ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Paying Student Athletes

1299 Words6 Pages

"[Student] Athletes are little more than indentured servants," according to Nancy Armour, USA Today sports columnist ("Paying"). Major issues get overlooked by Armour and others who support paying college athletes. The National College Athletic Association (NCAA) must push back against increasing pressure to pay student-athletes to preserve the principles of college sports, the college experience and uphold the teamwork of a school. In 1987, Southern Methodist University received the death penalty (Dobbs). Their scandalous history started in 1982 with Bobby Collins. He was the football head coach of SMU, who failed to recruit big-time players, so he started paying them to commit to SMU (Dobbs). The NCAA investigated the team in 1987 and …show more content…

The organization's legality is critiqued as a business. In O'Bannon v. National Collegiate Athletic Association, the NCAA compared to the Sherman Antitrust Act, which prohibits "[e]very contract, combination..., or conspiracy, in restraint of trade or commerce" ("O'Bannon"). This law points out how the NCAA restricts commerce to its players. Since it is a multibillion-dollar company, the players are the product because they are making money for the NCAA. When Nancy Armour called the athletes "little more than indentured servants," she is referring to the NCAA and the Sherman Antitrust Act ("Paying"). However, the significant difference between the NCAA and other businesses is that the NCAA is an organization for students. It pays students in the form of scholarships appropriate for student-athletes. College sports are at the preceding level to professional sports, so paying them as a professional would be inappropriate. Armour must remember that colleges have programs to help the student-athletes, such as career planning, academic help services, and student support centers. If a college athlete is struggling with any aspect of their day, they can use programs the college provides. The options benefit the players in ways that money can not because they provide immediate help and plan for future success out of

Show More
Related

  • Summary: NCAA Athletes Should Be Paid

    1433 Words  | 6 Pages

    NCAA athletes took the NCAA to court. Ed O’Bannon, a former NCAA athlete, led the charge for the student athletes. O’Bannon argued that the athletes are being taken advantage of because the schools make millions off of the players’ likeness, meaning the schools make money on selling a jersey, or bobble head of the players and the players deserve some of that money and it should be put into a trust fund for the player. Judge Claudia Wilkin decided the O’Bannon case and gave the athletes everything they wanted in 2014, but in a court of repeals the ruling was reversed and the college just had to pay for the full cost of attendance at the university and did not have to pay for the trust of each athlete (Nocera). This was a small step for college

    Read More

  • Summary Of Game On By Tom Farrey

    787 Words  | 4 Pages

    They neglect to treat the students with decency and the scholarships favor the NCAA membership

    Read More

  • Summary: College Athletes Should Be Paid

    358 Words  | 2 Pages

    The debate of whether not college athletes should be paid has been going on for a couple decades now. With college institutions gaining revenue from football bowl games and March Madness in basketball, Dr. Dennis Johnson thinks that “There now is a clamoring for compensating both football and basketball players beyond that of an athletic scholarship” (2012). On the other hand, Dr. John Acquaviva is satisfied with the current college system in which colleges provide athletic scholarships which reward a free college education in return for representing the university’s athletic program (2012). Dr. Johnson then follows up Dr. Aquaviva’s claim with his five selling points for the paying of college athletes and Dr. Aquaviva provides five points

    Read More

  • Analysis: Why College Athletes Have To Suffer

    494 Words  | 2 Pages

    Why Do College Athletes Have to Suffer? College athletics and the treatment of their athletes is an ongoing topic among many people. College athletes have to maintain amateur status to be eligible to play college sports. The National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA), the governing body for college sports, states that no college athlete can receive pay of any kind for the sport they play (Amateurism). College athletics have become big business over the past few decades with millions of dollars being poured into the NCAA, universities, and colleges.

    Read More

  • Summary Of Ryan Vanderford Pay For Play

    905 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ryan Vanderfords’ article published in the Southern California Interdisciplinary Law Journal explores this issue of whether or not college athletes should be paid beyond what they receive in scholarships. Vanderford is currently a law associate at a law firm in Los Angeles, California. He played sports throughout high school and college, so the author can relate to this topic. The payment of college athletes has become a more prominent issue in today’s society then it has been in the past. He argues that at major universities, student athletes help the school generate their revenue and therefore should be paid.

    Read More

  • College Athletes Should Be Paid

    668 Words  | 3 Pages

    The film “Schooled” makes many arguments to support the claim that the NCAA is taking advantage of college athletes. One way the NCAA has the ability to control these athletes is by giving these student athletes the title of amateurs. This title of amateur says that the athletes will be playing for the love of the game and not for money. This also means that the athletes will be offered something priceless in exchange for their playing abilities, which is a free education. During this time as an athlete these students are not able to persue any other kind of income since all of their time is taken up by participating in their sport and followed by school.

    Read More

  • Should College Athletes Be Paid Essay

    1297 Words  | 6 Pages

    When it comes down to it, the NCAA’s money-makers are their college athletes. The real question is should the NCAA’s student-athletes be paid for their time as “employees of the school” or continue to only be referred to as only a student. College

    Read More

  • Should Student Athletes Be Paid Essay

    451 Words  | 2 Pages

    Over time, college sports evolved into a multi-billion dollar industry, with universities and the NCAA reaping significant financial gains from ticket sales, sponsorships, and merchandise. Despite this, student athletes are still considered amateur participants, with the NCAA maintaining strict rules against paying athletes for their participation. This has led to a growing movement advocating for the recognition of student athletes as employees, as they are essential to the success of college sports. The legal and ethical arguments surrounding the employee status of student athletes are complex and

    Read More

  • Should College Athletes Be Paid Essay

    964 Words  | 4 Pages

    Athletes work hard around the clock to excel in their sport in the hopes of receiving a scholarship. However, many of these athletes pay the price with the extreme demands they place on themselves. College athletes are beginning to push to receive financial compensation from the NCAA because of their efforts. While the NCAA argues against it, student-athletes at the collegiate level should receive compensation because playing a D1 sport requires immense amounts of time, athletes are constantly taken advantage of by the NCAA, and scholarships alone are not sufficient to support the athletes. Playing a sport in college undoubtedly requires substantial time and effort that could have been better spent doing schoolwork.

    Read More

  • Why College Athletes Should Not Be Paid

    1706 Words  | 7 Pages

    The NCAA is the National Collegiate Athletics Association and they decide all of the rules and regulations that are to be placed and abided by their athletes. Most athletic scholarships come from NCAA sanctioned schools and sports. The NCAA has major restrictions on how student athletes can obtain money and income. They have just recently changed rules in regards to endorsement deals, but what hasn't been changed is the way that student athletes do not get paid for playing their sport.

    Read More

  • The Negative Effects Of Lack Of Pay Of College Athletes

    1091 Words  | 5 Pages

    The NCAA (National Collegiate Athletic Association) considers college athletes to be amateur athletes, which means that they are not allowed to be paid by schools. Many people believe that college students and especially college athletes are overworked, which begs the question, how does the lack of payment of college athletes affect their well-being? College athletes are not allowed to be paid by their schools or depending on the state they are in, by others despite the amount of effort and profit they bring to the schools. This is unfair to the athletes because they have the stresses of being an athlete without any of the rewards of being an athlete. College athletes are negatively affected by their lack of payment because they aren’t fairly

    Read More

  • Should College Athletes Be Paid Essay

    1579 Words  | 7 Pages

    College athletics is a core part of society, especially the colleges. Colleges themselves make a lot of money off of their college athletes, however, they do not treat them with the same respect. College athletes face terrible obstacles in their life balancing both their athletics and academic life. These problems lead to the debate over whether or not college athletes should be paid, to lessen the burden of college life. Throughout time, there has been an ongoing debate about whether or not college athletes should be paid to play.

    Read More

  • College Athletes Should Be Paid Analysis

    1317 Words  | 6 Pages

    It includes only those funds that end up in the NCAA 's bank account.” The FCAA being the organization that would collect and distribute the capital. This research paper described why college athletes should be paid. They make personal sacrifices, and take risks in order to produce revenue for their schools.

    Read More

  • College Athletes Rhetorical Analysis

    1103 Words  | 5 Pages

    College sports is one of the best-known entertainments around the world. But for the athletes, they are students first then athletes second. For college student-athletes, there are a variety of scholarships and grants to help pay for college or college debt. However, some critics say that student-athletes should be paid a salary like pro athletes would, with help from scholarships or grants. The authors of, College Athletes are being Educated, not Exploited, Val Ackerman and Larry Scott, argue that student-athletes are already paid by free education and other necessities.

    Read More

  • Annotated Bibliography: Should College Athletes Be Paid

    904 Words  | 4 Pages

    The NCAA says that they don’t want to pay college athletes because of their scholarships. As the money keeps flowing more and more each and every year, it comes with more arguments about the athletes getting the money that they deserve. Sounds as if college athletes are blindly signing a sheet of paper and the NCAA has an evil smirk saying “You have no idea what you’ve gotten yourself into”. A court case had also gone down about a young college athlete and a car dealership. The dealership was using the athletes to make more sales with his cars and was doing behind the athletes back without

    Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Paying Student Athletes

Open Document