John Marshall's Three Main Court Cases
John Marshall had a significant impact on strengthening the national government during his term as Chief Justice from 1800-1830. Marshall achieved this goal by strengthening the power of the Supreme Court in three main court cases. In Marbury v. Madison Marshall established the practice of judicial review, then in McCulloch v. Maryland he weakened the central government and Gibbons v. Ogden provided the federal government with the ability to regulate interstate commerce.
Marbury v. Madison (1803) was a court case that began the practice of judicial review. This case started because the night before President John Adams term ended, he appointed 42 justices of the peace. One of these justices that were appointed was William Marbury. The
…show more content…
Maryland (1819) is a huge court in defining federalism, which is a balance of power between the national government and the state government. In 1816, Congress passed a law to incorporate the National Bank. They set first bank was set up in Philadelphia, then decided to set one up in Maryland which is led by James William McCulloch. The state Maryland was upset by this law, so they voted to pass a law which would tax all bank business not done with state banks, which take people who lived in Maryland but did business with banks in other states. Maryland passed this law due to what they believed was allowed under the tenth amendment which states if it is not in the constitution, it is up the states to make a decision. Maryland passed this law to tax the federal bank. McCulloch, the President of the bank refused to pay the tax. The State of Maryland sued McCulloch, and the Supreme Court accepted the case. In the opinion written by Chief Justice Marshall, the Court ruled that the Bank of the United States was constitutional and that the Maryland tax was not. The Supreme Court said that the Bank of the United States has every right due to the Necessary and Proper Clause of Article I, Section 8 which stated that Congress can pass laws that they consider “necessary and proper”. In addition, the Supreme Court also stated Maryland lacked the power to tax the Bank due to the Supremacy Clause of Article VI of the
Case Study: Mcculloch Vs. Maryland
643 Words | 3 PagesIt was determined that “the Congress of the United States is granted for certain implied powers by the Constitution that are implemented in order to ensure for the proper function of the Federal Government. "3In relevance to the states, it was determined that “States cannot impose on the powers granted by the Constitution to the Federal Government by any action. "3 In the case of McCulloch vs Maryland,this included the act of imposing a state bank tax on a national bank. Federalism This case tells us that the relationship between federal and state government is limited.
Mcculloch Vs. Maryland Case Analysis
578 Words | 3 PagesMaryland, happened in 1819. In this case the state of Maryland enacted a tax that would force the United States Bank in Maryland to pay taxes to the state. McCulloch, a cashier for the Baltimore, Maryland Bank, was sued for not complying with the Maryland state tax. This cause a issue because people began to ask if the Congress had the power to establish a National Bank under the constitution. The case end in the Supreme Court and they decided that according to Article 1, Section 8 of the Constitution the Congress had the power to create the BUS and that the state of Maryland did not had the power to tax the
Why Is Mcculloch Vs Maryland Important
839 Words | 4 PagesNational supremacy McCulloch v. Maryland was a supreme court case held back in 1819 concerning the topic of national bank and taxation. This court was like many more that came before it and after it as it was the national government and states government arguing in front of the supreme court. The bank was a national bank created in Maryland being the second ever created national bank. The case all took course after Maryland the state questioned the power of Congress being able to create a national bank. Then the state of Maryland imposed a tax on all branches of bank not “chartered by the legislature.”
Why Is Muculloch Vs Maryland Important
1477 Words | 6 PagesState of Maryland decided to impose a tax to exempt every bank in Maryland expect the Bank of the US. James Muculloch was the cashier of the Baltimore branch. When the bank’s Baltimore branch refused to pay the tax,Maryland sued James Muculloch. The Bank’s Baltimore branch refused to pay the annual tax of $15,000 in top of this was a $500 penalty for any state that violated the statute. McCulloch was convicted by a Maryland court of violating the tax statute because he refused to pay and was fined $2,500.
How Did John Marshall Dominate The Supreme Court
484 Words | 2 PagesThe longest serving Chief Justice in Supreme Court history, Marshall dominated the Court for over three decades and played a major role in the improvement of the American legal system (Mod. 3b). John Marshall was a chief for 34 years leading the supreme court. Chief John Marshall performed a key role in the power of the federal and state governments during the mid-nineteenth century. Marshall gave it the strength and weight of the third, equivalent branch of government. Marshall's Court formed the new country with its understanding of the Constitution and the setting up of various early appropriate points of reference that was better describe, the part and size of the federal government.
How Did John Adams End His Presidency?
573 Words | 3 PagesWhat was President John Adams goal before he ended his presidency? The Organic Act, this act was perfect it was to ensure that though John Adams was not going to be president anymore he would still have a majority of federalist become dominate and have federalist ideologies pretty much mandate the federal judiciary. He took action and choose forty-two justices of the peace and sixteen circuit court justices for the District of Columbia, but his plan later failed after the documents were not delivered on time and new president Thomas Jefferson choose not to submit the completed documents. William Marbury one of the recipients that was chosen by John Adams, refuse to accept Jefferson’s decision and took matters into his own hands. The facts of the case were vividly sought out, Marbury was to be appointed as justice of peace and his paperwork was completed and ready to be submitted before he could take office.
John Marshall's Supreme Court Cases
252 Words | 2 PagesJohn Marshall’s Supreme Court hearings had a positive effect on the United States. From court cases like McCulloch v. Maryland, declared that the federal courts could decide if state laws were unconstitutional. The McCulloch v. Maryland trial went to the supreme court because Maryland had put a tax in place that too 2% of all assets of the bank or a flat rate of $30,000. John Marshall saw this tax as unconstitutional for the simple fact that people were being denied their property under the state legislature. From the Gibbons v. Ogden case, congress’s power over interstate commerce was strengthened.
How Did John Marshall Impact On American History
646 Words | 3 PagesHe expanded the power of the Supreme Court by declaring that the Constitution is the supreme law of the land, and that the Supreme Court Justices were the final deciders. In the Marbury vs. Madison case, Marshall wrote "It is emphatically the province and duty of the judicial department to say what the law is.” John Marshall was clearly in favor of judicial power, and believed that the Supreme Court should have the final say in cases involving an interpretation of the Constitution. While establishing this, he kept the separation of powers in mind, as he wanted equal representation among the Judicial, Executive, and Legislative branches. In the Marbury vs. Madison, John Marshall declared that the Judicial Branch could not force Madison to deliver the commission.
Marbury Vs Madison Case Summary
556 Words | 3 PagesIn Marbury v. Madison (1803) it was announced by the Supreme Court for the very first time, that if an act was deemed inconsistent with the constitution then the court was allowed to declare the act void. Thomas Jefferson’s secretary of state, James Madison, denied William Marbury of his commission. President John Adams appointed William Marbury the justice of peace for the District of Columbia during his last day in office. Madison denied Marbury of this commission because he believed that because it was not issued before the termination of Adams presidency, that it was invalid. Marbury himself started a petition, along with three others who were in a similar situation.
Chief Justice John Marshall: The Balance Of Power In The United States
504 Words | 3 PagesThe founding father’s idea when they created the Constitution was to prevent a centralized government. As expressed by James Madison in Federalist No. 51, they believe that the power surrendered by people would be divided between the federal and state governments, creating balance of power that would enable both governments to control each other. Over time, the balance of power between the federal and state governments has shifted in favor of the federal government and this has taken place with the help of the Constitution and by enactments of Congress. The role that Chief Justice John Marshall played in defining the power of the federal and state governments during the early 19th century is important to mention because he shaped the nation.
Colonial America Pros And Cons
1120 Words | 5 PagesMcCulloch v. Maryland, Cohen v. Virginia, and Gibbons v. Ogden all served great significance to judicial nationalism due to their American legal system impact. The court case of McCulloch v. Maryland was caused due to the dispute between Maryland and the federal government regarding the constitutionality of a tax on the Bank of the United States (Nationalism and Sectionalism 1808-1826 lecture). It was determined that the creation of a national bank was an implied power, through the Necessary and Proper Clause. With this expression of power, the state of Maryland was unable to interfere, resulting in the affirmed supremacy of federal laws over state powers (Nationalism and Sectionalism 1808-1826 lecture). The McCulloch v. Maryland court case allowed for the priniciple of implied powers to settle in, extending the meaning of federal authority within the United States.
Violation Of The Supreme Court Case Of John Marshall
1209 Words | 5 PagesAlthough he found that the petitioners were in fact entitled to their commissions, he believed that the Constitution did not give the Supreme Court the power needed to issue writs of mandamus. Marshall ruled that Marbury had been appropriately appointed in accordance with the procedures established by law and thereby had a right to a writ of mandamus. The Chief Justice concluded that Section 13 of the Judiciary Act of 1789 was unconstitutional as Section 13 of the act was inconsistent with the Constitution and consequently unacceptable. Original jurisdiction was the only jurisdictional issue oversaw by the Constitution. Article III of the Constitution applied only to cases "affecting ambassadors, other public ministers and consuls" and to litigation "in which the state shall be party (History.com).
Power Of The Federal Government In The 19th Century
674 Words | 3 PagesThe Supreme Court case McCulloch v Maryland originally originated in Maryland when the Maryland legislature decided to levy a tax on all branches of the banks. It was aimed to destroy the Baltimore branch of the Bank of the United States. James McCulloch was a cashier at the Baltimore branch. He was issuing bank notes without complying with the Maryland law. Maryland had sued McCulloch for refusing to pay the taxes under the Maryland statute.
Justice Thurgood Marshall Analysis
1324 Words | 6 PagesJustice Thurgood Marshall Response Justice Thurgood Marshall said in his “Reflections on the Bicentennial of the United States Constitution”, “I do not believe the meaning of the Constitution was forever ‘fixed’ at the Philadelphia Convention. Nor do I find the wisdom, foresight, and sense of justice exhibited by the framers particularly profound. To the contrary, the government they devised was defective from the start, requiring several amendments, a civil war, and momentous social transformation to attain the system of constitutional government and its respect for the individual freedoms and human rights, that we hold as fundamental as today” (Marshall). In this passage of his essay, Judge Marshall is critical of the government that is
Why The Judicial Branch Is The Most Powerful
478 Words | 2 PagesMadison court case that took place in 1803. The law that was declared by the Supreme Court at this hearing was that a court has the power to declare an act of Congress void if it goes against the Constitution. This case took place because President John Adams had appointed William Marbury as justice of the peace in the District of Columbia, and the new president, Thomas Jefferson, did not agree with this decision. William Marbury was not appointed by the normal regulation, which was that the Secretary of State, James Madison, needed to make a notice of the appointment. James Madison did not follow through and make a notice of Marbury’s appointment; therefore, he sued James Madison, which was where the Supreme Court came in place.
More about John Marshall's Three Main Court Cases
Case Study: Mcculloch Vs. Maryland
643 Words | 3 PagesMcculloch Vs. Maryland Case Analysis
578 Words | 3 PagesWhy Is Mcculloch Vs Maryland Important
839 Words | 4 PagesWhy Is Muculloch Vs Maryland Important
1477 Words | 6 PagesHow Did John Marshall Dominate The Supreme Court
484 Words | 2 PagesHow Did John Adams End His Presidency?
573 Words | 3 PagesJohn Marshall's Supreme Court Cases
252 Words | 2 PagesHow Did John Marshall Impact On American History
646 Words | 3 PagesMarbury Vs Madison Case Summary
556 Words | 3 PagesChief Justice John Marshall: The Balance Of Power In The United States
504 Words | 3 PagesColonial America Pros And Cons
1120 Words | 5 PagesViolation Of The Supreme Court Case Of John Marshall
1209 Words | 5 PagesPower Of The Federal Government In The 19th Century
674 Words | 3 PagesJustice Thurgood Marshall Analysis
1324 Words | 6 PagesWhy The Judicial Branch Is The Most Powerful
478 Words | 2 Pages