulls have not passed this temperament test. Should people still consider them aggressive and dangerous?
Pit Bulls are ranked as one of the least aggressive dogs, according to the American Temperament Test Society. People judge pit bulls by how they look. They are muscular, have blocky heads and jaws so everyone thinks they are aggressive. There should not be a ban on pit bulls because dog and owner suffer,they can be trained well, and they are very affectionate. Pit bulls should not be torn away from their owners because the dog and owner suffer.
“Pit Bulls are beauty without vanity, strength without insolence, courage without ferocity, and all the virtues of a man without the vices”. (“A quote by George Gordon Byron.” ) People mistreat Pit Bulls and use them in illegal dog fights causing them to be aggressive. Most people think that since Pit Bulls have a strong, fierce appearance they are aggressive. One reason Pit Bulls are put out on the street is because some places have banned ownership of them.