ipl-logo

Should Southern States Have The Right To Secede Dbq Essay

775 Words4 Pages

Even though the South was a part of the Union, and was bound by a contract, the South had every right to secede from the Union. Many states of the North has broken the Constitution, therefore the agreement that keeps the Southern states from seceding is broken. The North has also gained overwhelming power over the South in Congress, therefore the Southern states are not equally represented in the Union anymore. According to the tenth Amendment, the rights that are not listed in the Constitution are reserved for the states, and the right to secede is not in the Constitution. Therefore the Southern states should have been allowed to secede from the union as the government of the Union did not protect some of their given rights. First of all, the Southern states had the right to secede because the North had too much power over them. “In all the non-slave-holding States…the people have formed themselves into a great sectional party…based upon an unnatural feeling of hostility to these Southern States” (Document I). Based on this quote, the Northern states started to believe in the abolitionist movement too much; so much that they started to consider the slave states as their enemies. As shown in the quote “By consolidating their strength, they have placed the slave-holding states …show more content…

As stated in the tenth Amendment, the south has the right to secede if seceding was not mentioned in the Constitution, which it was not. In addition, the agreement between the states were broken, allowing the states to secede. The Northern states also gained too much power over the Southern states, causing the South to become a minority in the congress, therefore their rights and opinions were not represented. The Northern states were causing the government to become destructive of the southern rights, such as their right to gain their slaves back, and therefore the Southern states had the right to secede from the

Show More
Related

  • How Did Texas Fight In The Civil War

    352 Words  | 2 Pages

    “This is a union of equal states, and no state can force another state either to remain in it or withdraw from it. ”(C) I hold that… the Union of these States is perpetual… No state upon its own mere motion, can lawfully get out of the Union. The argument between whether a state could leave the US without permission was one of the main reasons that the Civil War began.

    Read More

  • Southern States Rights Dbq Essay

    136 Words  | 1 Pages

    While the North tried to stop the South from withdrawing their spot in the Union, the North also denied the Southern states rights. Sectional groups assembled in the North regarding the “unnatural feeling and hostility” to slavery in the South. “ By consolidating their strength, they have placed the strength... no avail in protecting Southern rights (Document I). The Northerners believed that slavery is not right, and also that “the demand of African slavery throughout the confederacy” is unheard of.

    Read More

  • Southern Secession Dbq

    266 Words  | 2 Pages

    In this paper there has been a discussion of the legislation and the tensions preceding the southern Secession. Based on this discussing it can be concluded that the tensions, which culminated with the Civil War, were present many decades before the secession itself. Even threats of Civil war and secession were present much prior to this particular conflict. 
This paper has also concluded that the threat of Lincoln was real to the South, because of the Republican party’s very distinct foundation as an anti-slavery party. Slavery was a soft spot in the South because of the substantial value slaves had.

    Read More

  • Lincoln First Inaugural Address Analysis

    657 Words  | 3 Pages

    It would be more than difficult not to read Abraham Lincoln’s First Inaugural Address without some sense of pride or honor for one’s own country. He brings about a call to civility among all citizens striving for unity and harmony with one another. Lincoln understood the dilemma that slavery became for not only the Northerners attempting to abolish the practice entirely, but also for the Southerners perpetuating it in the first place. The fact that there was a faction rising in favor of slavery on a scale that would divide the country indefinitely and that Lincoln foresaw this danger demonstrates the level of prudence he was able to acquire up until his presidency. In this address, Lincoln stressed the importance of the nation staying unified and true to the principles set by

    Read More

  • Dred Scott Decision Of 1857: The Lincoln-Douglas Debates Of 1860

    1715 Words  | 7 Pages

    This led to a secession crisis. By February 1861, six more states from the South seceded. These seven seceded states went on to form the Confederate States of America. The president at the time, James Buchanan, refused to take action to stop them claiming that it was not up to the government to preserve the Union, because it is based on public opinion and can never be strengthened by the blood of its people shed in a war. The new president waiting to take his term in office, Abraham Lincoln, obviously very much disagreed with this statement and denied the fact that states can secede.

    Read More

  • Lincoln And Douglass Debate Analysis

    534 Words  | 3 Pages

    The quote shows the only way out for safety or protection is to secede from the state. The southern states seceded because of Abraham Lincoln 's election, which convinced that the slaves way of life based on slavery was threatened. Seceding from the state brought more intentions for the war to happen easily because states were separated and divided which brought issues in the union and the confederate states. Concerning the civil war, the north and the south used political strategies such as the anaconda plan and cotton to win the war.

    Read More

  • Secession Was A Failure In Democracy

    251 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the months following the election of Abraham Lincoln as President of the United States, seven southern states seceded from the Union and formed the Confederate States of America. This was done primarily as a response to Lincoln’s election, as Lincoln did not support the institution of slavery, a crucial aspect of Southern society. Secession from the United States meant that these states would form a separate country from the United States with its own government and military. Some have speculated that secession was failure in democracy, that democracy should have prevented such a large part of the United States to be so unhappy with its government that it would form a new country. However, it was the American system of democracy that laid

    Read More

  • Essay On North And South Secession

    798 Words  | 4 Pages

    So is secession of the states right? Is this what needs to be done in order to find some peace between the states? After looking at how the North and South are becoming more and more diverse and how much strife there is between the two territories, Yes, I do believe that secession needs to take place in order for there to be some settlement in the disagreements taking place. As one can see, all the states are not going to be able to come to one conclusion about the use of slaves, so if the states can form their own government aside from the union, it can become a

    Read More

  • Why Did The South Want To Secede Essay

    682 Words  | 3 Pages

    The South has had many problems but I believe many of them could have been solved faster if we were allowed to secede. The North stopped us from seceding though, so we will never know. Secession has been around for centuries but when the South tried to do it, it was seen as unconstitutional. The South had many good reasons to secede. For example, it would have benefited both the North and the South, it would have stopped the Civil War from happening, and even though many people say the South wasn’t at a place to make its own decisions I think we would have been fine.

    Read More

  • How Did Slavery Cause Secession

    1451 Words  | 6 Pages

    ‘Slavery was the root cause of secession’. ‘November 6 1860, Lincoln was elected president of America which resulted in panic emerging in the South’ . The election of Lincoln as president who was a Republican leader meant that ideologies, movements and values from the North would be implemented in the South which meant the abolition of slavery. Slavery was a huge characteristic of the South as the economy; politics; social status and psychological mind-sets were influenced by the process of slavery. The southern white population then derived the idea of secession which meant the South would gain independence from Northern aggression .

    Read More

  • The Civil War: Why Did Texans Fight?

    630 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Texas State Gazette wrote, “ This is a Union of equal states, and no state can force another state either to remain in it or to withdraw from it.” (Document C) This document states that every state has equal rights, and that no state has more power than another state. Also from Document C, Abraham Lincoln stated, “No state upon its own mere motion, can lawfully get out of the Union.” What Abraham Lincoln meant by this is that no state can just say they are out of the Union.

    Read More

  • The South Seceded From The Union In Uncle Tom's Cabin

    757 Words  | 4 Pages

    The South seceded from the Union because of Abraham Lincoln being elected President, Harriet Beecher Stowe writing Uncle Tom’s Cabin, abolitionists were becoming more vocal, and the differences between the Northern and Southern economies being so diverse. One reason the South seceded from the Union was that Abraham Lincoln was elected president. Abraham Lincoln was part of the Republican Party, people who supported the abolitionist movement. The Southerners did not

    Read More

  • Why Did Texas Fight In The Civil War Dbq

    432 Words  | 2 Pages

    This was called state’s rights which were the rights withheld by a state rather than the federal government. Even though most of them did believe they had the right to withdraw, Abraham Lincoln didn’t agree. He said during his inauguration,“I hold that the Union of these states is perpetual. No state upon its own mere motion, can lawfully get out of the Union”. (Doc C)

    Read More

  • Dbq Civil Rights Act Of 1860

    1024 Words  | 5 Pages

    “The lack of… nationality, I believe, is one of the great evils of the times…” Senator John Sherman stated on February 10, 1863. The United States had been split into sections from the beginning, and it created a lack of unity and togetherness. In Document A, the reader can acquire from the reading that South Carolina (and later many other states) seceded from the Union because of states’ rights. Document A states that an amendment (specifically the

    Read More

  • Southern Nationalism In The Civil War

    1668 Words  | 7 Pages

    The Civil War resulted due to the division and the gradual collapse of the Union between the two sections. It can be argued that both the North and South were distinct regions. However, both regions initially displayed nationalism in various ways at the beginning of the Civil War. Southern nationalism allowed the Confederates to justify their secession and independence. The formation of the Confederacy and the established Confederate Constitution in February 1861, nationalism validated their status as an independent country.

    Read More

More about Should Southern States Have The Right To Secede Dbq Essay

Open Document